Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.
Customized for You
we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Track Your Progress
every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance
Practice Pays
we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
It appears that you are browsing the GMAT Club forum unregistered!
Signing up is free, quick, and confidential.
Join other 500,000 members and get the full benefits of GMAT Club
Registration gives you:
Tests
Take 11 tests and quizzes from GMAT Club and leading GMAT prep companies such as Manhattan GMAT,
Knewton, and others. All are free for GMAT Club members.
Applicant Stats
View detailed applicant stats such as GPA, GMAT score, work experience, location, application
status, and more
Books/Downloads
Download thousands of study notes,
question collections, GMAT Club’s
Grammar and Math books.
All are free!
Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:
a-b even: Thus both a, b are both even or both odd
a/b even: Thus a is always even, b could be even or odd!
Combining, if a is even, b has to be even also!
Thus, a = rb where r is even!
1. Always even (rb/2 = even )
2. Could be even or odd.
3. Always integer (even or odd)
4. ODD! (the expression reduces to a/2 +1. a/2 is always even, as shown above, hence even + 1 is odd)
5. reduces to b/2 +1. Result could be even or odd
a-b even: Thus both a, b are both even or both odd a/b even: Thus a is always even, b could be even or odd!
Combining, if a is even, b has to be even also!
Thus, a = rb where r is even!
1. Always even (rb/2 = even ) 2. Could be even or odd. 3. Always integer (even or odd) 4. ODD! (the expression reduces to a/2 +1. a/2 is always even, as shown above, hence even + 1 is odd) 5. reduces to b/2 +1. Result could be even or odd
John,
(a+2)/2 could be even too.
if a = 6, result is even. If a = 8, result is odd.
I tried this problem & I'm not seeing any choice that must be odd
this a = nb where n has a factor or 2 and b also has a factor of 2!
This when a/2, the result shud have a factor of 2. Cos 2 will cancel out either the factor in n or in b. But the other term will still have a factor of 2 left. Thus, a/2 is ALWAYS even!
Last edited by sm176811 on 23 Apr 2006, 03:59, edited 1 time in total.
I guess the explaination given is the best. You need to also try with different combinations. The only thing to note here is that the a>b and that a-b=4 or multiple of 4 else a/b will be odd.
Can you explain me how b can be odd ? Since othervise
b/2 + 1 is always odd.
I just don't get why did you say that when you combined the conditions
you got that b is even or odd?
As I can see it, since b is even when a is even AND since a is indeed even so b is also even.
Can you explain me how b can be odd ? Since othervise b/2 + 1 is always odd.
I just don't get why did you say that when you combined the conditions you got that b is even or odd? As I can see it, since b is even when a is even AND since a is indeed even so b is also even.
Can you please explain your point?
b can be even or odd!! See above.
Its a which is a factor or 4. hence a/2 is always even!
a-b even: Thus both a, b are both even or both odd a/b even: Thus a is always even, b could be even or odd!
Combining, if a is even, b has to be even also!
Thus, a = rb where r is even!
1. Always even (rb/2 = even ) 2. Could be even or odd. 3. Always integer (even or odd) 4. ODD! (the expression reduces to a/2 +1. a/2 is always even, as shown above, hence even + 1 is odd) 5. reduces to b/2 +1. Result could be even or odd
John,
I'm not convinced with your explanation.
Given that
a + b = E -------1
and a/b is E ----2
For 1 to be Even,
either a and b both will be even or both will be odd.
For 2 to be even a must be even but b can be even or odd.
Here only even even case satisfies both condition, that is both a and b must be even.
Hence all answer choice are irrelevant.
a-b even: Thus both a, b are both even or both odd a/b even: Thus a is always even, b could be even or odd!
Combining, if a is even, b has to be even also!
Thus, a = rb where r is even!
1. Always even (rb/2 = even ) 2. Could be even or odd. 3. Always integer (even or odd) 4. ODD! (the expression reduces to a/2 +1. a/2 is always even, as shown above, hence even + 1 is odd) 5. reduces to b/2 +1. Result could be even or odd
John, I'm not convinced with your explanation.
Given that
a + b = E -------1
and a/b is E ----2
For 1 to be Even, either a and b both will be even or both will be odd. For 2 to be even a must be even but b can be even or odd.
Here only even even case satisfies both condition, that is both a and b must be even. Hence all answer choice are irrelevant.
Altough OA is D, but I'm not convince.
Solve for a, b: a - b = even; a/b = even.
Observe that the above equations can only be satisfied for even a and even b.
We would never get an even number on dividing two odd numbers. Also, we would never get an even number if we subtract two odd numbers and divide the two odd numbers and intend to finish with an even number!!
So a = even (say 2m, m is an integer, b = even (say 2n, n is an integer).
Now try the options.
i. a/2 = even*b/2 (as a = even) = even*2n/2 = even (always).
ii. b/2 = even/2 => could be odd or even.
iii. (a+b)/2 = (even + even)/2 = even
iv. (a+2)/2 = (a/2) + 1 = even (from i) + 1 = odd
v. (b+2)/2 = (b/2) +1 = even or odd (asfrom iiwe get b/2 as odd or even)
So the answer is iv. The trick is to note (as John has pointed out) that not only are a and b even but a = even*b = even*even. This implies a/2 is always even. _________________