Congrats on getting into such great schools, I wish I had your problem!
I would rank it Columbia, Haas, Kellogg. It would be easier/cheaper to go interview from Columbia, and their finance alum network is phenomenal. I work with a Columbia 2nd year MBA student, and he is one of the best co-workers I've had.
If you are set on finance, I would definitely pick Columbia. I see less Kellogg MBA in finance, maybe that's just me, they seem to be more in industry or marketing.
How can you be sick of NYC, it's the greatest city in the world!
If you liked my post, please consider thanking me with Kudos! I really appreciate it!