She was less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta compared

Answer is option C..
All the other options are comparing the cities but not the success in those cities...

Answer has to be "C"

a) Using "had" changes the meaning that She moved to Calcutta first then to her native place.

b) same as A...Also Less....then missing

c) correct, had is placed correctly before her native place.
d) it should show first she was in Bangladesh then she moved to Calcutta, Past perfect is required. Also Less....than (missing)
e) This shows she was less successful before moving to Calcutta, which is not the intended meaning.


Thanks

A) She was less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta compared to
B) Being less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta as compared to
C) Less successful after she emigrated to Calcutta than she had been in
D) Although she was less successful after emigrating to Calcutta when compared to
E) She had been less successful after emigrating to Calcutta than in


"Compared to" here compares the person with 'native Bangladesh' which is incorrect and not the meaning of this sentence
A,B and D can be eliminated

E sort of focuses more on the fragment that she was less successful after emigrating to Calcutta

Whereas the crux is, even though she was less successful after emigrating to calcutta, she earned admirers and publications in India

This is best expressed by C, Hence IMO C

A) She was less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta compared to - Run on Sentence
B) Being less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta as compared to - As compared to is wrong construction
C) Less successful after she emigrated to Calcutta than she had been in - Correctly modifies the Taslima Nasreen
D) Although she was less successful after emigrating to Calcutta when compared to - When compared to is wrong construction
E) She had been less successful after emigrating to Calcutta than in - Changes the meaning.

So C is correct

A) She was less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta compared to-
Wrong comparison of career with city/nation.
Two complete clauses connected with a comma..A clear run on

B) Being less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta as compared to-

Incorrect usage of being:Being" is the present-tense form of the verb "to be"; you'd use it when something is currently (but not always) happening..this is not the case here with "less successful" here.,,Also as a rule you should always avoid being in the gmat..
Wrong comparison of career with city/nation.

C) Less successful after she emigrated to Calcutta than she had been in

Correct comparison..Correct usage of perfect tense as the time contrast is necessary..Correctly modifies Author..

D) Although she was less successful after emigrating to Calcutta when compared to

Although & Nevertheless - Redundancy
Wrong Comparison again

E) She had been less successful after emigrating to Calcutta than in

Two complete clauses connected with a comma..A clear run on
Other previous issues as well

A - We need to compare success with success or place to a place. However the given sentence compares success Less successful) to place (Bangladesh). Hence it is wrong

B - The same problem with A is there in B. The comparison is not proper (Moreover a yellow light should glow as soon as words such as "being" is used)

C - Perfect. The comparison is with her success in Calcutta to the same in Bangladesh.

D - The same problem with A is there in D. The comparison is not proper . Moreover although gives us anticipation that the things that would come next would help strengthen the part after although. For eg: Although he's not so studious, James scored a 780 on the GMAT.

E - The same problem with A is there in E. The comparison is not proper. Moreover had been has just made it more difficult. Without any simple verb, this sentence is "poor construction" and nothing else

The statement uses a comparative degree, hence 'than' is essential.
E changes the meaning.
And by all means, C fits the bill.

~
Sony

Hi, option C is correct choice.

Let's walk through all the given options to dig deep as to why these choices are wrong.

A) She was less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta compared to --- Run on Sentence as two Independent clauses are connected by comma

B) Being less successful after she had emigrated to Calcutta as compared to ---- The word "Being" can be used in two contexts
1) Being is used as a noun to introduce something
2) when used to express in passive form.
Option B satisfies neither one nor two . Apart from this Being is always considered wrong in gmat land( blind thumb rule).

D) Although she was less successful after emigrating to Calcutta when compared to
Words like "Although" are used to bring contrast, but nothing is present in sentence that brings contrast. There is also redundancy issue between Although and Nevertheless.

E) She had been less successful after emigrating to Calcutta than in -- Two IC's connected just by a comma ---- Run on Sentence.

C) Less successful after she emigrated to Calcutta than she had been in
"Less successful after she emigrated to Calcutta than she had been in" is correctly modifying author "Taslima Nasreen" . Correct usage of Modifier.

Hence Correct Answer is C

Hope you are still accepting answers for this...Here's my take

Right answer is C,
A is wrong b/c of Tenses and idiomatic error...
tenses: had is used for earlier past ordered - event but here its used for Emigration (latter event ).
idiom: Right idiom is as compared to/ as compared with ...therefore "compared to" is wrong here.
B is wrong b/c of tenses(same as A) and b/c passive "Being" is garbled with active voice.
D is wrong b/c of wrong continuous tense usage (i.e emigrating) for facts and wrong Idiomatic usage of "when compared to"
E is wrong b/c of wrong continuous tense usage (i.e emigrating) for facts and illogical comparison

Hi Bunuel and souvik101990,

Is this contest still on

Ok first thing first whenever we are talking about two events which happened in past, we use "had" or past perfect tense to denote to the event which happened earlier in those two events.
e.g: I had already eaten when the Pizza delivery guy came.

Whenever you see "had" in underlined part, you should try to find another event which happened in the past. Ad decide two things:
1. Did both the events happen in the past.
2. Which one of the events happened first(because that Event and only that Event can use "had")

II. Compared to/with is a correct idiom and is used to compare two things. Now In any comparison question such as this, you should always establish the goal of the comparison: ask yourself what is being compared. Here you are trying to compare the effect of Emigration when she moved to Calcutta from Bangladesh.

III When/As Compared to/With is Incorrect usage of the idiom

________________
No, it's not.

Although it doesn't affect the correct option, the translated in all over India at the end is incorrect.

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.