Are there DS problems where statement 1 is "ALWAYS YES" and statement 2 yields an "ALWAYS NO"? In this case, which would be the correct answer?
If I understood you properly then my ananlysis is below.
Question: is x > 5?
STAT2 something else
Now, if STAT 1 is giving you that x > 5 for ALL the conditions
Then it is SUFFICIENT
if STAT2 is giving you that x NOT > 5 for ALL the conditions
Then is is SUFFCIENT
Answer will be D in this case.
The whole point in solving for a DS question is that whether you are able to find out the answer to the question with the given options.
What i mean is if the question is asking if x >5?
then if you are able to prove that x > 5 always then it is sufficent
also, if you are able to prove that x NOT 5 ALWAYS then this is also sufficent.
The conclusion is, by suing the options given you SHOULD be able to asnwer the question asked in the problem.
Hope it helps.
You must Believe
GMAT Quant Tutor
How to start GMAT preparations?
How to Improve Quant Score?
Gmatclub Topic Tags
Check out my GMAT debrief
Quant Formula Sheet
How to Solve :
Statistics || Reflection of a line || Remainder Problems || Inequalities