Since part-time MBA's always award the same MBA degree as the full time program, when your MBA is on your resume it will be considered more on the basis of the full time MBA rankings. The full-time and part-time MBA programs are two totally different experiences that both have their benefits and negatives. For your decision, I think you should attend either of those schools, so go to the one that you like best. Since you are awarded the same degree, you have to decide which style of program will provide you with the most benefit for your future goals. But since the full-time option is not an option for you, you just need to decide if the part-time option will work for you are your goals.
New to the GMAT Club? <START HERE>GMAT Club Premium Membership - big benefits and savings
My GMAT and BSchool Tips: