NEW HERE? LEARN MORE
closeclose
Last visit was: 25 Apr 2024, 01:55 It is currently 25 Apr 2024, 01:55
Decision Tracker
My Rewards
New posts
New comers' posts

Close
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track
Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.
Go to My Error Log Learn more
Close
Request Expert Reply
Confirm Cancel

In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many

SORT BY:
Date
Kudos
Tags:
Find Similar Topics 
Show Tags
Hide Tags
User avatar
dixitraghav
Manager
Manager
Joined: 16 Feb 2010
Posts: 77
Own Kudos [?]: 128 [29]
Given Kudos: 17
Send PM
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   Updated on: 11 Oct 2017, 22:52
3
Kudos
26
Bookmarks
00:00
A
B
C
D
E

Difficulty:

55% (hard)

Question Stats:

62% (01:48) correct 38% (01:55) wrong based on 1252 sessions
Hide Show timer Statistics
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.
ShowHide Answer
Official Answer
E

Originally posted by dixitraghav on 30 May 2010, 10:06.
Last edited by Mahmud6 on 11 Oct 2017, 22:52, edited 2 times in total.
OA not provided
User avatar
B
dimitri92
Manager
Manager
Joined: 15 Nov 2006
Affiliations: SPG
Posts: 232
Own Kudos [?]: 3137 [0]
Given Kudos: 34
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   30 May 2010, 10:14
I would go with D. This is strongly related to the conclusion.
User avatar
madeinafrica
Current Student
Joined: 20 Jul 2009
Affiliations: ?
Posts: 132
Own Kudos [?]: 73 [0]
Given Kudos: 6
Location: Africa/Europe
Concentration: Entrepreneurship, Finance, Strategy
Schools:Kellogg; Ross ($$); Tuck
 Q48  V38
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   30 May 2010, 11:10
For me it's A or E.

One monk made a mistake and the result is ALL subsequent copies will be corrected. was this monk the only one to make the subsequent copies? mabe a copy existed before the Middle Ages....

If this monk made all the copies, can we traced them back for correction?..hum

I think I will go for A

OA?
User avatar
ykaiim
Director
Director
Joined: 25 Aug 2007
Posts: 520
Own Kudos [?]: 5422 [4]
Given Kudos: 40
WE 1: 3.5 yrs IT
WE 2: 2.5 yrs Retail chain
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   31 May 2010, 23:13
4
Kudos
Please dont post the OA so early.

IMO E.
This is an Defender Assumption based question.

When you read the stimulus you will find that the author has presented his views fairly without missing some key assumptions. But, in the end, he makes a broad generalization based conclusion. We are asked to support the conclusion with an additional premise which is stated in E.

E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.

If you negate this, it will become:
All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic cannot be traced back to the flawed copy.

If the copies cannot be traced back then how can all copies be corrected. The conclusion fals apart.


dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.
avatar
smartmanav
Intern
Intern
Joined: 18 Jun 2012
Posts: 28
Own Kudos [?]: 18 [0]
Given Kudos: 15
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   01 Aug 2013, 08:01
ykaiim wrote:
Please dont post the OA so early.

IMO E.
This is an Defender Assumption based question.

When you read the stimulus you will find that the author has presented his views fairly without missing some key assumptions. But, in the end, he makes a broad generalization based conclusion. We are asked to support the conclusion with an additional premise which is stated in E.

E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.

If you negate this, it will become:
All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic cannot be traced back to the flawed copy.

If the copies cannot be traced back then how can all copies be corrected. The conclusion fals apart.


dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.


Lets look at A

Lets say some copies of Plato's republic predates Middle ages , that means "NOT ALL" copies needs to be replaced and again the conclusion is destroyed. What do you have to say about it ?
User avatar
MzJavert
Manager
Manager
Joined: 22 Apr 2013
Posts: 71
Own Kudos [?]: 56 [4]
Given Kudos: 95
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   01 Aug 2013, 08:30
3
Kudos
1
Bookmarks
dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.



A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages. At least one copy, prior to the mistake copy, has to exist or it's unlikely that the mistake would have been found.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected. The question stem only covers Plato's Republic.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text. Again already covered in the question stem.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week. Stated in the question stem.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy. Not previous included in the question stem. The fact all copies can be traced to the flawed copy is important information supporting the conclusion.
avatar
adityapagadala
Intern
Intern
Joined: 29 Jan 2013
Posts: 25
Own Kudos [?]: 114 [0]
Given Kudos: 24
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   22 Aug 2013, 02:56
smartmanav wrote:
ykaiim wrote:
Please dont post the OA so early.

IMO E.
This is an Defender Assumption based question.

When you read the stimulus you will find that the author has presented his views fairly without missing some key assumptions. But, in the end, he makes a broad generalization based conclusion. We are asked to support the conclusion with an additional premise which is stated in E.

E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.

If you negate this, it will become:
All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic cannot be traced back to the flawed copy.

If the copies cannot be traced back then how can all copies be corrected. The conclusion fals apart.


dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.


Lets look at A

Lets say some copies of Plato's republic predates Middle ages , that means "NOT ALL" copies needs to be replaced and again the conclusion is destroyed. What do you have to say about it ?



The author clearly mentioned 'All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.' The copies which are prior to medival age need not be corrected.

But i dont think that E is correct one too... the author simply stated that books need to be corrected, how these books can be corrected, is it possible or not is out of scope here
User avatar
KapTeacherEli
Kaplan GMAT Instructor
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
Posts: 613
Own Kudos [?]: 645 [3]
Given Kudos: 2
Location: Cambridge, MA
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   22 Aug 2013, 19:12
3
Kudos
Expert Reply
adityapagadala wrote:
The author clearly mentioned 'All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.' The copies which are prior to medival age need not be corrected.

