mrbucket wrote:
mth1214 wrote:
Does anyone know if the same admissions team that reviews applications also reads scholarship applications / essays?
Some of the material from my application essays would work well with one of the scholarhips essays, but I want to be sure someone new will be reading it. Clearly I would not be cutting and pasting full essays, but want to at least use some of the same ideas.
Thanks in advance.
I really don't know the answer here, but I can tell you how I approached it:
I figured that there is a Financial Aid team that is separate from admissions but has access to your original application package, and I assumed they'd at least review your application briefly when considering you for a grant or fellowship. With that mindset I decided to write entirely new essays, though obviously there might be some overlap in material. In one case, for the need-based grant, I briefly explained some circumstances and then included a parenthetical that basically said "I address this issue more extensively in my original application". I figured I didn't need to waste precious words (that essay was limited to 250) and that if the person reviewing my app really wanted to learn more they could dig up my original essays. I have no idea if this is kosher, but I did end up getting a need-based grant.
Some different fellowships might have different approval processes (if I donated a ton of money for a regular fellowship I'd probably want to have a little input in who got it, right?), so don't necessarily assume the person has combed through your entire app, but avoid the urge to recycle material if you can.
Hope that helps -- maybe someone with a little more visibility in the process can chime in.
I had the exact same question when I was applying for scholarships, so I picked up the phone and called the financial aid office and just asked them outright. They were very friendly and forthcoming- I don't remember the exact conversation details, but who reviews your scholarship app depends on what you are applying for; for example, if you are applying for one of the academic ones (marketing, finance, etc.) people from that department review it (potentially along with some admissions folks? can't remember). Others have different people reading it. In any case, they didn't necessarily have my original application in front of them so I was told I can recycle stories if I wanted. That being said, I didn't get awarded anything, so perhaps mrbucket's approach was better.
I think, if in doubt, give them a call and ask about the ones you're looking at. Can only help.