Statement 1 tells us the sum of expenditures for 4 out of 6 countries. so 67.8% - 56% for 2 of the countries. Statement 1 says that X, if part of the 6, is #5 or #6. We don't know enough to determine what X paid.

Statement 2 says that 4.8% of the expenses were paid by X. But this statement doesn't tell us how 4.8% relates to the whole or any other country's contributions. Insufficient.

To determine if we have enough information together, take 67.8% - 56% to see how much #5 & #6 paid. We get 11.8%. 4.8% is not even half of that, so it is possible that 2 other countries contributed more than 4.8% in order to make up the last of the % of the top 6.

If X had contributed greater than half the 11.8% remaining, then we would know that they were # 5 because there would be no way for 2 other countries to contribute more than X and leave X out. But, since X only contributed 4.8%, then it is possible that some other country paid 4.9% and another country paid 6.9%, thus making the 11.8% + 56% = 67.8% of the top 6, leaving X on the outside of the top 6.

japped187 wrote:

In a certain year the UN`s total expenditures were $1.6 billion. Of this amount, 67.8 % was paid by the 6 highest-contributing countires, and the balance was paid by the remaining 153 countries. Was Country X among the 6 highest-contributing countries?

(1) 56% of the total expenditures was paid by the 4 highest contributing countries, each of which paid more than Country X.

(2) Country X paid 4.8 % of the total expenditures.

The answer E, please explain

_________________

------------------------------------

J Allen Morris

**I'm pretty sure I'm right, but then again, I'm just a guy with his head up his a$$.

GMAT Club Premium Membership - big benefits and savings