Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
10 Jun 2009, 19:08

1

This post received KUDOS

Explanation Official Answer: D

Statement 1: If |x| = y = 10, y is 10 but x could be -10 or 10. The area is same for x = 10 and x = -10. This is sufficient to answer the question. Statement 2: If x = |y| = 10, x = 10 but y could be 10 or -10 but different value of y does not affect the area of the triangle. This statement is also sufficient to answer the question.

Statement 1: If |x| = y = 10, y is 10 but x could be -10 or 10. Area is not same for x = 10 and x = -10. This is not sufficient to answer the question. Statement 2: If x = |y| = 10, x = 10 but y could be 10 or -10 but different value of y does not affect the area of the triangle. This statement is sufficient to answer the question.

Therefore the OA is B.

How can a difference in x co-ordinate will change the area. Coz the y co-ordinate will decide the height of the triangle and it is constant. IMHO the answer should be D.

Statement 1: If |x| = y = 10, y is 10 but x could be -10 or 10. Area is not same for x = 10 and x = -10. This is not sufficient to answer the question. Statement 2: If x = |y| = 10, x = 10 but y could be 10 or -10 but different value of y does not affect the area of the triangle. This statement is sufficient to answer the question.

Therefore the OA is B.

How can a difference in x co-ordinate will change the area. Coz the y co-ordinate will decide the height of the triangle and it is constant. IMHO the answer should be D.

Agree with kyabe. Even when x = -10, you still can calculate the area of the rectangle (area of 350) and subtract the areas of two other triangles (250 total). That leaves you with 100 for the area of the triangle.

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
21 Aug 2009, 21:58

1

This post received KUDOS

Answer should be C.

1) B can be two points B1(10, 10) or B2(-10,10) therefore Sabc is not certain

2) B can be B1(10, 10) or B2(10, -10) although AC is certain, but the height from B1 to AC and B2 to AC are not the same. therefore Sabc is not certain

put 1) and 2) together, B can only be (10, 10) Sabc can be calculated.
_________________

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
22 Aug 2009, 18:33

flyingbunny wrote:

Answer should be C.

1) B can be two points B1(10, 10) or B2(-10,10) therefore Sabc is not certain

2) B can be B1(10, 10) or B2(10, -10) although AC is certain, but the height from B1 to AC and B2 to AC are not the same. therefore Sabc is not certain

put 1) and 2) together, B can only be (10, 10) Sabc can be calculated.

The question does not require that you know exactly where the triangle is or what its shape is... only the area is being discussed here... the area is the same for any of the possible locations for B that were mentioned, so the correct answer is D.

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
22 Aug 2009, 22:53

1

This post received KUDOS

flyingbunny wrote:

Architect wrote:

flyingbunny wrote:

Answer should be C.

1) B can be two points B1(10, 10) or B2(-10,10) therefore Sabc is not certain

2) B can be B1(10, 10) or B2(10, -10) although AC is certain, but the height from B1 to AC and B2 to AC are not the same. therefore Sabc is not certain

put 1) and 2) together, B can only be (10, 10) Sabc can be calculated.

The question does not require that you know exactly where the triangle is or what its shape is... only the area is being discussed here... the area is the same for any of the possible locations for B that were mentioned, so the correct answer is D.

when B is at different points, the areas are different.

If B is (-10,10), Area=100. If B is (10,10), Area=100. If B is (10,-10), Area=100. 100=100=100. Make sense? If not, I can sketch up a diagram and scan it to prove it.

I agree that the answer is D as well. I spent a lot of time trying to figure this one out.

In short if you assume that two points at (5,0) and (25,0) are the base (which equals 20), you still get the same area regardless of whether the third point is at:

(10,10) (-10,10) (10,-10) (-10,-10)

All that matters is that the height is still 10, because the area of a triange is 1/2*base*height: 1/2*10*20 = 100

doesn't matter what the x coordinate is... as long as your base is fixed, and your height is fixed, area should be the same... but i still have to see it (and drag the coordinates around -- see link above) myself to believe it!!
_________________

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
18 Jan 2012, 08:04

Wha? Alright, either I'm totally confused right now or there's something wrong.

I made a drawing of the whole thing, these are the 2 triangles that could result from the points stated in A), so (10|10) or (10|-10). I've attached my drawing to this post.

Unless I made a mistake, this should be drawn to scale. Each division of the grid on the paper corresponds to 5 units. It is very obvious the area of the orange trinangle (the one resulting from point (-10|10)) is a lot larger than that of the blue triangle (resulting from point (10|10)). Also, if assuming the line connecting (5|0) and (25|0) is the base, it is clearly obvious that the heights of these two triangles are different, after all as far as i know the height should be a line from the point opposite to the base in an angle that is orthogonal to the base. Since the base is not a straight vertical line but rather askew, the point (-10|10) cant be simply mirrored to generate a triangle with an equal area.

Does that make sense? Did I make a mistake or is there a flaw in the question?

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
20 Dec 2012, 16:12

ummm, the question is rather tricky.

Before wasting time trying to solve either statements, remember that: if two statements provide identical information then the correct answer will be either D or E. It's plain to see that both statements are identical; hence, a question with identical statements can not be A, B, or C. (1) |x| = y = 10 (2) x = |y| = 10

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
14 Aug 2013, 16:55

BCG13 wrote:

ummm, the question is rather tricky.

Before wasting time trying to solve either statements, remember that: if two statements provide identical information then the correct answer will be either D or E. It's plain to see that both statements are identical; hence, a question with identical statements can not be A, B, or C. (1) |x| = y = 10 (2) x = |y| = 10

Answer = D, since each statement is sufficient.

This is small, but you might want to note that these two statements are not identical. Statement 1 implies that that the third vertex is either located at (-10,10) or at (10,10), while Statement 2 implies (10,-10) or (10,10). In this particular problem, due to how those three points would all have the same effect on the area formula, the two statements are redundant, but not identical.

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35 [#permalink]
16 Dec 2013, 01:04

JeeMat wrote:

Wha? Alright, either I'm totally confused right now or there's something wrong.

I made a drawing of the whole thing, these are the 2 triangles that could result from the points stated in A), so (10|10) or (10|-10). I've attached my drawing to this post.

Unless I made a mistake, this should be drawn to scale. Each division of the grid on the paper corresponds to 5 units. It is very obvious the area of the orange trinangle (the one resulting from point (-10|10)) is a lot larger than that of the blue triangle (resulting from point (10|10)). Also, if assuming the line connecting (5|0) and (25|0) is the base, it is clearly obvious that the heights of these two triangles are different, after all as far as i know the height should be a line from the point opposite to the base in an angle that is orthogonal to the base. Since the base is not a straight vertical line but rather askew, the point (-10|10) cant be simply mirrored to generate a triangle with an equal area.

Does that make sense? Did I make a mistake or is there a flaw in the question?

Dear JeeMath, in the premise said that point A (5;0) and C(25;0) which is gives you strait line on x-line (as the points has the same y-coordinate=0) hope you are just overlooked it
_________________

Good things come to those who wait… greater things come to those who get off their ass and do anything to make it happen...

gmatclubot

Re: GMAT Diagnostic Test Question 35
[#permalink]
16 Dec 2013, 01:04