Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

Hi guys, this was written before I saw the post on how to write mathematically correct in the forum.

DS #90:

My question about this problem has to do with part 1. The question is fairly simple: Why in part 1 can’t I make all signs match up and equal x? x/yz would then look like this in the way I did it: x / 2x*2x/5.

Here is what the book says:

(1) From this, z can be expressed in terms of y by substituting y/2 for x in the equation z=2x/5, which gives us z=2(2/5) / 5= y/5. The value of x/yz in terms of y is then y/2 / y(y/5) = y/2(5/y[squared])=5/2y. This expression cannot be evaluated further since no information is given about the value of y; not sufficient. (BCE).

Here is how I did it:

What I did is take x=y/2 and make it 2x=y (which Quant book did not do), which then gave me: x / 2x*2x/5, which gave me x / 4x/5, which equals 5x / 4x, and I get 5/4. Meaning I mark this as AD and move to part 2.

Part 2 is easier to solve because we just plug in: y=10, x=5, z=2. 5/10*2=1/4, for which I pick letter D as my answer because both solutions by them selves are sufficient.

One of the big problems I see with my answer is that in part 1 I got 5/4, and in part 2 I got ¼, which is a contradiction and according to MGMAT, I did something wrong.

Please explain this problem and let me know whether and if so, then why I am wrong.

Hi guys, this was written before I saw the post on how to write mathematically correct in the forum.

DS #90:

What is the value of x / yz ?

1. x=y/2 and z=2x/5 2. x/z=5/2 and 1/y=1/10

My question about this problem has to do with part 1. The question is fairly simple: Why in part 1 can’t I make all signs match up and equal x? x/yz would then look like this in the way I did it: x / 2x*2x/5.

Here is what the book says:

(1) From this, z can be expressed in terms of y by substituting y/2 for x in the equation z=2x/5, which gives us z=2(2/5) / 5= y/5. The value of x/yz in terms of y is then y/2 / y(y/5) = y/2(5/y[squared])=5/2y. This expression cannot be evaluated further since no information is given about the value of y; not sufficient. (BCE).

Here is how I did it:

What I did is take x=y/2 and make it 2x=y (which Quant book did not do), which then gave me: x / 2x*2x/5, which gave me x / 4x/5, which equals 5x / 4x, and I get 5/4. Meaning I mark this as AD and move to part 2.

Part 2 is easier to solve because we just plug in: y=10, x=5, z=2. 5/10*2=1/4, for which I pick letter D as my answer because both solutions by them selves are sufficient.

One of the big problems I see with my answer is that in part 1 I got 5/4, and in part 2 I got ¼, which is a contradiction and according to MGMAT, I did something wrong.

Please explain this problem and let me know whether and if so, then why I am wrong.

Re: What is the value of x / yz ? [#permalink]
05 Jul 2013, 02:48

financeguy25 wrote:

What is the value of x / yz ?

1. x=y/2 and z=2x/5 2. x/z=5/2 and 1/y=1/10

My question about this problem has to do with part 1. The question is fairly simple: Why in part 1 can’t I make all signs match up and equal x? x/yz would then look like this in the way I did it: x / 2x*2x/5.

Here is what the book says:

(1) From this, z can be expressed in terms of y by substituting y/2 for x in the equation z=2x/5, which gives us z=2(2/5) / 5= y/5. The value of x/yz in terms of y is then y/2 / y(y/5) = y/2(5/y[squared])=5/2y. This expression cannot be evaluated further since no information is given about the value of y; not sufficient. (BCE).

Hi Bunuel/Instructors, I have a doubt : (In red above) how can we cancel Y in numerator with Y in denominator, if the problem doesnt states: y IS NOT= 0. As the cancellation of Y(or for any variable) involves/multiplication or division by Y on both ends.

So far as I understand GMAT has marked statements in many DS Qs as insuffiecient on this ground stating "we cant divide by a variable unless it is mentioned as non zero"

I observed similar things in Q57(where m/n = 5/3 has been cross multiplied to 5n =3m) - they ignored the point that if m or n is 0 then the answer B wont be SUFFICIENT.

& Q15(in option B, they have ignored the case of x=0, which if true makes B not sufficient as it also the solution also involves division by a variable )

ARE there any particular scenarios in which we are allowed to divide/multiply varibles or transfer them by cross multiplication in an equation. OR where am i lacking in my basics ?

Re: What is the value of x / yz ? [#permalink]
05 Jul 2013, 03:40

Expert's post

p111 wrote:

financeguy25 wrote:

What is the value of x / yz ?

