Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

It appears that you are browsing the GMAT Club forum unregistered!

Signing up is free, quick, and confidential.
Join other 500,000 members and get the full benefits of GMAT Club

Registration gives you:

Tests

Take 11 tests and quizzes from GMAT Club and leading GMAT prep companies such as Manhattan GMAT,
Knewton, and others. All are free for GMAT Club members.

Applicant Stats

View detailed applicant stats such as GPA, GMAT score, work experience, location, application
status, and more

Books/Downloads

Download thousands of study notes,
question collections, GMAT Club’s
Grammar and Math books.
All are free!

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

please help me in understanding how this question can be sol [#permalink]

Show Tags

17 Feb 2013, 02:17

THis is a question from Mgmat cat

The Marsden family is traveling through Europe on vacation and has two days to spend in Barcelona. While planning the daily activities, each family member has fairly strong preferences. Little brother asked to go to the beach at least one of the days, but cannot walk for more than 4 hours during a day. Mom loves shopping for local crafts so requested shopping activities on both days. Big sister will get credit for school so she must visit at least 4 art or architectural sites during the family’s visit, but Dad said he could not stand to visit more than one art exhibit on a single day. The family has 12 hours each day to devote to activities, and they have already decided on the following.

Day 1: Park Güell (Art Exhibit, Bicycle, 3 hours) Catalunya en Miniatura (Entertainment, Walking, 1 hour) Olympic Stadium (Sightseeing, Bicycle Tour, 4 hours) Las Ramblas (Shopping, Bus Tour, 3 hours)

Day 2: La Segrada Familia (Architecture, Walking, 3 hours) Barri Gotico (Shopping, Bicycle Tour, 2 hours) Aeri del Port (Sightseeing, Cable Car, 4 hours) Nova Icària (Beach, Walking, 1 hour)

Select an activity that can be added to the schedule for the first day. Then select an activity that could be added to the schedule for the second day. Make only two selections, one in each column.

Additional Day 1 Additional Day 2 Activity Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) Poble Espanyol (Shopping, Walking 2 hours) Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) Museu Picasso (Art Museum, Walking, 2 hours) Mar Bella (Ocean, Boat Outing, 4 hours) La Pedrera (Art Museum, Walking, 1 hours)

Re: please help me in understanding how this question can be sol [#permalink]

Show Tags

18 Feb 2013, 10:55

Hello,

Are you sure that this question is legit and picked directly from MGMAT CAT? Somehow the constraints and the answer options don't fit together well.

The first day the family is left with an option of going to visit some architecture that might or might not involve 1 hour of walk(since 3 hours of walk is already completed). The second day the family can visit an art center or art museum that involves no walking as 4 hours of walking has already been completed(architecture and beach). They need to complete both activities since sister needs at least 4 hours of art/architecture visit and only by visiting these sites will they be able to accomplish that goal(they have already charted out the plan for one art museum and one visit to a piece of architecture). On the first day they can visit an architectural site with a one hour walk ( Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour)). However, there is no option that involves a visit to an art museum without walking.

It would be great if you could reconfirm the question.

siddharth86 wrote:

THis is a question from Mgmat cat

The Marsden family is traveling through Europe on vacation and has two days to spend in Barcelona. While planning the daily activities, each family member has fairly strong preferences. Little brother asked to go to the beach at least one of the days, but cannot walk for more than 4 hours during a day. Mom loves shopping for local crafts so requested shopping activities on both days. Big sister will get credit for school so she must visit at least 4 art or architectural sites during the family’s visit, but Dad said he could not stand to visit more than one art exhibit on a single day. The family has 12 hours each day to devote to activities, and they have already decided on the following.

Day 1: Park Güell (Art Exhibit, Bicycle, 3 hours) Catalunya en Miniatura (Entertainment, Walking, 1 hour) Olympic Stadium (Sightseeing, Bicycle Tour, 4 hours) Las Ramblas (Shopping, Bus Tour, 3 hours)

Day 2: La Segrada Familia (Architecture, Walking, 3 hours) Barri Gotico (Shopping, Bicycle Tour, 2 hours) Aeri del Port (Sightseeing, Cable Car, 4 hours) Nova Icària (Beach, Walking, 1 hour)

Select an activity that can be added to the schedule for the first day. Then select an activity that could be added to the schedule for the second day. Make only two selections, one in each column.

