admitkid07 wrote:
alphanumericman wrote:
admitkid07 wrote:
Just finished my on campus interview today as well. Had a great visit. My only qualm was that my interviewer had experience just totally unrelated to what I do and want to do. I think they just randomly assign on campus interviewees with students. Oh well, I honestly don't think they put much weight on the interviews, as long as you are not unprofessional. The rest of the visit was great!
I'm sorry, but I don't think any shared professional experience is required to conduct an effective MBA admissions interview. In fact it would be better for the interviewer to have very little in common with you, because it forces you to communicate clearly and effectively.
Sent from my iPhone using
GMAT Club Forum mobile appI'm going to totally disagree with you. Like others have said, when your experiences are so disparate, it's hard to ask meaningful questions and get a real sense of the applicants work experience. What might be a huge accomplishment in your industry may seem minor to them. Of course, it is your job to communicate and describe what you do as clearly as possible. But that can be very difficult when they already have a set number of questions they need to ask you in 30 minutes.
Personally, I'd much prefer being interviewed by someone who's not too familiar with my background. This definitely makes explaining your accomplishments more challenging, but allows you to focus more on the behavioural aspects of your successes and failures without getting carried away and spending too much time elaborating on the technical details.
I think the Admissions Committee (particularly at Yale) is looking to better understand your motivations and the rationale behind your decision making more than simply your accolades. And I don't think industry or background really factors in that much there. It's also more fulfilling in a way: if you can convince someone who comes from a very different place that you're a great fit for the school, you probably are. Your résumé, essays, and the rest of your file already provide enough insights into your accomplishments; so I think the interview is a great opportunity to focus on the reasoning more than on the facts already known to members of the school.
For the reasons mentioned above, I'd personally pick being interviewed by someone from the admissions committee over someone who's shared a similar industry/career trajectory with me.
Sent from my Mi 4i using
GMAT Club Forum mobile app