1. x=y/2 and z=2x/5 2. x/z=5/2 and 1/y=1/10

My question about this problem has to do with part 1. The question is fairly simple: Why in part 1 can’t I make all signs match up and equal x? x/yz would then look like this in the way I did it: x / 2x*2x/5.

Here is what the book says:

(1) From this, z can be expressed in terms of y by substituting y/2 for x in the equation z=2x/5, which gives us z=2(2/5) / 5= y/5. The value of x/yz in terms of y is then y/2 / y(y/5) = y/2(5/y[squared])=5/2y. This expression cannot be evaluated further since no information is given about the value of y; not sufficient. (BCE).

Hi Bunuel/Instructors, I have a doubt : (In red above) how can we cancel Y in numerator with Y in denominator, if the problem doesnt states: y IS NOT= 0. As the cancellation of Y(or for any variable) involves/multiplication or division by Y on both ends.

So far as I understand GMAT has marked statements in many DS Qs as insuffiecient on this ground stating "we cant divide by a variable unless it is mentioned as non zero"

I observed similar things in Q57(where m/n = 5/3 has been cross multiplied to 5n =3m) - they ignored the point that if m or n is 0 then the answer B wont be SUFFICIENT.

& Q15(in option B, they have ignored the case of x=0, which if true makes B not sufficient as it also the solution also involves division by a variable )

ARE there any particular scenarios in which we are allowed to divide/multiply varibles or transfer them by cross multiplication in an equation. OR where am i lacking in my basics ?

Please help !!

What is the value of x/yz?

(1) x = \frac{y}{2} and z = \frac{2x}{5}. If y=10, then x=5, z=2 and in this case \frac{x}{yz}=\frac{5}{20}=\frac{1}{4} BUT if y=20, then x=10, z=4 and in this case \frac{x}{yz}=\frac{10}{80}=\frac{1}{8}. Not sufficient.

(2) \frac{x}{z} = \frac{5}{2} and \frac{1}{y} = \frac{1}{10}. Multiply these two equations: \frac{x}{yz}=\frac{5}{20}. Sufficient.

Answer: B.

As for your questions: 1. Yes, it would be better if the stem stated that yz\neq{0}. If you don't state that, then x=y=z=0 satisfies the first statement and in this case x/(yz) is undefined.

2. As for m/n = 5/3. This equation already implies that neither of them is zero: if m=0, then m/n = 0 and not 5/3 and if n=0, then m/n is not defined, and not 5/3. So, in this case we can write 3m = 5n.

Re: What is the value of x / yz ? [#permalink]
05 Jul 2013, 05:24

Hi, Appologies for the PM, I wasnt aware.

Bunuel wrote:

As for your questions: 1. Yes, it would be better if the stem stated that yz\neq{0}. If you don't state that, then x=y=z=0 satisfies the first statement and in this case x/(yz) is undefined.

I think you understand my doubt. The scenarios(x,y,z=0) will make the solution undefined. Hence answer E. (Thats the way i solved, considering all scenarios) SO why are we not picking these values as well? The statement is meant to be true for all real numbers ~ RIGHT ? How to decide between option D(here) & option E for such questions in exam. Seeking lessons from your experience

Bunuel wrote:

3. I don't know what question is Q15.

It is question 15 from Data sufficiency & Q57 is question 57.

Re: What is the value of x / yz ? [#permalink]
05 Jul 2013, 05:36

Expert's post

p111 wrote:

Hi, Appologies for the PM, I wasnt aware.

Bunuel wrote:

As for your questions: 1. Yes, it would be better if the stem stated that yz\neq{0}. If you don't state that, then x=y=z=0 satisfies the first statement and in this case x/(yz) is undefined.

I think you understand my doubt. The scenarios(x,y,z=0) will make the solution undefined. Hence answer E. (Thats the way i solved, considering all scenarios) SO why are we not picking these values as well? The statement is meant to be true for all real numbers ~ RIGHT ? How to decide between option D(here) & option E for such questions in exam. Seeking lessons from your experience

Bunuel wrote:

3. I don't know what question is Q15.

It is question 15 from Data sufficiency & Q57 is question 57.

The answer to the question is neither D nor E, it's B.

(1) is not sufficient irrespective whether you have yz\neq{0} condition or not. The point is that, their solution for (1) is not 100% correct since it's not mentioned that yz\neq{0}.

(2) is still sufficient as shown in my post above.

As for Q15 and Q57: I don't know what questions are you talking about. Please post them. _________________