You may not be headed to ibanking/consulting, but you still are thinking about the finance industry (at least enough to call it out here), so Stern will open up many doors for you. And you have half of your tuition covered, which puts you in a better spot than most people.
UNC recruiting will be very regional for mid-Atlantic/Southeast. Unless you want to end up in the Carolinas for life, I'd go with Stern. I think most people in this situation would lean Stern as well, but then again, since you went to UNC undergrad, you might have other ties to the Carolinas that make that full-ride there really compelling (withholding the obvious extra $ and lower standard of living for expenses).
aerienWhy Yale | My Advice For Younger Applicants
GMAT Club Premium Membership - big benefits and savings