I think it would be helpful to the readers if I posted my conversations with Tuck adcom on the matter.
neo656 (applying to Tuck Round 1) commented on Tuck (view comment thread)Hi Guys
Any clue what would be the effect on my candidacy if I do not waive off my right to to see the recommendation? Does it even matter to Tuck adcom or not?
Tuck Admissions (Member of the Tuck Admissions Committee) replied Hi neo656 - By not waiving your right, it might raise a question that you had a hand in writing your own recommendation. The majority of applicants DO waive their right to see their LOR.
neo656 (applying to Tuck Round 1) replied Hi Adcom Member,
Thanks for the advice! Good for me I waived off the right in second reco too.
But I am confused, because a curious person who has not seen his LOR or had a hand in writing it might be tempted to see it and hence waiver right shouldn't raise a red flag. Regardless, your advice comes in a good time. I'll post it on the other forums too.
Cheers
Tuck Admissions (Member of the Tuck Admissions Committee) replied I know it's tempting! While we do like to give people the benefit of the doubt, it's important to be cautious. Additionally, if your recommender knows you'll see the letter, they may be less inclined to be as candid as they would be knowing it was private. Thanks for the question!
neo656 (applying to Tuck Round 1) replied Thanks for the reply!