I have 2 choices for who writes my peer recommendation letter. I'd like the gmat club's members advice on who I should get.
1. I've worked with this guy for 9 months. He now works at another company. He said that he would write a strong recommendation, but I'm not so sure what he would say.
2. I've worked with this new guy at my current work for 3 months. I've been training him and working really close with him. I know for sure that he would write me a Stellar recommendaion.
Who should I pick? I would go with 2, but I haven't worked with him long enough. Would the adcomm not like this?
I'd go with whoever is going to write the better rec and is going to have more to say about you. The person that can't think of anything is going to write a shite rec. I'd be very scared of a rec where I "didnt know what they might say". I'd rather get one from someone thats only worked with me for 3 months and rocks than one from 9 months and might just be good.
Plus, he can address the 3 months thing : "Although I've only worked with him for 3 months, we interact daily, often numerous times a day on a variety of different subjects and bla bla"