H/S/W - slim; I'm sure you're a great guy, solid all around, etc. but you're simply up against too many other finance guys with stronger (read: more blue chip in terms of experience and education) resumes than you have
Columbia, Booth, Kellogg, Sloan, and Tuck: stretches, but worth giving a shot; choose 2 (I'm guessing given your finance career path and goals, CBS and Booth are the 2).
NYU, Cornell, Yale, Haas, Duke, Darden, Michigan, UCLA - sweet spots; choose 3-4 from this list (for finance, NYU, Cornell, Yale). \
You may want to look at European schools as well -- LBS/INSEAD will be stretches (similar to CBS/Booth), and Oxford/Cambridge will be sweet spots.
Follow me on Facebook