If you're limited to the midwest, then there's not a lot of options.
Try Chicago Booth as your stretch school. Other schools to look at in the area would be Indiana and Purdue. Or Michigan. Any of these schools you should have no problems getting into. Booth will be a stretch, but where it's worth at least giving it a shot. If you're looking for finance careers, there's always Columbia and NYU if there's any way you can be more mobile.
Follow me on Facebook