Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though : GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR)
Check GMAT Club App Tracker for the Latest School Decision Releases http://gmatclub.com/AppTrack

 It is currently 08 Dec 2016, 00:03

### GMAT Club Daily Prep

#### Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

# Events & Promotions

###### Events & Promotions in June
Open Detailed Calendar

# Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though

Author Message
TAGS:

### Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2003
Posts: 247
Location: USA
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 6 [1] , given: 0

Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though [#permalink]

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 04:21
1
KUDOS
00:00

Difficulty:

(N/A)

Question Stats:

100% (03:13) correct 0% (00:00) wrong based on 5 sessions

### HideShow timer Statistics

Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though they are not speaking to each other. Cecily, the club president, is appointing members to the fundraising committee, but she has resolved that she will not appoint anyone without his or her explicit consent. Steve tells Cecily, 'I will not consent to appointment on that committee unless I know whether JoAnne is to be a member of it.' And JoAnne says, 'I will not consent to be a member of that committee unless I know whether Steve will be appointed to it.'

If all three of these people stick by these resolutions, then:

A) Neither of them can be appointed to the committee.

B) The situation described in the scenario cannot arise, because it is inherently incoherent.

C) They must either both be appointed or both be left out.

D) The committee may finally have one of them, both of them, or neither of them as members.

E) Either one of them can be appointed, but not both.
If you have any questions
New!
SVP
Joined: 03 Feb 2003
Posts: 1603
Followers: 8

Kudos [?]: 235 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 04:41
1
KUDOS
My intuition whispers that it is E. But I have influenza and may write stupid things.
CEO
Joined: 15 Aug 2003
Posts: 3460
Followers: 67

Kudos [?]: 855 [1] , given: 781

Re: CR: Steve and JoAnne [#permalink]

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 06:14
1
KUDOS
pitts20042006 wrote:
Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though they are not speaking to each other. Cecily, the club president, is appointing members to the fundraising committee, but she has resolved that she will not appoint anyone without his or her explicit consent. Steve tells Cecily, 'I will not consent to appointment on that committee unless I know whether JoAnne is to be a member of it.' And JoAnne says, 'I will not consent to be a member of that committee unless I know whether Steve will be appointed to it.'

If all three of these people stick by these resolutions, then:

A) Neither of them can be appointed to the committee.

B) The situation described in the scenario cannot arise, because it is inherently incoherent.

C) They must either both be appointed or both be left out.

D) The committee may finally have one of them, both of them, or neither of them as members.

E) Either one of them can be appointed, but not both.

its not clear what both these two want.

do they want to be on the same committee or not?

i doubt if we can pass judgement on what their decisions are, in case they
know who is in and who is out.

D is best.
Director
Joined: 28 Oct 2003
Posts: 501
Location: 55405
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 24 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 06:18
1
KUDOS
Isn't D true, tautologically?

It's like saying "It will either rain today, or it will not rain".
Director
Joined: 13 Nov 2003
Posts: 964
Location: Florida
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 118 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 07:59
1
KUDOS
D seems good.

don't have much explanation for it, but it seems like a perfect probability question.
Senior Manager
Joined: 05 May 2003
Posts: 424
Location: Aus
Followers: 2

Kudos [?]: 10 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 08:06
1
KUDOS
Is it A ?
Director
Joined: 28 Oct 2003
Posts: 501
Location: 55405
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 24 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 08:17
Steve tells Cecily, 'I will not consent to appointment on that committee unless I know whether JoAnne is to be a member of it.'
And JoAnne says, 'I will not consent to be a member of that committee unless I know whether Steve will be appointed to it.'

Cecily first tells JoAnne that she is appointing both of them.
Joanne declines, then Cecily calls Steve, telling him that she is appointing him, and informing him of Joannes decision. Steve accepts or declines.
(Steve only or neither)

Or:
Cecily first tells JoAnne that she is appointing both of them.
Joanne accepts, then Cecily calls Steve, telling him that she is appointing him, and informing him of Joannes decision. Steve accepts or declines.
(Both, or Joanne only)

Or:
Cecily tells both of them that their attitudes are crap, and appoints Carl and Lenny.
(Neither)
Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2003
Posts: 247
Location: USA
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 6 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 08:21
any more tries?

I will put the official answer and explanation once I reach home .. in about 6 hours.

The reason for this question here is it is a questions from one of the established website tests and I got it wrong but don't agree with the 'official' answer myself - though their explanation is in 'much detail'. So wanted to know your thoughts ....
Intern
Joined: 12 Jul 2003
Posts: 31
Location: Boston
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 1 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 08:52
1
KUDOS
I'd be shocked if it wasn't D.

They could still end up on the same committee. Both want to know if the other person will be on it, but it does not mean they will refuse to join it.
Manager
Joined: 29 Aug 2003
Posts: 240
Location: MI
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 26 [0], given: 0

Re: CR: Steve and JoAnne [#permalink]

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 09:16
pitts20042006 wrote:
Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though they are not speaking to each other. Cecily, the club president, is appointing members to the fundraising committee, but she has resolved that she will not appoint anyone without his or her explicit consent. Steve tells Cecily, 'I will not consent to appointment on that committee unless I know whether JoAnne is to be a member of it.' And JoAnne says, 'I will not consent to be a member of that committee unless I know whether Steve will be appointed to it.'

