acedemania wrote:

Hi guys, I'm having abit of a problem trying to comprehend the explaination given by the OG guide on Question 97 DS.

If x is negative, is x<-3

1) x^2 >9

2) x^3 < - 9

My initial answer was D (either one is sufficient). but the books says the correct answer is A (Statement 1 alone is sufficient)

I could understand the explaination that was offered for 1) but not for 2)

Explaination for 2)

Given that x^3 < -9 if x = -4 , then x^3 = - 64. so x^3<-9. and it is true than x <-3. However if x = -3 (this is the part i don't get), then x^3 = -27 and so x^3 <-9 but it is not true that x<-3, NOT SUFFICIENT

What does this mean?? Why are we even considering x=-3 when the question clearly says that x<-3 (therefore the value should be anything less than -3 (Eg -10, -8, -4 etc.).

Clarification much needed

thanks in advance!

Here, it is asking whether x<-3 or not, it's

not an information rather it's

being asked. As far as explanation for letting x=-3 is concerned, when you take x=-3 then x^3=-27 that means for the given information x^3<-9 to be true x can be either x=-3 or x<-3 for values of x=-4 onwards, so from the given information x^3<-9 we can't exactly say whether x<-3 or not, it's not sufficient because it can be either x<-3 or x=-3 so not sufficient. If it was asked "is x<=-3" then the information II x^3<-9 was sufficient.

Hope it helps!

_________________

"Don't be afraid of the space between your dreams and reality. If you can dream it, you can make it so."

Target=780

http://challengemba.blogspot.com

Kudos??