nave81 wrote:

Is this really a 700 question? seemed too easy

Well, when I post a question, the GC system makes me guess on the difficulty ---- take that as a guess, no more. It's true, if you are fluent combinatorics and counting problems, this problem is a breeze, but folks who are not particular adroit at counting might start, for example, listing all possibilities. All math is impossibly difficult when you don't see how to do it, and trivially easy when you do, and that's doubly true for counting problems. I was basing my guess of the difficulty on the frequency of questions I see about such topics. If this question was easy for you,

nave81, that may reflect more on your talent than on the nature of the question.

PiyushK wrote:

Question states as following, thus I am not able to understand why others are considering GAB as a possible arrangement.

"Child A has to sit next to both B & G, with these two children immediately adjacent to Child A on either side."

As per my understanding I am able to figure out following possible arrangements.

[BGA] C D E F = 5! permutations.

[ABG] C D E F = 5!

[GBA] C D E F = 5!

[AGB] C D E F = 5!

120 x 4 = 480 arrangements, I got this, is it right ?

Dear

PiyushK,

I regret to tell you, sir, that you are misreading the question. The wording here is tricky.

Child A has to sit next to both B & G, with these two children immediately adjacent to Child A on either side.

These "

two children" are B & G, and each one of them is adjacent to A ---- thus BGA & AGB are not a possibilities because B is not adjacent to A, and ABG & GBA are not possibilities because G is not adjacent to A. The wording implies that B must be adjacent to A and that G must be adjacent to A, and that these two are on "

either side" of A, that is

on opposite sides of A. All four of your cases had B adjacent to G, not a requirement, and had them both on the same side of A, which contradicts the condition given in the text.

That's an example of a math idiom --- "

on either side of A" --- this means that the two items in question, B & G, cannot possibly be on the same side of A; they must be on opposites sides of A.

Does all this make sense?

Mike

_________________

Mike McGarry

Magoosh Test Prep