If all three of these people stick by these resolutions, then:

A) Neither of them can be appointed to the committee.

B) The situation described in the scenario cannot arise, because it is inherently incoherent.

C) They must either both be appointed or both be left out.

D) The committee may finally have one of them, both of them, or neither of them as members.

E) Either one of them can be appointed, but not both.

Another way to look at it is ---

Steve tells Cecily, 'I will not consent to appointment on that committee unless I know whether JoAnne is to be a member of it.'
Rephrase -
I will only agree to become a member if JoAnne becomes a member.

JoAnne says, 'I will not consent to be a member of that committee unless I know whether Steve will be appointed to it.'
Repharse -
I will only consent to be a member if Steve will be appointed to it.

Considering the statements together, we get C as the answer.
Either both of them are on the committee or neither of them.

Any thoughts ?
Director
Joined: 28 Oct 2003
Posts: 501
Location: 55405
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 24 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 11:50
I bet your stupid test prep company is going to say "A" is the answer.

Because the key word here is appoint "not appoint anyone without his or her explicit consent."

So she has to get their permission to appoint them, but cannot appoint them until she gets their permission.

This is a stupid question, IMO, and I've never seen anything quite this stupid in the OG...

The LSAT, maybe, but screw the lawyers. Let them work for a living.
Intern
Joined: 19 Aug 2003
Posts: 6
Location: Pittsburgh
Followers: 0

Kudos [?]: 1 [1] , given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 12:31
1
KUDOS

President calls Steve to ask his consent. He will not say whether he will join the comittee or not, unless he knows whether Joann will join or not.
President calls Joann, not knowing whether Steve will join or not and gets the same reply.

President can not resolve this cyclical dependency and moves on. Hence, neither steve nor Joann is on the comittee.
Director
Joined: 28 Oct 2003
Posts: 501
Location: 55405
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 24 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 12:49
bnagasub--

Why can't Cecily choose not to nominate JoAnne, and call Steve, telling him that JoAnne will not be appointed?
CEO
Joined: 15 Aug 2003
Posts: 3460
Followers: 67

Kudos [?]: 855 [0], given: 781

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 13:49
bnagasub wrote:

President calls Steve to ask his consent. He will not say whether he will join the comittee or not, unless he knows whether Joann will join or not.
President calls Joann, not knowing whether Steve will join or not and gets the same reply.

President can not resolve this cyclical dependency and moves on. Hence, neither steve nor Joann is on the comittee.

i will show you one of three scenarios where your "cyclical dependency" wont work.

President and Steve

president : steve , if joann is on the committee , would be interested in being on the committee

steve : NO

president and Joann

president : Joann, steve is not on the committee, would you like to join the committee

Joann : Yes

now second scenario , is both will say NO.

third scenario, both will say yes. ( we dont know what the problem

is between them) ..we cant assume that if one is there, the other wont.

if you'd like, switch joann and steve around, it doesnt really matter.
Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2003
Posts: 247
Location: USA
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 6 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 14:54

800score explanation which i don't agree with

(E) Because of the resolutions of Steve and JoAnne, neither of them can be appointed before a decision is made about the other one. That rules out making a positive decision to appoint in either case because no such decision could be the FIRST decision. But nothing in the scenario rules out Cecily's first making a negative decision (the decision, say, not to appoint Steve). Then she could inform JoAnne of that fact; JoAnne might then consent to the appointment and thus be appointed. Or, of course, the first negative decision might have been made about JoAnne, resulting in the possible appointment of Steve.
Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2003
Posts: 247
Location: USA
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 6 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 17:55
I feel it is D. Official ans is E. I don't think other options stand a good chance logically itself.

akamai .....? others ...?
GMAT Club Legend
Joined: 15 Dec 2003
Posts: 4302
Followers: 38

Kudos [?]: 418 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

19 Dec 2003, 17:59
Pitts, just curious to know if that was a GMAT or LSAT problem?
SVP
Joined: 03 Feb 2003
Posts: 1603
Followers: 8

Kudos [?]: 235 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

20 Dec 2003, 07:26
I feel like I saw it somewhere long time ago but cannot remember where exactly.
Manager
Joined: 12 Oct 2003
Posts: 247
Location: USA
Followers: 1

Kudos [?]: 6 [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

20 Dec 2003, 08:34
Gmat 800score one of the computer adaptive tests
Similar topics Replies Last post
Similar
Topics:
9 Some members of the basketball team are members of the chess club 13 18 Sep 2014, 04:44
CR Steve and JoAnne 6 26 Jun 2008, 20:25
9 Steve and JoAnne are both members of a certain club, though 12 30 Jan 2008, 19:24
To be accepted as a member at the Brown Country Club, one 16 30 Dec 2007, 15:19
To be accepted as a member at the Brown Country Club, one 6 12 Jun 2007, 05:11
Display posts from previous: Sort by