Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

It appears that you are browsing the GMAT Club forum unregistered!

Signing up is free, quick, and confidential.
Join other 500,000 members and get the full benefits of GMAT Club

Registration gives you:

Tests

Take 11 tests and quizzes from GMAT Club and leading GMAT prep companies such as Manhattan GMAT,
Knewton, and others. All are free for GMAT Club members.

Applicant Stats

View detailed applicant stats such as GPA, GMAT score, work experience, location, application
status, and more

Books/Downloads

Download thousands of study notes,
question collections, GMAT Club’s
Grammar and Math books.
All are free!

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan [#permalink]

Show Tags

26 Sep 2010, 11:55

8

This post received KUDOS

20

This post was BOOKMARKED

00:00

A

B

C

D

E

Difficulty:

95% (hard)

Question Stats:

38% (02:37) correct
62% (01:28) wrong based on 940 sessions

HideShow timer Statistics

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?

(1) y ≤ 8 (2) y ≥ 4

# of total marbles in the jar equals to \(8+y\), out of which \(R=8\) and \(W=y\)

\(P(RR)=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{8-1}{8+y-1}=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}\); \(P(RW)=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{8+y-1}=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\), multiplying by 2 as RW can occur in two ways RW or WR;

Question: is \(\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}>2\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\)? --> is \(\frac{7}{2}>y\)? --> is \(y<3.5\)? eg 0, 1, 2, 3.

(1) y ≤ 8, not sufficient. (2) y ≥ 4, sufficient, (\(y\) is not less than 3.5).

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

28 Sep 2010, 02:31

@Bunnel

will permutation be considered..?? . The question only says that 2 marbles were taken out . It does not say that the marbles were taken out one by one . Please throw some light...me confused.

will permutation be considered..?? . The question only says that 2 marbles were taken out . It does not say that the marbles were taken out one by one . Please throw some light...me confused.

For probability there is no difference whether we pick some # of marbles one by one or all at once.

For example: Jar containing 3 red and 5 blue marbles. We pick 2 marbles one by one. What is the probability that both marbles are red? Jar containing 3 red and 5 blue marbles. We pick 2 marbles simultaneously. What is the probability that both marbles are red?

\(\frac{C^2_3}{C^2_8}=\frac{3}{28}\) or \(\frac{3}{8}*\frac{2}{7}=\frac{3}{28}\).

As for the "permutation": what do you mean by that? Question asks to compare the probability "of 2 red marbles" with the probability of "one marble of each color". So can you pleas clarify what permutation has to do with it?
_________________

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

20 Oct 2010, 05:38

1

This post was BOOKMARKED

Bunuel wrote:

Orange08 wrote:

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?

(1) y ≤ 8 (2) y ≥ 4

# of total marbles in the jar equals to \(8+y\), out of which \(R=8\) and \(W=y\)

\(P(RR)=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{8-1}{8+y-1}=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}\); \(P(RW)=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{8+y-1}=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\), multiplying by 2 as RW can occure in two ways RW or WR;

Question: is \(\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}>2\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\)? --> is \(\frac{7}{2}>y\)? --> is \(y<3.5\)? eg 0, 1, 2, 3.

(1) y ≤ 8, not sufficient. (2) y ≥ 4, sufficient, (\(y\) is not less than 3.5).

Answer: B.

Bunuel, consider the case where \(Y = 2\). then The probability \(of P(RW) = 2*\frac{8}{10}*\frac{2}{9} = \frac{32}{90}\)

So even for \(y=2\), it is likely to pick two reds than a red and white. Isn't that contradicting the OA? As a matter of fact, as \(y\)keeps growing this likelyhood goes down and so \(y >!8\) (y cannot be greater than 8).

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?

(1) y ≤ 8 (2) y ≥ 4

# of total marbles in the jar equals to \(8+y\), out of which \(R=8\) and \(W=y\)

\(P(RR)=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{8-1}{8+y-1}=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}\); \(P(RW)=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{8+y-1}=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\), multiplying by 2 as RW can occure in two ways RW or WR;

Question: is \(\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}>2\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\)? --> is \(\frac{7}{2}>y\)? --> is \(y<3.5\)? eg 0, 1, 2, 3.

(1) y ≤ 8, not sufficient. (2) y ≥ 4, sufficient, (\(y\) is not less than 3.5).

Answer: B.

Bunuel, consider the case where \(Y = 2\). then The probability \(of P(RW) = 2*\frac{8}{10}*\frac{2}{9} = \frac{32}{90}\)

So even for \(y=2\), it is likely to pick two reds than a red and white. Isn't that contradicting the OA? As a matter of fact, as \(y\)keeps growing this likelyhood goes down and so \(y >!8\) (y cannot be greater than 8).

Or did I keep my foot in my mouth?

I'm not sure understand your question.

Anyway, according to the solution above when the number of white marbles (y) is 0, 1, 2, or 3 then the probability of picking two red marbles is higher than the probability of picking one marble of each color (and when the number of white marbles (y) is more than 3: 4, 5, ... then the probability of picking two red marbles is lower than the probability of picking one marble of each color). So clearly for \(y=2\): \(P(RR)>P(RW)\).

