I think you have a great profile. Solid GMAT, good GPA, great extracurricular activities, feasible career goals, probably strong letters of recommendation... If I were you, I'd maybe even apply to another top 10 school aside from Duke. Seems like you want to stay on the eastcoast. Maybe Tuck or Stern could be a potential 5th school.
MBAvolunteers - Application feedback & interview preps in exchange for a donation to a non-profit