Can a Verbal expert please come for the rescue....This question is confusing...plus I am not sure how could the correct ans be A? IMO it should be 'D'...please help!
Fact #1: All of the best comedians have had unhappy childhoods.
Fact #2: Many people who have had happy childhoods are good comedians,
Fact #3: Some good comedians who have had miserably unhappy childhoods are happy adults.
If the statements in the passage are true, which one of the following CANNOT be true?
(A) The proportion of good comedians who had unhappy childhoods is greater than the proportion of the best comedians who did. Correct.
Fact #1 says "ALL
the best comedians have had unhappy childhoods" ==> The proportion = 100%
(because of "all").
Fact #2 says "Many
comedians have had happy childhoods" --> There are still some comedians have had unhappy childhoods. Two sets combined make up 100% ==> The sub set MUST be < 100%
Thus, A CAN'T be correct.
(B) Some good comedians have had unhappy childhoods and are unhappy adults. Wrong.
Yes, B can be true. Fact #3 says "some
good comedians who have had unhappy childhoods are happy adults
" ==> Absolutely, there are still some
comedians who have had unhappy childhoods are unhappy adults
(C) Most of the best comedians are happy adults. Wrong.
Yes, C can be true. It is possible that a group of best comedians is the sub set
of a group of good comedians. Deduce from fact #3, C can be true.
(D) More good comedians have had unhappy childhoods than have had happy childhoods. Wrong.
From fact #2, because we don't know how many "some" is, we can assume that we have 100 good comedians, 60 have had unhappy childhoods, 40 have had happy childhoods. D can be true.
(E) The proportion of comedians who are happy adults is higher than the proportions who are unhappy adults.Wrong.
From fact #3, because we don't know how many "some" is, we can assume that we have 100 comedians, 60 are happy adults, 40 are unhappy adults. Clearly, E can be true.
Hope it helps.
Please +1 KUDO if my post helps. Thank you.
"Designing cars consumes you; it has a hold on your spirit which is incredibly powerful. It's not something you can do part time, you have do it with all your heart and soul or you're going to get it wrong."
Chris Bangle - Former BMV Chief of Design.