Statement (1) says \(y\leq{8}\), not sufficient, as \(y\) could be for example 1 (answer YES) or 7 (answer NO). Statement (1) says \(y\geq{4}\) --> as \(y\geq{4}\) then the probability of picking two red marbles is lower than the probability of picking one marble of each color and the answer to the question is NO. Sufficient

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

22 Oct 2010, 20:26

4

This post received KUDOS

1

This post was BOOKMARKED

This question is from MGMAT CAT. I initially thought that it is a tough question and marked it randomly. But this question is quite easy.

Since the total number of events will be same in both the cases, the question is basically asking whether the number ways in which we can pick 2 red marble is greater than that of picking of one of each color.

=> is 8C2 > 8*y

=> is 8!/6!*2! > 8*y

is 7/2 > y

=> the question is is y < 3.5

Statement 1: y ≤ 8 not sufficient.

Statement 2: y ≥ 4 => the answer to the question is NO.. hence sufficient.

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

13 Apr 2011, 00:51

Actually you don't have to do any calculation in 1). Consider the worst case.

y can be zero. In that P(two red) > P(either color) Hence Statement 1) y <= 8 fails to give one answer. On the other hand P(two red) < P (either color) for every y >=4 . Here you can pick y =4 and y = 5 to convince yourself. Probability of picking two of the same color will always be less than than picking two of different colors

Two red Vs 2 different colors y = 4 P(two red) = 8C2 / 12C2 P(either color) = 8 * 4 / 12C2 y = 5 P(two red) = 8C2 / 13C2 P(either color) = 8 * 5 / 12C2

The first probability decreases with the increase in y. The second probability increases with the increase in y

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

18 Mar 2012, 03:02

Hey Bunuel, Could you please clarify the below doubt. I know that we can calculate the probability by using Combination approach or by using Probability Approach.

The only doubt that I have is why do we need to multiply by 2 when I use the Probability approach. i.e \(P(RW)=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{8+y-1}=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\) Is it because we are considering cases over here i.e RW can occur in 2 ways - (R and then W) or (W and then R). If yes, then when we calculate the probability(RW) by using combination approach.. we don't multiply the expression by 2. Why. P(RW) = [(8C1)(yC1)]/[(8+y)C2]

Just to make it a bit clearer-

Question #1: A bag has 6 red marbles and 4 marbles. What are the chances of pulling out a red and blue marble.

Answer: (Chance of picking red * chance of picking blue) + Chance of picking blue*chance of picking red)

6/10*4/9 + 4/10*6/9 = 48/90

***Here, it appears that order matters, because you have to find the probability of getting red-blue, and add it to the probability of getting blue-red.

Question #2: A bag has 4 red marbles, 3 yellow, and 2 green, what is the probability of getting 2 Red, 2 Green, and 1 yellow, if the marbles aren't replaced:

# of ways to get 2R, 2G, 1Y 2: 4C2*2C2*3C1 =18 Total # of ways to pick 5 balls: 9C5= 126

Answer: 18/126

Now here, it appears order DOES NOT matter, since we're using combinations (instead of permutations).

How come in Q#1, blue-red, red-blue are distinct, which means you have to add the probabilities of each together, but in Q#2, it uses combinations, which means order doesn't matter.

WHY? Completely lost

Please throw some light on this. Thanks -H

Bunuel wrote:

Orange08 wrote:

A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?

(1) y ≤ 8 (2) y ≥ 4

# of total marbles in the jar equals to \(8+y\), out of which \(R=8\) and \(W=y\)

\(P(RR)=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{8-1}{8+y-1}=\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}\); \(P(RW)=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{8+y-1}=2*\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\), multiplying by 2 as RW can occure in two ways RW or WR;

Question: is \(\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{7}{7+y}>2\frac{8}{8+y}*\frac{y}{7+y}\)? --> is \(\frac{7}{2}>y\)? --> is \(y<3.5\)? eg 0, 1, 2, 3.

(1) y ≤ 8, not sufficient. (2) y ≥ 4, sufficient, (\(y\) is not less than 3.5).

The only doubt that I have is why do we need to multiply by 2 when I use the Probability approach.

i.e RW can occur in 2 ways - (R and then W) or (W and then R). If yes, then when we calculate the probability(RW) by using combination approach.. we don't multiply the expression by 2. Why. P(RW) = [(8C1)(yC1)]/[(8+y)C2]

Responding to a pm: Order matters. That is the reason we multiply by 2 in the probability approach. We can pick R and then W or W and then R. So R and W can be picked in two different sequences with the same end result.

As for the combination approach - it works and you can use it but I wouldn't like to in this case. When we say 8C1, we are assuming that the balls are distinct and we can select one ball out of 8 Red balls in 8 ways. But it is kind of implied in the question that the balls are identical. Still, you can assume all the balls to be distinct and select 1 out of 8 Red balls in 8 ways and 1 out of y white balls in y ways. Number of ways of selecting R and W = 8*y Number of ways of selecting W and R = y*8 Total number of ways of selecting 2 balls = (8+y)(7+y) (first ball can be selected in 8+y ways and second in 8+y-1 ways) Required probability = 16y/(8+y)(7+y) (which is the same as obtained in the probability method) It works because in the numerator we assume all balls to be distinct and we do the same in the denominator too. Hence, the probability stays the same.

