A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor : GMAT Problem Solving (PS) - Page 2
Check GMAT Club App Tracker for the Latest School Decision Releases http://gmatclub.com/AppTrack

 It is currently 09 Dec 2016, 15:08

### GMAT Club Daily Prep

#### Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

# Events & Promotions

###### Events & Promotions in June
Open Detailed Calendar

# A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor

Author Message
TAGS:

### Hide Tags

Current Student
Joined: 19 Nov 2012
Posts: 205
Concentration: Marketing, Social Entrepreneurship
GMAT 1: 750 Q47 V47
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 49 [0], given: 44

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

25 Oct 2013, 09:29
I arrived at D as well.

Quick question:

Obviously, the order is important here, which is why we do not account for repetitions.

How would the wording of the question change if order did not matter, which would lead us to divide D by n!?
Intern
Joined: 12 Dec 2012
Posts: 33
GMAT 1: Q V
GMAT 2: 660 Q48 V33
GMAT 3: 740 Q49 V41
GPA: 3.74
Followers: 10

Kudos [?]: 105 [0], given: 19

Re: Combination or Permutation: Can't make up my mind :) [#permalink]

### Show Tags

06 Nov 2013, 23:00
Bunuel wrote:
rvthryet wrote:
Small doubt.. Why should this not be 2C1 x 8C5??

I just can't seem to understand how is my thinking flawed there, although it is quite obvious that it is

Imagen different situation 4 players, we should choose 1 for defense and 1 for forward. (no restrictions).

The way you are doing you'll get 4C2=6. But look at the real case.

ABCD (players):

Defence - Forward
A B
A C
A D

B A
B C
B D

C A
C B
C D

D A
D B
D C

Total 12 possibilities 4C1*3C1=4*3=12. You just narrowed possible ways of selection.

In original question we are not choosing 5 people from 8, but we are choosing 2 from 8, than 2 from 6, than 1 from 4 (well and before we chose 1 from 2 as goalkeeper). And this is more ways of selection than 8C5 as you can see in the example.

Bunuel - I see how you arrived at D, but initially when I solved this problem I adjusted it because the order in which we make these selections shouldn't matter. Right?

We are making a team of 6 - so we need to select : 1GK (2C1), 2 Midfielders (8C2), 2 Defenders (6C2), 1 Forward (4C1) = 3360 (but aren't we over counting here, since it doesn't matter what order we make these selections in? So shouldn't we divide this by 4! to give us 140 different groupings?

I made the mistake of NOT doing this on previous 'different grouping' questions and find it quite confusing. If you can explain when do adjust / when not to, it would be helpful!

Cheers
Intern
Joined: 01 May 2013
Posts: 1
Schools: Stanford '16 (S)
GMAT 1: 760 Q50 V44
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 0 [0], given: 1

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

16 Nov 2013, 07:34
You can alternatively come to the same conclusion using another approach:

First part - main team. There are 8 options (10 teammates excluding 2 goalkeepers). It means 8! combinations. But there are repeating elements. 2 defenders - that is 2!, 2 midfield - 2!, and 3 will not be chosen and order inside of this unlucky team is also irrelevant, thereby 3!.

So we've got: 8! / (2!*2!*3!)

Second part is pretty easier - goalkeepers. There are two of them, one is to be chosen - 2 options.

Now we have: 2*8! / (2!*2!*3!)
Intern
Joined: 10 Dec 2013
Posts: 20
Location: India
Concentration: Technology, Strategy
Schools: ISB '16 (S)
GMAT 1: 710 Q48 V38
GPA: 3.9
WE: Consulting (Consulting)
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 7 [0], given: 7

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

28 Jan 2014, 10:40
Why cant we solve this by simple number theory?? If we use that approach then the answer changes
first we will have the 2 goalies, then 8 choices for first defender, then 7 choices for second defender and so on and so forth.
This would give us the answer as 2*8*7*6*5*4 = 13440

I know this is wrong answer but can someone please help me understand why this approach is wrong. Just because we are considering each position at a time?
Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 35932
Followers: 6860

Kudos [?]: 90098 [0], given: 10413

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

29 Jan 2014, 07:45
Rohan_Kanungo wrote:
Why cant we solve this by simple number theory?? If we use that approach then the answer changes
first we will have the 2 goalies, then 8 choices for first defender, then 7 choices for second defender and so on and so forth.
This would give us the answer as 2*(8*7)*(6*5)*4 = 13440

I know this is wrong answer but can someone please help me understand why this approach is wrong. Just because we are considering each position at a time?

The point is that the number of ways to select 2 out of 8 is NOT 8*7=56 it's $$C^2_8=28$$ and the number of ways to select 2 out of 6 is NOT 6*5=30 it's $$C^2_6=15$$.

Hope it's clear.
_________________
Manager
Joined: 14 Nov 2011
Posts: 149
Location: United States
Concentration: General Management, Entrepreneurship
GPA: 3.61
WE: Consulting (Manufacturing)
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 13 [0], given: 103

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

09 Jun 2014, 06:48
Bunuel wrote:
Rohan_Kanungo wrote:
Why cant we solve this by simple number theory?? If we use that approach then the answer changes
first we will have the 2 goalies, then 8 choices for first defender, then 7 choices for second defender and so on and so forth.
This would give us the answer as 2*(8*7)*(6*5)*4 = 13440

I know this is wrong answer but can someone please help me understand why this approach is wrong. Just because we are considering each position at a time?

