Gary’s brother told him that he would attend the graduation ceremony i

Hi all,
I couldn't pick any of these choices

a) would ..... if ... would : wrong
b)will...if...is possible : seems good but this is a reported speech in the past,hence wrong
c) could be a possibility : awkward
d) might be a possibility : awkward
e) will ... if...was possible : wrong pair of v-tense

Any help would be great
Thanks

Your observation is correct. For a future event within a statement in past, "would" should be used instead of "will". Moreover the pronoun "it" wrongly refers to verb "will attend". Option B has been modified to take care of both the issues. Thank you for pointing out.

(In the modified option B, the pronoun "it" is a placeholder, used to refer to the infinitive "to attend". Please let me know if you have any further query about the modified option B.)

Thank you, I was expecting this query.

First suppose that the statement is in present tense:

Gary’s brother TELLS him that he WILL attend the graduation ceremony if it IS possible to attend...... this is not a case of hypothetical subjunctive - this is a case of a particular case in future with no uncertainty. IF simple present THEN simple future (e.g., If he plays the match, they will win).

Now consider that the sentence is taken one step back in the past. The general rule is that all verbs are required to be taken one step back in the past as well (simple present becomes simple past and simple future "will" becomes "would"). Now the sentence becomes:

Gary’s brother TOLD him that he WOULD attend the graduation ceremony if it WAS possible to attend.

Thus you may see that this is not a case of hypothetical subjunctive, but a case of a future certain event from the perspective of past.

Hi,
'it' is working as a placeholder here to postpone the infinitive subject 'to come' , which is ellipsis ( if it is possible to come) .

Merged topics. Please, search before posting questions!

Hi sayantanc2k,
I am still unable to cross out A. what are the errors in this option ?

Thanks

Usage Of If clause

If "Condition",then"outcome"

Here
IF clause tense Then clause tense
Simple present (a) simple present or (b) simple future

Simple past (c) Simple past or (d)would verb

past perfect (e)would have verb


example for each is given below

(a)If Roy plays with any toy,it is his bat.
(b) If Roy plays with any toy,it will be his bat.
(c)If Roy played with any toy,it was his bat.
(d)If Roy played with any toy,it would be his bat.
(e)If Roy had played with any toy,it would have been his bat.

Accordingly Answer Is B for this question

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.