I am trying to gain a perspective of how the two things compare in an overall application and whether which has a better chance of getting you inside the school and if possible scholarship.
In terms of Percentages
Just type your choice in the form of.
W 50% (Work Experience)
G 15% (Gmat)
E 20% (Essay)
R 5% (Referrals)
X 10% (Extra Curricular) I would imagine B schools would want to see some helping nature in students.
By the way, I seen the knewton video, so need to post it again.
If you found the reply to be helpful, give kudos.