Gmat760sanskar wrote:
Please explain difference between Option A and Option D.
Here's the passage:
Obviously, we cannot in any real sense mistreat plants. Plants do not have nervous systems, and having a nervous system is necessary to experience pain.We see that the conclusion is about what cannot be done, "We cannot ... mistreat plants." The support for the conclusion is, basically, that plants do not have nervous systems therefore cannot experience pain.
So, the point is that the fact that something cannot experience pain supports the conclusion that it cannot be mistreated.
We need an assumption that connects the evidence that plants cannot experience pain to the conclusion that we cannot mistreat plants.
In other words, we need something that means that being able to experience pain is necessary for being able to be mistreated.
Now, let's compare (A) and (D).
(A) Any organism that can experience pain can be mistreated.This statement does not help to complete the argument.
Notice that, even if this statement is true, it does not mean that a plant cannot be mistreated.
After all, the fact that an organism that CAN experience pain CAN be mistreated doesn't mean that an organism that CANNOT experience pain CANNOT be mistreated.
In other words, given what this statement says, it could be that any organism that experiences pain, along with some organisms that cannot, can be mistreated.
So, (A) doesn't do what we need.
Now, let's consider (D).
(D) Only organisms that can experience pain can be mistreated.Notice that, if "Only organisms that can experience pain can be mistreated," then organisms that cannot experience pain cannot be mistreated.
So, this choice does just what we need.
It completes the argument as follows:
Plants do not have nervous systems, and having a nervous system is necessary to experience pain. Only organisms that can experience pain can be mistreated (meaning organisms that cannot experience pain cannot be mistreated. Obviously (therefore), we cannot in any real sense mistreat plants.So, the correct answer is (D).