ABC is a right triangle with right angle at point B. If the ratio of

I too believe the answer is D, but just wanted to correct a typo. The question stem says the ratio is 8:15 and your solution shows 8:5.

So for statement 2 we would have 8x+15x+x*(289)^1/2 =680.

Answer is D.

Oh yea,! thanks.
good luck

Could you guys explain it a little in detail as to why is statement 1 sufficient. I did not get it.

Warm Regards,

Rudraksh.

using any side as the base, the area should be the same, but the corresponding height from that base needs to be used.
half base into height.

Hi All,

When a Geometry question does not include a picture, you have to be careful about the assumptions you make about the shape(s) involved.

Here, do you KNOW which side of the triangle is the height: AB or BC.....? If you drew 2 different pictures, and did the necessary work, would the answer to the question change?

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

ABC is right angle at B
hence, any line touching B cant be the hypotenuse.

Dear RudeyboyZ

Please refer to the image below. It represents the information that we were given in the Question Statement and in St. 1.Also, if AB = 8x and BC = 15x, can you calculate AC? Sure, using Pythagoras Theorem, you know that it's 17x.





Now, area of triangle ABC =\(\frac{1}{2}*AB*BC\) = \(\frac{1}{2}*8x*15x\)

But, suppose you take the base as AC. Then, what is the height? BD. And St. 1 tells us that BD = 120

So, the area of triangle ABC can also be written as = \(\frac{1}{2}*BD*AC\) = \(\frac{1}{2}*120*17x\)

By equating the two expressions for area of triangle ABC, you can find the value of x and therefore, you can find a unique value of the area of triangle ABC. So, St. 1 is sufficient.

Note that I could analyze Statement 1 till its logical conclusion because:

1. I drew a neat diagram that represented all the pieces of information that were given in Question statement + St. 1 and also the information that I had inferred (AC = 17x, using Pythagoras Theorem)

2. I was able to mentally rotate the triangle ABC such that AC became its base. By doing so, I could see that the area of triangle ABC can also be written as \(\frac{1}{2}*BD*AC\). This ability to mentally rotate a given image comes in handy in many questions.

Here's an official question that involves rotation of a triangle:

https://gmatclub.com/forum/in-the-figure-above-triangle-abc-is-equilateral-and-point-143496.html

Hope this helped!

Japinder

Dear Japinder,

The detailed explanation is really helpful. Thank you!

Warm Regards,

Rudey.

Dear Japinder,

The detailed explanation is really helpful. Thank you!

Warm Regards,

Rudraksh.

Hi Bunuel,
Can you please help me with this question, i have a specific doubt.
St 1 says, The height from point B to the hypotenuse is 120; We know that Perpendicular to the hypotenuse(height from point B to the hypotenuse) will always divide the triangle into two triangles with the same properties as the original triangle and it'll be half the length of the hypotenuse? Which only goes on to prove hypotenuse = 2x120=240
St 2 says, perimeter of the triangle is 680; 8x+15x+17x=680 x=17 hypotenuse = 17x17 = 289
How can we have 2 different hypotenuse measures for the same triangle?

you are quoting statement 2 correctly but your interpretation of statement 1 is not correct.

The property that you have mentioned in the red text above is ONLY possible when the triangle is a 45-45-90 triangle and in this triangle AB = BC which is not the case provided to us.

Triangle ABC is NOT 45-45-90 triangle and hence you can not say that the hypotenuse will be divided into 2 by the height from B.

The way you will be able to calculate the impact of height is as follows:

Let the 2 sides of the triangle be 8k and 15k (as the ratio is 8:15)

Thus the hypotenuse is = ((8k)^2+(15k)^2)^0.5 = 17k.

Thus the area of the triangle = 0.5*AB*BC = 0.5*Height*Hypotenuse ---> 0.5*8k*15k = 0.5*120*17k ---> k = 17 and thus hypotenuse = 17*17= 289 same as Statement 2.

Hope this helps.

How do we know that BD is a perpendicular line segment?

(1) says "The height from point B to the hypotenuse is 120." In a triangle, height refers to the perpendicular distance from a vertex to its opposite side.

ABC is a right triangle with right angle at point B. If the ratio of AB to BC is 8 to 15, what is the area of the triangle?

Using Pythagoras we can find the multiple of AC as follows:
8x^2 + 15x^2 = ACx^2 = 17^2
AC = 17x

Hence
AB:BC:AC = 8x:15x:17x

As we don't know the value of x, we are required to find its value to get the area of the triangle ABC.

(1) The height from point B to the hypotenuse is 120.
This implies that B and point D(one that meets AC) make a line that is perpendicular to AC.
Since there can only be one unique value for BD, we know that it must have some value that follows a ratio pattern with any side of the triangle. Although going into the details of this is not required, only knowing that is enough.

And if there is a unique value then getting a value of x, eventually area, becomes easier.

SUFFICIENT.

(2) The perimeter of the triangle is 680.
Now, for this we have
8x + 15x + 17x = 680
This gives x = 17

From here on we can calculate the value of area.

Answer D.