Author
Message
TAGS:
Manager

Joined: 29 Jul 2007

Posts: 183

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
10
[0 ] , given: 0

If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, [#permalink ]
26 Nov 2007, 14:57

If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true?
Ⅰ. x = y
Ⅱ. y = 1
Ⅲ. x and y are prime integers.
A) None
B) Ⅰ only
C) Ⅱ only
D) Ⅲ only
E) Ⅰ and Ⅲ

CEO

Joined: 17 Nov 2007

Posts: 3571

Concentration: Entrepreneurship, Other

Schools: Chicago (Booth) - Class of 2011

GMAT 1 : 750 Q50 V40

Followers: 355

Kudos [? ]:
1730
[0 ] , given: 357

B.
1. if x<y> 3*n - is not a prime. so x=y. suff.
2. for (1,1) y=1 but for (2,2) y=2 insuff.
3. for (2,2) x,y - prime but for (4,4) x,y - not prime. insuff.

CEO

Joined: 29 Aug 2007

Posts: 2501

Followers: 53

Kudos [? ]:
500
[0 ] , given: 19

Skewed wrote:

If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true? Ⅰ. x = y Ⅱ. y = 1 Ⅲ. x and y are prime integers. A) None B) Ⅰ only C) Ⅱ only D) Ⅲ only E) Ⅰ and Ⅲ

must be!!! hmmm.................

ok, then it is B. I only because if x and y are cancelled out then only 3x/y remains a prime.

Manager

Joined: 29 Jul 2007

Posts: 183

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
10
[0 ] , given: 0

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I?
[3*(5/3)]/1= 5
A.

CEO

Joined: 29 Aug 2007

Posts: 2501

Followers: 53

Kudos [? ]:
500
[0 ] , given: 19

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

thats why the question says that y is not equal to 3.

though thats a good point.

CEO

Joined: 17 Nov 2007

Posts: 3571

Concentration: Entrepreneurship, Other

Schools: Chicago (Booth) - Class of 2011

GMAT 1 : 750 Q50 V40

Followers: 355

Kudos [? ]:
1730
[0 ] , given: 357

hm... A is reasonably.

Intern

Joined: 26 Nov 2007

Posts: 1

Followers: 0

Kudos [? ]:
0
[0 ] , given: 0

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

In case I, Y has to be equal to X.

CEO

Joined: 29 Mar 2007

Posts: 2593

Followers: 16

Kudos [? ]:
183
[0 ] , given: 0

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

Thats pretty good.

Tiger he says that (3*5/3)/1 X=5/3. So A looks good.

Director

Joined: 22 Aug 2007

Posts: 573

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
11
[0 ] , given: 0

B it is,
was going to say E..

Director

Joined: 22 Aug 2007

Posts: 573

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
11
[0 ] , given: 0

GMATBLACKBELT wrote:

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

Thats pretty good.

Tiger he says that (3*5/3)/1 X=5/3. So A looks good.

from the question:

3x=y*prime number-----> either y=3 or prime number=3

y is not 3, thus Prime number= 3----> 3x=y3---->x=y, where x and y are not necessarily prime numbers.

Manager

Affiliations: CFA L3 Candidate, Grad w/ Highest Honors

Joined: 03 Nov 2007

Posts: 130

Location: USA

Schools: Chicago Booth R2 (WL) , Wharton R2 w/ int , Kellogg R2 w/ int

WE 1: Global Operations (Futures & Portfolio Financing) - Hedge Fund ($10bn+ Multi-Strat)

WE 2: Investment Analyst (Credit strategies) - Fund of Hedge Fund ($10bn+ Multi-Strat)

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
26
[0 ] , given: 9

Answer is...
Ⅱ only!

Senior Manager

Joined: 06 Aug 2007

Posts: 370

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
21
[0 ] , given: 0

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

Good point was going for B..

Director

Joined: 22 Aug 2007

Posts: 573

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
11
[0 ] , given: 0

Skewed wrote:

What about [(5/3),1] for x,y in case I? [3*(5/3)]/1= 5 A.

it was not mentioned that x is an intenger...missed this point

vote for A

Senior Manager

Joined: 09 Oct 2007

Posts: 468

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
18
[0 ] , given: 1

agh! the simple ones...
how do one avoid felling for these tricks?

Director

Joined: 22 Aug 2007

Posts: 573

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
11
[0 ] , given: 0

asdert wrote:

agh! the simple ones... how do one avoid felling for these tricks?

"assumed to be possible unless stated or proved otherwise"

unless it says that a number is not a ratio, same as to say that a number is an intenger (as in the example above), we can correctly assume that the number is a ratio ..

simple indeed,

i fell for too

Intern

Joined: 25 Nov 2007

Posts: 40

Followers: 0

Kudos [? ]:
6
[0 ] , given: 0

It is A.
x=1/3
Y=1/5
3x/y = 5 which is prime
so x != y

SVP

Joined: 05 Jul 2006

Posts: 1542

Followers: 5

Kudos [? ]:
67
[0 ] , given: 39

If y ≠ 3 and 3x/y is a prime integer greater than 2, which of the following must be true?
Ⅰ. x = y
Ⅱ. y = 1
Ⅲ. x and y are prime integers
for 3x/y to be prime , x/y must = 1
i believe it is A

SVP

Joined: 28 Dec 2005

Posts: 1593

Followers: 2

Kudos [? ]:
68
[0 ] , given: 2

did we get a final consensus on this one ?
I am getting A. Here is why.
Q basically tells us that 3x/y =3,5,7,9, ...
1 says x must equal y. not true, because if 3x/y=5, we just get 3x=5y. not always true
2 says y must be 1. again, from above, we can see it doesnt have to be the case.
3. x and y must be prime. i dont think they do, just by looking at the above.
so since none fit the bill, i went with A

Manager

Joined: 11 Aug 2007

Posts: 65

Followers: 1

Kudos [? ]:
4
[0 ] , given: 0

it is obviously A:
Pick numbers: x=14, y=6
3*14/6=7. None of the choices works. And no restrictions on x=14 and y=6