Additional Day 1 Additional Day 2 Activity Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) Poble Espanyol (Shopping, Walking 2 hours) Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) Museu Picasso (Art Museum, Walking, 2 hours) Mar Bella (Ocean, Boat Outing, 4 hours) La Pedrera (Art Museum, Walking, 1 hours)

Re: please help me in understanding how this question can be sol [#permalink]

Show Tags

29 Mar 2013, 16:24

our constraints are: Mom shopping: 1 or both days Lil Bro cant walk more than 4 hrs any day + must go to BEACH either 1 or both days big Sis to visit 4 arch sites but Dad cant stand more than 1 art exhibit a day DAY 1 Park Güell (Art Exhibit, Bicycle, 3 hours) Catalunya en Miniatura (Entertainment, Walking, 1 hour) Olympic Stadium (Sightseeing, Bicycle Tour, 4 hours) Las Ramblas (Shopping, Bus Tour, 3 hours)

we have 1 extra hour to spend what more can we accomodate? can WALK for 3 hrs or we CANT accomodate - No more ART EXHIBIT, No more SHOPPING

of the choices, Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) - oUT NO WALKING Poble Espanyol (Shopping, Walking 2 hours) - oUT NO WALKING Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) - WINS Museu Picasso (Art Museum, Walking, 2 hours) - OUT NO WALKING Mar Bella (Ocean, Boat Outing, 4 hours) - OUT only have 1 more hour to spend for the day La Pedrera (Art Museum, Walking, 1 hours) -OUT NO WALKING

Hence Montserrat for Day 1.

For DAy 2: LaSegrada Familia (Architecture, Walking, 3 hours) Barri Gotico (Shopping, Bicycle Tour, 2 hours) Aeri del Port (Sightseeing, Cable Car, 4 hours) Nova Icària (Beach, Walking, 1 hour)

We have 2 extra hours to spend. what we CAN accomodate: ART EXHIBIT What we CANNOT accomodate: NO MORE WALKING, NO SHOPPING

Of the answer choices: Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) - OUT for walking Poble Espanyol (Shopping, Walking 2 hours) -OUT for walking Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) ONLY OPTION that remains GOOD Museu Picasso (Art Museum, Walking, 2 hours) -OUT for walking Mar Bella (Ocean, Boat Outing, 4 hours) - OUT for no of hours available to spend La Pedrera (Art Museum, Walking, 1 hours) - OUT for walking

For day 2 also we have only Montserrat left. however it only uses 1 hour out of 2 available. not the best answer choice but only one that stays valid after all eliminations.

Re: please help me in understanding how this question can be sol [#permalink]

Show Tags

12 Apr 2013, 23:53

Day 1: Marbella (no walking required, little brother must go to beach either or both days) Day 2: Montserrat (sister's architectural sightseeing requirement satisfied)

Re: please help me in understanding how this question can be sol [#permalink]

Show Tags

14 Apr 2013, 09:26

1

This post received KUDOS

Hi,

first to analyze the given data

Day 1: Park Güell (Art Exhibit, Bicycle, 3 hours) Catalunya en Miniatura (Entertainment, Walking, 1 hour) Olympic Stadium (Sightseeing, Bicycle Tour, 4 hours) Las Ramblas (Shopping, Bus Tour, 3 hours)

Activities schedules are for 11 hrs(3+1+4+3) so we cannot select a >1 hr activity Also the activities scheduled already have walking for 1 hrs (Catalunya en Miniatura ) so activities selected can have at most 3 hrs walking shopping activity required by mom has already been done. Already involves a Art Exhibit visit so cannot have any art musuem visit

evaluating available options: Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) Poble Espanyol (Shopping, Walking 2 hours) : >1 hr activity Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) Museu Picasso (Art Museum, Walking, 2 hours) : >1 hr activity Mar Bella (Ocean, Boat Outing, 4 hours) : >1 hr activity La Pedrera (Art Museum, Walking, 1 hours) : 1 art exhibit activity already done on the day

Available options for Day 1 Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours)

Day 2: La Segrada Familia (Architecture, Walking, 3 hours) Barri Gotico (Shopping, Bicycle Tour, 2 hours) Aeri del Port (Sightseeing, Cable Car, 4 hours) Nova Icària (Beach, Walking, 1 hour)

Activities schedules are for 10 hrs(3+2+4+1) so we cannot select any activity >2 hr Also the activities scheduled already have walking for 4 hrs (La Segrada Familia and Nova Icària) so we cannot have any activity that involves walking shopping activity required by mom has already been done . The visit to Beach is scheduled so little brother's stipulation for beach visit on atleast one day is met.

So for day 2 only available activity is : Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours)

Coming back to Day 1 available options Mirador De Colon (Architecture, Walking, 1 hour) Montserrat (Sightseeing, Bus Tour, 1 hours) :Day 2 Activity

Hence Day 1 activity is Mirador De Colon and Day 2 activity is Montserrat

This was the logical conclusion i came up with but only problem is that With this answer only 3 art or Architecture visits are made not the 4 art or Architecture visits

Also the 4 art or Architecture visits cannot be achieved with given data as: for Day1 art exhibit is already scheduled so we can have only architecture visits for day 2 architecture visit is already scheduled and the listed art museum options both involve walking whereas the scheduled activities for day 2 already involve 4 hrs of walking so given the constraint that little brother cannot walk for at max 4 hrs we cannot select art museum visit for Day2

Kudos if you find the post helpful

gmatclubot

Re: please help me in understanding how this question can be sol
[#permalink]
14 Apr 2013, 09:26