The point is that the number of ways to select 2 out of 8 is NOT 8*7=56 it's $$C^2_8=28$$ and the number of ways to select 2 out of 6 is NOT 6*5=30 it's $$C^2_6=15$$.

Hope it's clear.

Hi Bunnel,

In this question why we not dividing by 3! ?

2c1 * {(8c2*6c2*4c1)/3!}

and why do we do so in the below question?

The Carson family will purchase three used cars. There are two models of cars available, Model A and Model B, each of which is available in four colors: blue, black, red, and green. How many different combinations of three cars can the Carsons select if all the cars are to be different colors?

a) 24
b) 32
c) 48
d) 60
e) 192
Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 35932
Followers: 6860

Kudos [?]: 90098 [0], given: 10413

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

09 Jun 2014, 08:20
cumulonimbus wrote:
Bunuel wrote:
Rohan_Kanungo wrote:
Why cant we solve this by simple number theory?? If we use that approach then the answer changes
first we will have the 2 goalies, then 8 choices for first defender, then 7 choices for second defender and so on and so forth.
This would give us the answer as 2*(8*7)*(6*5)*4 = 13440

I know this is wrong answer but can someone please help me understand why this approach is wrong. Just because we are considering each position at a time?

The point is that the number of ways to select 2 out of 8 is NOT 8*7=56 it's $$C^2_8=28$$ and the number of ways to select 2 out of 6 is NOT 6*5=30 it's $$C^2_6=15$$.

Hope it's clear.

Hi Bunnel,

In this question why we not dividing by 3! ?

2c1 * {(8c2*6c2*4c1)/3!}

and why do we do so in the below question?

The Carson family will purchase three used cars. There are two models of cars available, Model A and Model B, each of which is available in four colors: blue, black, red, and green. How many different combinations of three cars can the Carsons select if all the cars are to be different colors?

a) 24
b) 32
c) 48
d) 60
e) 192

Because for this case the order of the selection matters: A = defense, B = midfield, C = forward is different from B = defense, A = midfield, C = forward, ... Therefore here we don't need factorial correction. While for "Carson family" problem Blue A/Black A/Red A is the same as Black A/Red A/Blue A...

Hope it's clear.

P.S. You can solve the second question with another approach described here: the-carson-family-will-purchase-three-used-cars-there-are-128876.html#p1056566
_________________
Manager
Joined: 30 Mar 2013
Posts: 137
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 39 [0], given: 196

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

23 Sep 2014, 07:42
amkabdul wrote:
Guys... since we have 6 positions in the field which are to be filled with 10 players.

Look at this: Filling the goal keeper position in 2 ways.
Next: the rest of the 5 positions are to be filled with 8 players and each player at a different position would be 8p5 But since we have 2 positions each for the defence and mid. divide it with 2! twice.

So answer is : 2* (8P5/(2!*2!)) = 3360

A very simple and easy approach based on the basics of P 'n C

Kudo me if you like this.

Agreed about the permutations approach. I was under the impression that we use permutations when there are places specified in the group, as there are here. I dont understand the combinations approach at all. For eg, in how many ways can you select a president and VP from a group of 6. Should be 6*5=30, or 6P2= 30.

Can someone please point me in the direction where I can understand when to apply C and when to apply P. I understand that P is applied when order is imp, but the problem is, that when selecting president and VP from a group, order shouldn't be important. AB or BA is the same, and therefore, even those should be solved by using combinations. I hope I'm explaining my confusion well enough for someone to help me
GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1183
Followers: 409

Kudos [?]: 1480 [2] , given: 4

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

23 Sep 2014, 09:38
2
KUDOS
Expert's post
usre123 wrote:

the problem is, that when selecting president and VP from a group, order shouldn't be important. AB or BA is the same

If you're choosing a President and Vice-President, and you choose A for President and B for VP, that's very different from choosing B for President and A for VP -- you have a different President! So when you're choosing a President and VP, order is very important, and AB and BA are not the same selection.
_________________

GMAT Tutor in Toronto

If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com

Intern
Joined: 12 Nov 2014
Posts: 4
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 1 [0], given: 5

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

21 Nov 2014, 02:21
Just wondering, why are we not just applying 2*8*7*6*5*4 ? Since the 8 remaining players can play anywhere, why do we need to differentiate Midfield vs defence vs forward?
GMAT Club Legend
Joined: 09 Sep 2013
Posts: 12904
Followers: 562

Kudos [?]: 158 [0], given: 0

Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor [#permalink]

### Show Tags

29 Nov 2015, 03:53
Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________
Re: A Coach is filling out the starting lineup for his indoor   [#permalink] 29 Nov 2015, 03:53

Go to page   Previous    1   2   [ 31 posts ]

Similar topics Replies Last post
Similar
Topics:
In Sam's hanger there are 23 boxes, 16 out of the boxes are filled 2 19 Jun 2016, 09:58
12 A certain football coach allows his quarterback to call thre 6 12 Jul 2014, 22:52
3 Jim filled his dog's bowl with 80 dog food pellets. Starting 3 25 May 2014, 14:01
10 A pump started filling an empty pool with water and continue 8 20 Nov 2008, 10:30
14 Coach Miller is filling out the starting lineup for his 18 25 Dec 2007, 15:44
Display posts from previous: Sort by