Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

It appears that you are browsing the GMAT Club forum unregistered!

Signing up is free, quick, and confidential.
Join other 350,000 members and get the full benefits of GMAT Club

Registration gives you:

Tests

Take 11 tests and quizzes from GMAT Club and leading GMAT prep companies such as Manhattan GMAT,
Knewton, and others. All are free for GMAT Club members.

Applicant Stats

View detailed applicant stats such as GPA, GMAT score, work experience, location, application
status, and more

Books/Downloads

Download thousands of study notes,
question collections, GMAT Club’s
Grammar and Math books.
All are free!

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

Re: If a = 3be, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
05 Jan 2014, 05:27

werbliben wrote:

If a = 3be, what is the value of c?

(1) a = 10 - b (2) 3a = 4b

Hopefully this wasn't posted before. At least I wasn't able to find this task on the forum

The answer given by the authors of the textbook is B. Their solution suggests dividing the equation in the 2nd statement by b, thus transforming it to the form c = 1/3*a/b. This would be true if not for the circumstance that we cannot divide by b unless we prove it isn't 0. Both the initial equation a=3be and the one in the 2nd statement give us no information about possible value of b or a, but by using 1st statement in combination with the 2nd one we can prove that both a and b are non-zero, after which we have legitimate power to do the transformation described above. But in that case the answer should be C, not B. Am I missing something or is this a typo?

Re: If a = 3be, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
05 Jan 2014, 05:35

1

This post received KUDOS

Expert's post

werbliben wrote:

werbliben wrote:

If a = 3bc, what is the value of c?

(1) a = 10 - b (2) 3a = 4b

Hopefully this wasn't posted before. At least I wasn't able to find this task on the forum

The answer given by the authors of the textbook is B. Their solution suggests dividing the equation in the 2nd statement by b, thus transforming it to the form c = 1/3*a/b. This would be true if not for the circumstance that we cannot divide by b unless we prove it isn't 0. Both the initial equation a=3be and the one in the 2nd statement give us no information about possible value of b or a, but by using 1st statement in combination with the 2nd one we can prove that both a and b are non-zero, after which we have legitimate power to do the transformation described above. But in that case the answer should be C, not B. Am I missing something or is this a typo?

Yes, you are right. The answer cannot be B, it's C. For (2) if a=b=0, then c can be any number.

Hope it's clear.

P.S. Are you sure that it's MGMAT question? _________________

Re: If a = 3bc, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
05 Jan 2014, 05:56

Thanks again =)

Well, yes, I've found this one on page 115 of the 5th edition of Algebra MGMAT Strategy guide. It's given as an example, not in a problem set, and, what's more, the explanation is ended in a rather unusual fashion: instead of naming the letter of the correct answer, the textbook says: "Statement 2 by itself allows us to solve for a/b". So, either a typo or great troubles await me in the Reading comprehension section =)

Re: If a = 3bc, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jan 2014, 01:06

werbliben wrote:

Thanks again =)

Well, yes, I've found this one on page 115 of the 5th edition of Algebra MGMAT Strategy guide. It's given as an example, not in a problem set, and, what's more, the explanation is ended in a rather unusual fashion: instead of naming the letter of the correct answer, the textbook says: "Statement 2 by itself allows us to solve for a/b". So, either a typo or great troubles await me in the Reading comprehension section =)

The example question in the guide asks " If a = 3bc, and abc does not equal 0, what is the value of c?

(1) a = 10 - b (2) 3a = 4b "

With the condition abc not equal to zero, the value of a/b from statement (2) is sufficient to evaluate c uniquely from equation a = 3bc. Hence, the answer is (B) in the strategy guide.

Re: If a = 3bc, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jan 2014, 01:45

Expert's post

arunspanda wrote:

werbliben wrote:

Thanks again =)

Well, yes, I've found this one on page 115 of the 5th edition of Algebra MGMAT Strategy guide. It's given as an example, not in a problem set, and, what's more, the explanation is ended in a rather unusual fashion: instead of naming the letter of the correct answer, the textbook says: "Statement 2 by itself allows us to solve for a/b". So, either a typo or great troubles await me in the Reading comprehension section =)

The example question in the guide asks " If a = 3bc, and abc does not equal 0, what is the value of c?

(1) a = 10 - b (2) 3a = 4b "

With the condition abc not equal to zero, the value of a/b from statement (2) is sufficient to evaluate c uniquely from equation a = 3bc. Hence, the answer is (B) in the strategy guide.

Yes, if it's given that abc does not equal 0, then the answer is B. _________________

Re: If a = 3bc, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jan 2014, 03:39

arunspanda

There is no mention of the abc =/= 0 condition in my edition, they should've updated this task in the subsequent editions, although I thought the 5th, published in 2012, was the latest to date.

Re: If a = 3bc, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jan 2014, 07:44

werbliben wrote:

arunspanda

There is no mention of the abc =/= 0 condition in my edition, they should've updated this task in the subsequent editions, although I thought the 5th, published in 2012, was the latest to date.

The quoted text is from the guide published on 24th April, 2012 (Kindle Edition).

Re: If a = 3be, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jun 2014, 10:37

Expert's post

faamir wrote:

Hi Bunuel,

Please help me out here. Doesn't 3a = 4b mean a/b=4/3 ? Doesn't this imply a not= 0 and b not= 0. In this case shouldn't the answer be B?

If we are not given that a and b does not equal 0, then from 3a=4b we cannot write a/b=4/3. Because 3a=4b also holds when a=b=0, and in this case a/b=0/0=undefined not 4/3. _________________

Re: If a = 3be, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jun 2014, 10:44

Bunuel wrote:

faamir wrote:

Hi Bunuel,

Please help me out here. Doesn't 3a = 4b mean a/b=4/3 ? Doesn't this imply a not= 0 and b not= 0. In this case shouldn't the answer be B?

If we are not given that a and b does not equal 0, then from 3a=4b we cannot write a/b=4/3. Because 3a=4b also holds when a=b=0, and in this case a/b=0/0=undefined not 4/3.

Thanks Bunuel.

If instead of the 2nd statement being 3a=4b, we were given a/b=4/3, can we then deduce a not=0 and b not=0 ? Would the answer then have been B?

Re: If a = 3be, what is the value of c? [#permalink]
06 Jun 2014, 10:48

Expert's post

faamir wrote:

Bunuel wrote:

faamir wrote:

Hi Bunuel,

Please help me out here. Doesn't 3a = 4b mean a/b=4/3 ? Doesn't this imply a not= 0 and b not= 0. In this case shouldn't the answer be B?

If we are not given that a and b does not equal 0, then from 3a=4b we cannot write a/b=4/3. Because 3a=4b also holds when a=b=0, and in this case a/b=0/0=undefined not 4/3.

Thanks Bunuel.

If instead of the 2nd statement being 3a=4b, we were given a/b=4/3, can we then deduce a not=0 and b not=0 ? Would the answer then have been B?

___________________ Absolutely. From a/b=4/3 it follows that neither of them can be 0. _________________

Great to know you are joining Kellogg. A lot was being talked about your last minute interview on Pagalguy (all good though). It was kinda surprise that you got the...