Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

Got this one from the GMAT Club test m05. What is the volume [#permalink]
22 Nov 2010, 18:55

00:00

A

B

C

D

E

Difficulty:

5% (low)

Question Stats:

78% (01:14) correct
22% (00:29) wrong based on 9 sessions

Got this one from the GMAT Club test m05.

What is the volume of a cardboard box with sides a , b , and c ?

1. a = \frac{12}{bc} 2. b = 3, c = 2

Isn't this kind of a trick question? To actually get the correct answer, you need to assume that a, b, and c are the length, width, and height of the box, but in the question they don't actually specify that. Given how specific we usually have to be about the information they give us, shouldn't the answer technically be E? And is it safe to expect not to get a problem like this on the real thing?

Re: Volume of box - trick question? [#permalink]
22 Nov 2010, 21:36

The question says that the sides are a,b, and c; which means that they are respectively the length, breadth & height. So there is no ambiguity in saying the answer is A _________________

Re: Volume of box - trick question? [#permalink]
23 Nov 2010, 05:16

Expert's post

TehJay wrote:

Got this one from the GMAT Club test m05.

What is the volume of a cardboard box with sides a , b , and c ?

1. a = \frac{12}{bc} 2. b = 3, c = 2

Isn't this kind of a trick question? To actually get the correct answer, you need to assume that a, b, and c are the length, width, and height of the box, but in the question they don't actually specify that. Given how specific we usually have to be about the information they give us, shouldn't the answer technically be E? And is it safe to expect not to get a problem like this on the real thing?

A similar question in GMAT will specify 'rectangular box'. _________________

Re: Volume of box - trick question? [#permalink]
23 Nov 2010, 06:53

VeritasPrepKarishma wrote:

TehJay wrote:

Got this one from the GMAT Club test m05.

What is the volume of a cardboard box with sides a , b , and c ?

1. a = \frac{12}{bc} 2. b = 3, c = 2

Isn't this kind of a trick question? To actually get the correct answer, you need to assume that a, b, and c are the length, width, and height of the box, but in the question they don't actually specify that. Given how specific we usually have to be about the information they give us, shouldn't the answer technically be E? And is it safe to expect not to get a problem like this on the real thing?

A similar question in GMAT will specify 'rectangular box'.

Based on what I've seen in my studying, though, we are not supposed to assume ANYTHING about any problem. In this case, I was unsure if I'm supposed to assume that a, b, and c are different sides, or if the answer is (E) because we don't know for sure that a and b aren't both the length of the box, just on different sides.

For a 2-d example, if the problem said there was a rectangle with sides a and b and asked me to calculate the area, I wouldn't assume that a and b are adjacent and not opposite sides unless the problem specifically told me that.

I know I must sound nitpicky but my exam is in 10 days and I've really gotten into the habit of not assuming a single thing that isn't given to us.

Re: Volume of box - trick question? [#permalink]
23 Nov 2010, 08:26

Expert's post

TehJay wrote:

VeritasPrepKarishma wrote:

TehJay wrote:

Got this one from the GMAT Club test m05.

What is the volume of a cardboard box with sides a , b , and c ?

1. a = \frac{12}{bc} 2. b = 3, c = 2

Isn't this kind of a trick question? To actually get the correct answer, you need to assume that a, b, and c are the length, width, and height of the box, but in the question they don't actually specify that. Given how specific we usually have to be about the information they give us, shouldn't the answer technically be E? And is it safe to expect not to get a problem like this on the real thing?

A similar question in GMAT will specify 'rectangular box'.

Based on what I've seen in my studying, though, we are not supposed to assume ANYTHING about any problem. In this case, I was unsure if I'm supposed to assume that a, b, and c are different sides, or if the answer is (E) because we don't know for sure that a and b aren't both the length of the box, just on different sides.

For a 2-d example, if the problem said there was a rectangle with sides a and b and asked me to calculate the area, I wouldn't assume that a and b are adjacent and not opposite sides unless the problem specifically told me that.

I know I must sound nitpicky but my exam is in 10 days and I've really gotten into the habit of not assuming a single thing that isn't given to us.

Valid concern. Come to think of it, if a question says 'a, b and c are sides of a rectangular box. What is the volume of the box?' I would not like to assume that a, b and c are length, breadth and height. They could be length, length and height. If they mention that a, b and c are distinct, then it is fine. (It is not essential that length, breadth and height of a box have to be distinct but if three sides are distinct, they have to be length, breadth and height.) You do not assume anything in DS questions except for what is obvious (e.g. if in a group of people, there are 20% males, then the rest 80% are definitely female). It is sometimes a matter of judgment. Though, rest assured GMAT religiously follows its statistics i.e. if many 700 scorers are answering a particular 500 level question incorrectly, the question is deemed unfit and removed. So there is little chance that you will face even a single question that is debatable in actual GMAT. _________________