recommender with gmail address

That should not be a problem. Because supervisors themselves have concerns some times. They might not want the senior management to know that they recommended their subordinates to top-schools (helped quit their organizations). And official ids reveal this info. IT department guys have access to all official mails.

I am sure schools appreciate such concerns.

you guys think I should ask the ad com officers abt this when I meet them??

sangoman,

You can ask, but honestly I don't think it should matter. A rec is a rec, and if schools want to contact a recommender then they can.

I seem to remember that they are more likely to contact a recommender if s/he has a generic email, but who cares? You're legit, so don't worry. It's really not a big deal.

I know both my recommendations are going to be from generic email addresses. Where I work our email is strictly for business, its all tracked due to the nature of what we do as is internet use.

Since recommendations are most likely done on personal time I doubt schools care about the email address. As long as your boss doesn't have something very inappropriate for an address. You can always ask to give yourself piece of mind...I know its a lot to ask for anyone to give a recommendation so I am not going to complain if they want to do it from an AOL account.

My application is going through a gmail account, my wife is the only person outside of my work that actually knows my work email address.

I'll add one more opinion that email isn't going to matter. Both my recommenders preferred the forms to be sent to their home email addresses instead of their company emails. So I have a yahoo and a comcast account, respectively.

sorry junta,

did not follow the golden rule of being nice.

Thank you all for your opinions........most of you got it right - the crrect answer is that it just dosent matter - an that is the bottom line cause Thomas Caleel said so.

(bonus marks for whoever said that its cause they take other contact info from the recommender)

Thanks again