Committee member: We should not vote to put at the top of the

Doer01, (D) is wrong because it supports the statement made by the author, but it does not fit into the criteria for its line of reasoning. If this were a strengthen question, (D) would fit the bill. Further, the argument talks about history of drinking vs. just excessive drinking (maybe it was one time?). But as it stands, it cannot be our answer because it doesn't match. Lastly, we are not talking about ANY position, but top positions. As for (A), it is correct because all of the others are not fitting the bill. I even paused on (A) before I took it. In the end, it is the CLOSEST to being the original statement. Remember, our goal is to show what the person is saying, using their premises and conclusions.

One last item I want to mention: This is from an older test (22 years ago), so some of the wording has been updated over the years with LSAC, and thus may not conform 100% to what we would see today as 100% correct.