Whereas scientists, because of random fluctuations in the

"Just as x, so y" is used to explain how two things are both true at the same time and are somehow related. You will often see it as "just as x, so too y", but the too is not required (personally I prefer using "too"). Just as I was late for breakfast, so too I was late for my morning meeting.

KW
_________________

Dear Friends,

Here is a detailed explanation to this question-

Meaning is crucial to solving this problem:
Understanding the intended meaning is key to solving this question; the intended meaning of this sentence is that because of random fluctuations in the weather, scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, and in the same way they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.

Concepts tested here: Meaning + Pronouns + Idioms + Awkwardness/Redundancy

• “as A + comma + so B” is an idiomatic construction, used to compare two elements; A and B must be comparable and parallel.

A: This answer choice alters the meaning of the sentence through the phrase “Whereas scientists”; the use of “Whereas” incorrectly implies that because of random fluctuations in the weather, scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, but they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures; the intended meaning is that because of random fluctuations in the weather, scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, and in the same way they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.

B: Correct. This answer choice correctly uses the idiomatic construction “as A (“scientists… cannot determine...basis”) + comma + so + B (“they cannot determine...temperatures”), conveying the intended meaning – that because of random fluctuations in the weather, scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, and in the same way they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures. Further, the sentence formed by Option B correctly refers to the plural noun “scientists” with the plural pronoun “they”. Additionally, Option B is free of any awkwardness or redundancy.

C: This answer choice incorrectly uses the unidiomatic construction “like A (“scientists”) + comma + so + B (“they”)”; remember, “as A + comma + so B” is an idiomatic construction, used to compare two elements; A and B must be comparable and parallel.

D: This answer choice incorrectly uses the unidiomatic construction “inasmuch as A (“a scientist cannot determine...basis”) + comma + so + B (“they cannot determine...temperatures”)”, leading to an incoherent meaning; the intended meaning is that because of random fluctuations in the weather, scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, and in the same way they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures. remember, “as A + comma + so B” is an idiomatic construction, used to compare two elements; A and B must be comparable and parallel. Further, the sentence formed by Option D incorrectly refers to the singular noun “scientist” with the plural pronoun “they”.

E: The sentence formed by this answer choice incorrectly refers to the singular noun “scientist” with the plural pronoun “they”. Additionally, Option E uses the needlessly wordy phrase “In the same way as a scientist”, leading to awkwardness and redundancy.

Hence, B is the best answer choice.

All the best!
Experts' Global Team
_________________

Answer seems to be #2 or B.

Answer 1 seems wrong because it is using 'whereas' which is used for contrasts - there are no contrasts here. Answer 3 seems wrong because the sentence is not likening scientists to anything - trick answer. Answer 4 & 5 seems wrong because they make reference to singular 'scientist' when the sentence is really talking about plural 'scientists'.

[color=#0000BF]“So they” in the main clause requires plural “scientists” – eliminate 4 and 5[/color]
1) Whereas scientists [Just as much preferred over whereas – eliminate it]
2) Just as scientists [Hold it]
3) Like scientists who [“Like” – is not used to compare clauses – eliminate it]
4) Inasmuch as a scientist
5) In the same way as a scientist

Answer: 2

B for me as well. Need 'scientists' to match up with 'they', and the proper idiom

B , I think.

A and C are unidiomatic. D and E have incorrect SV.
Note the THEY in bold.

Looks like this question is testing the idiom of "just as..., so..." Just as scientists cannot determine..., so they...

Out of curiosity, what's the source?
_________________

1. A is wrong because of where as
2. Hold it comparison is correct
3. Like cannot be used
4. scientist singular with they -- wrong
5. scientist singular with they -- wrong

Can someone explain the idiom with just as ... so?

Thx you!
_________________

look at non underlined part :-

because of random fluctuations in the weather, cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, so they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.

Just as X so Y idiom

In B, its given "Just as.... so....". Isn't the correct idiom Just as... so to... ?

No. "Just as... so to ..." is incorrect. The correct usage is "just as...so..".

Here is the correct sentence with mapping:
Just as scientists, ---, cannot determine --, so they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.

Just as X , so Y
Just as Scientist cannot determine, so They cannot determine

Option A - Incorrect

"whereas" indicates a contrast. The two clauses reinforce each other, not contrast. Moreover, "so" is generally used to denote effect.
"they cannot determine the onset of global warming ..." is not an effect of "scientists cannot determine the transition from one season to the next ..."

Option B - Correct

The correlative conjunction used here is -- "just as X, so [too] Y".

Option C - Incorrect

"scientists who cannot determine …"(this seems to imply that there are some who cannot determine and by consequence there are OTHERS WHO CAN -- not logical).
"like + so" is unidiomatic.

Option D - Incorrect

The pronoun "they" does not have an antecedent.
"in as much as" does not make sense here. It can mean - "in view of the fact that/because" - this does not make sense.
OR "to the extent that" - even this does not make sense.

Option E - Incorrect

The pronoun "they" does not have an antecedent.
_________________

correct idiom is "Just as x, so y" .
here, x = scientists , y = they
so correct answer is B

Hello Experts. I have one doubt regarding use of "Just as x, so y" construction. Which part is the independent clause in these types of sentences.
As it seems, so they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.
is IC here but can a IC starts with so
It doesn't seem to me that so they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.
can stand alone.

Hi SALAKSHYA,

We should look at everything after this so as an independent clause. That is, so does introduce an independent clause here.

I understand that this can be a little frustrating, but we'll face the same issue even with something like and. For example, in "{IC1} and {IC2}", we can't say that {IC2} cannot be an independent clause just because "and {IC2}" doesn't sound like a complete sentence.
_________________

Whereas scientists, because of random fluctuations in the weather, cannot determine the transition from one season to the next by monitoring temperatures on a daily basis, so they cannot determine the onset of global warming by monitoring average annual temperatures.

(A) Whereas scientists
(B) Just as scientists
(C) Like scientists who
(D) Inasmuch as a scientist
(E) In the same way as a scientist

If you look at individual choices , only A and B make sense .
Out of a and b , we can pick B easily based on Idiom usage - Just as ...., so ....
Whereas scientists, .....So, .Here , so -should be avoided. So, B is out

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________