jallenmorris wrote:

Are you sure the exchange rate cancels itself out?

If I convert $100 into GBP, lets say I then have £200. If the % rate is 5%, then the first time, I get charged $5US, so I have $95 to convert and then I have £190. In the exchange back, the stem doesn't tell us the % is based upon one certain form of currency, so it seems that 5% would be levied upon the £190 as well, thus actually giving us £180.50 to exchange back into dollars. And if the exchange rate is 2:1 £:$, then £180.50 becomes $90.25. It doesn't cancel itself out. I'm not sure the wording of the question is exactly clear on how the commission % is calculated.

Either way you need to know the % commission otherwise in the exchange from £ back to $, you don't know how much is left after the first exchange, so you don't know how much is commission on the second exchange from £ to $.

We don't need exchange rate but we need commision %

1000 $

convert $ to £

= 1000 *x*

= first converted amount received + first commision paid

= 1000*x (1-y/100)+ 1000*x*y/1000

reconvert amount 1000*x (1-y/100) £ to $ ( commision levied is y)

= second converted amount received+ second commision paid

=

[1000*x (1-y/100) ] *1/x(exchange rate) * (1-y/100) + [1000*x (1-y/100) ] *1/x * y/100

second converted amount received

= 1000 * (1-y/100) ^2
_________________

Your attitude determines your altitude

Smiling wins more friends than frowning