But i dont think that E is correct one too... the author simply stated that books need to be corrected, how these books can be corrected, is it possible or not is out of scope here

The author thinks the books must be corrected because of an error in a single medieval copy. If some books didn't stem from that copy, then those books won't have the monk's error, and won't need correcting! Thus, the information in choice (E) is necessary for the author's conclusion to hold--without it, we have no reason to fix any copies that trace their lineage to a different monastery.

Hope this helps!
avatar
B
hacker
Manager
Manager
Joined: 08 Mar 2010
Status:Bouncing back from failure
Posts: 54
Own Kudos [?]: 77 [0]
Given Kudos: 40
Concentration: SCM, Strategy, General Management
Schools:Wharton,MIT, Tepper, Kelly,
 Q48  V26
WE 1: 7 years- Service Managament, poject Management, Business Consultant- Retail
Send PM
Reviews Badge
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   27 May 2014, 01:55
dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?
A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.


"All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected" - author's reasoning of the correction. Author is not concluding on how to implement the correction.
However, option E -"All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy" this option tells how to implement the fix. and Implementing the correction is out of scope.

Please help me to understand.
User avatar
schazamhuzzah
Intern
Intern
Joined: 05 Nov 2014
Status:I am ready!
Posts: 35
Own Kudos [?]: 13 [0]
Given Kudos: 362
Location: India
GMAT 1: 700 Q49 V35
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   02 Jun 2015, 12:48
Let's look at d & e as others can be eliminated easily..
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
If no one has ever noticed this before then obviously all subsequent books of this lineage need to be corrected(whether there are only a few or many or none or whether they can be traced or not is a whole different matter)


E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy
What if some one has observed this mistake before and has already corrected it before any subsequent copies were even made?


EDIT: Its crystal clear to me now. Answer is definitely 'E'.. thank you all for the nice discussions.
User avatar
S
brs1cob
Manager
Manager
Joined: 06 Jun 2013
Posts: 122
Own Kudos [?]: 37 [0]
Given Kudos: 339
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, Economics
Schools: Tuck
GMAT 1: 640 Q49 V30
GPA: 3.6
WE:Engineering (Computer Software)
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   23 Jul 2017, 09:21
E is the correct answer as it talks about the subsequent copies of Plato's Republic that can be traced back to the flawed copy.
and the conclusion says all these flawed copies need to be corrected.
User avatar
S
Neverbackdown25
Kelley School Moderator
Joined: 11 Nov 2014
Posts: 307
Own Kudos [?]: 89 [0]
Given Kudos: 48
Location: India
Concentration: Operations, Strategy
Schools: W.P. Carey (A$$$$) Fisher '25 (WD)
GMAT 1: 620 Q47 V29
GMAT 2: 730 Q50 V39
GPA: 3.69
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   24 Jun 2019, 21:16
ykaiim wrote:
Please dont post the OA so early.

IMO E.
This is an Defender Assumption based question.

When you read the stimulus you will find that the author has presented his views fairly without missing some key assumptions. But, in the end, he makes a broad generalization based conclusion. We are asked to support the conclusion with an additional premise which is stated in E.

E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.

If you negate this, it will become:
All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic cannot be traced back to the flawed copy.

If the copies cannot be traced back then how can all copies be corrected. The conclusion fals apart.


dixitraghav wrote:
In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many of the great works of Antiquity. They maintained these works in their libraries and spent many hours transcribing them for distribution to other monasteries. However, last week a Classics scholar discovered that a monk had consistently miscopied a word while transcribing Plato's Republic, thereby altering the meaning of the entire text. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.

The conclusion above would be more reasonably drawn if which of the following were inserted into the argument as an additional premise?

A. No copy of Plato's Republic predates the Middle Ages.
B. Only Plato's Republic needs to be corrected.
C. A single word can alter the meaning of an entire text.
D. No one had ever noticed the mistake before last week.
E. All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic can be traced back to the flawed copy.


Posted from my mobile device
avatar
anubhavgdel
Intern
Intern
Joined: 08 Feb 2019
Posts: 1
Own Kudos [?]: 0 [0]
Given Kudos: 0
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   01 Jul 2019, 01:58
Hi Eli Mayer,

Can you please explain why "C" is incorrect?

Is it incorrect simply because it is stated in the passage as a fact? By the negation technique, if a single word does not alter the meaning of the text, then there will be no need for any amendments in any of the copies.

Please advise.



KapTeacherEli wrote:
adityapagadala wrote:
The author clearly mentioned 'All subsequent copies of Plato's Republic will now have to be corrected.' The copies which are prior to medival age need not be corrected.

But i dont think that E is correct one too... the author simply stated that books need to be corrected, how these books can be corrected, is it possible or not is out of scope here

The author thinks the books must be corrected because of an error in a single medieval copy. If some books didn't stem from that copy, then those books won't have the monk's error, and won't need correcting! Thus, the information in choice (E) is necessary for the author's conclusion to hold--without it, we have no reason to fix any copies that trace their lineage to a different monastery.

Hope this helps!
User avatar
VerbalBot
Non-Human User
Joined: 01 Oct 2013
Posts: 17215
Own Kudos [?]: 848 [0]
Given Kudos: 0
Send PM
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink] New post   15 May 2022, 13:59
Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
GMAT Club Bot
gmatclubot
Re: In the Middle Ages, monks possessed the only copies of many [#permalink]
15 May 2022, 13:59
Moderators:
GMATNinja
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
6920 posts
GMATNinjaTwo
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
238 posts
mysterymanrog
CR Forum Moderator
832 posts

Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group | Emoji artwork provided by EmojiOne
Main navigation
GMAT Resources
Partners
MBA Resources
www.gmac.com|www.mba.com | | GMAT Club Rules | Terms and Conditions