You can also calculate the probability assuming that order doesn't matter (for both numerator and denominator). Since it is probability, you will get the same probability since the 2 of the numerator will get canceled with the 2 of the denominator.

Number of ways of picking R and W = 8C1*yC1 (order doesn't matter so we don't multiply by 2) Number of ways of picking 2 balls = (8+y)C2 (order doesn't matter when we use nCr)

Probability = 8C1*yC1/(8+y)C2 = 8y/(8+y)(7+y)/2 = 16y/(8+y)(7+y) Obviously, the result is the same.
_________________

Re: 8 red marbles and y white marbles [#permalink]

Show Tags

07 Jun 2012, 15:29

Thanks Karishma for the explanation. I understand both the approaches now. However, just needed a little bit of more explanation on the concept of identical vs distinct as you mentioned in the below excerpt.

I have noticed that you have given emphasis on the distinct vs identical objects. I want to understand that as to how does the word identical vs distinct makes a difference when using combinations. I have understood that for solving probability questions,it won't make much of impact since we assume the same in both numerator and denominator. Please clear this doubt also, but wanted to understand this concept from Combinations point of view

Thanks H

VeritasPrepKarishma wrote:

Responding to a pm: Order matters. That is the reason we multiply by 2 in the probability approach. We can pick R and then W or W and then R. So R and W can be picked in two different sequences with the same end result.

As for the combination approach - it works and you can use it but I wouldn't like to in this case. When we say 8C1, we are assuming that the balls are distinct and we can select one ball out of 8 Red balls in 8 ways. But it is kind of implied in the question that the balls are identical. Still, you can assume all the balls to be distinct and select 1 out of 8 Red balls in 8 ways and 1 out of y white balls in y ways. Number of ways of selecting R and W = 8*y

Thanks Karishma for the explanation. I understand both the approaches now. However, just needed a little bit of more explanation on the concept of identical vs distinct as you mentioned in the below excerpt.

I have noticed that you have given emphasis on the distinct vs identical objects. I want to understand that as to how does the word identical vs distinct makes a difference when using combinations. I have understood that for solving probability questions,it won't make much of impact since we assume the same in both numerator and denominator. Please clear this doubt also, but wanted to understand this concept from Combinations point of view

Thanks H

You have four distinct balls. In how many ways can you select a ball? In 4 ways. In how many ways can you select 2 balls? In 4C2 ways. etc... You have four identical balls. In how many ways can you select a ball? In 1 way. No matter which ball you pick, it is no different from the other 3 balls so every case is the same. In how many ways can you select 2 balls? Again, only 1 way. You can select any two balls - they are all the same.

Re: A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan [#permalink]

Show Tags

25 Apr 2013, 09:53

Hi Bunuel, I have a question. I got B, and below is how I conceptualized it. On second thought, however, I realized that the logic behind my reasoning is weak. But my answer was still right. Was my intuition correct or was I just lucky?

Basically, I figured that if you wanted twice the chance to pull RR as RW, you would want twice as many R as W - so you would have 8 R and 4 W. In this case the chance of pulling R is 2x the chance of pulling W. Then, in order for it to be more likely to pull RR, W would have to be <4.

My basic intuition might be in the right direction, but I was just lucky that the #s worked out in my favor, right? Because I don't think my reasoning is mathematically logically sound, as it only accounts for one pull from the jar. Thank you!

EDIT: Just for anyone else thinking this way, I realized that I was just lucky to get the right answer. If instead you say there were 9 Red Marbles, there is obviously no way to have 4.5 White Marbles, and also, using Bunuel's method, the correct answer would be that the # of White Marbles must <4, not 4.5

Re: A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan [#permalink]

Show Tags

14 Apr 2014, 23:43

'm not sure understand your question.

Anyway, according to the solution above when the number of white marbles (y) is 0, 1, 2, or 3 then the probability of picking two red marbles is higher than the probability of picking one marble of each color (and when the number of white marbles (y) is more than 3: 4, 5, ... then the probability of picking two red marbles is lower than the probability of picking one marble of each color). So clearly for y=2: P(RR)>P(RW).

Statement (1) says y\leq{8}, not sufficient, as y could be for example 1 (answer YES) or 7 (answer NO). Statement (1) says y\geq{4} --> as y\geq{4} then the probability of picking two red marbles is lower than the probability of picking one marble of each color and the answer to the question is NO. Sufficient

Happy New Year everyone! Before I get started on this post, and well, restarted on this blog in general, I wanted to mention something. For the past several months...

It’s quickly approaching two years since I last wrote anything on this blog. A lot has happened since then. When I last posted, I had just gotten back from...

Happy 2017! Here is another update, 7 months later. With this pace I might add only one more post before the end of the GSB! However, I promised that...