Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 08 May 2017
Posts: 1
Location: India
Concentration: Operations, Economics
GPA: 2.49

A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2018, 17:43
Question Stats:
25% (02:42) correct 75% (02:36) wrong based on 100 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table? 1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. 2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 8151

A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2018, 22:35
Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. let there be n people, so basically we are asked to find 2 out of n people. nC2.. let us see each choice now... 1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(17\leq{nC2(n2)C2}\leq{19}\). let us find (n)C2(n2)C2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(17\leq{2n3}\leq{19}=20\leq{2n}\leq{22}\)=\(10\leq{n}\leq{11}\).. so n can be 10 or 11 insuff.. 2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(18\leq{nC2(n2)C2}\leq{21}\). let us find nC2(n2)C2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(18\leq{2n3}\leq{21}=21\leq{2n}\leq{24}\)=\(10.5\leq{n}\leq{12}\).. so n can be 11 or 12 insuff.. Combined.. n can be 11.. sufficient.. C You can also work with taking different values of n.. find 8C26C2 and then 9C27C2 and so on.. match with your statement and you will get your answer.. example 9C27C2 = 9*47*3=3621=15, so increase n by 1.. 10C28C2=5*94*7=4528=17.. 11C29C2=11*59*4=5536=19.. so n as 10 and 11 are correct. As we can see with increase of 1 in n, the possible value of n increases by 2.. so, if 10C28C2=17, 11C29C2=19, 12C211C2=21.. so statement I gives us 17 and 19 and statement II gives us 19 and 21.. Thus, 19 is the answer.. C
_________________



Intern
Joined: 19 Jul 2018
Posts: 5
Location: India

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2018, 23:45
Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Can some one please explain, "each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people" ?



Intern
Joined: 21 Oct 2018
Posts: 32
Location: India

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Dec 2018, 00:54
jashandeep2332 wrote: Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Can some one please explain, "each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people" ? to explain above statement , for example take 5 persons seated and named as a,b,c,d,e first person a can clink with b,c,d,e .so on total there will be 4 clinks in the same way, second person can clink with b,c,e on total there will be 3 clinks... so on Hope answered your question



Manager
Joined: 09 Jul 2018
Posts: 63

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Dec 2018, 02:27
chetan2u wrote: Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. let there be n people, so basically we are asked to find 2 out of n people. nC2.. let us see each choice now... 1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(17\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{19}\). let us find (n2)C2nC2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(17\leq{2n3}\leq{19}=20\leq{2n}\leq{22}\)=\(10\leq{n}\leq{11}\).. so n can be 10 or 11 insuff.. 2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(18\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{21}\). let us find (n2)C2nC2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(18\leq{2n3}\leq{21}=21\leq{2n}\leq{24}\)=\(10.5\leq{n}\leq{12}\).. so n can be 11 or 12 insuff.. Combined.. n can be 11.. sufficient.. C You can also work with taking different values of n.. find 8C26C2 and then 9C27C2 and so on.. match with your statement and you will get your answer.. example 9C27C2 = 9*47*3=3621=15, so increase n by 1.. 10C28C2=5*94*7=4528=17.. 11C29C2=11*59*4=5536=19.. so n as 10 and 11 are correct. As we can see with increase of 1 in n, the possible value of n increases by 2.. so, if 10C28C2=17, 11C29C2=19, 12C211C2=21.. so statement I gives us 17 and 19 and statement II gives us 19 and 21.. Thus, 19 is the answer.. C can u please explain this equation \(17\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{19}\). why its (n2)C2nC2?



Retired Moderator
Joined: 22 Aug 2013
Posts: 1417
Location: India

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Dec 2018, 22:29
ritu1009 wrote: chetan2u wrote: Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. let there be n people, so basically we are asked to find 2 out of n people. nC2.. let us see each choice now... 1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(17\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{19}\). let us find (n2)C2nC2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(17\leq{2n3}\leq{19}=20\leq{2n}\leq{22}\)=\(10\leq{n}\leq{11}\).. so n can be 10 or 11 insuff.. 2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(18\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{21}\). let us find (n2)C2nC2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(18\leq{2n3}\leq{21}=21\leq{2n}\leq{24}\)=\(10.5\leq{n}\leq{12}\).. so n can be 11 or 12 insuff.. Combined.. n can be 11.. sufficient.. C You can also work with taking different values of n.. find 8C26C2 and then 9C27C2 and so on.. match with your statement and you will get your answer.. example 9C27C2 = 9*47*3=3621=15, so increase n by 1.. 10C28C2=5*94*7=4528=17.. 11C29C2=11*59*4=5536=19.. so n as 10 and 11 are correct. As we can see with increase of 1 in n, the possible value of n increases by 2.. so, if 10C28C2=17, 11C29C2=19, 12C211C2=21.. so statement I gives us 17 and 19 and statement II gives us 19 and 21.. Thus, 19 is the answer.. C can u please explain this equation \(17\leq{(n2)C2nC2}\leq{19}\). why its (n2)C2nC2? Hello If there are total 'n' people, number of clinks produced will be nC2. If there are total 'n2' people, number of clinks produced will be (n2)C2. First statement says that in case of 2 fewer people, the 'difference in number of clinks produced' will be between 17 and 19 inclusive. And what is the difference in number of clinks produced ? It will be nC2  (n2)C2 only. Thats why Chetan has made the equation: 17 <= [nC2  (n2)C2] <= 19 (I think just by typo Chetan has written (n2)C2  nC2.. instead he should have written nC2  (n2)C2. But his calculation is completely fine, and all else that he has written is also perfect).



Intern
Joined: 28 Sep 2018
Posts: 6

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Dec 2018, 02:53
This was my thought process without the need of any calculations
 clinks are made only once by each member, 1 clink requires two persons. Once clinked members are out of scope.
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
let the current people be n+2, now statement 1 says 17<=n/2<=19 => 34<=n<=38 => 34<= current_people <=38 II
Thus current people = n+2 => 36<= n+2 <= 40
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. let the current people be n+2, now statement 1 says 18<= n/2 <=21 => 36<= n <=42
Thus current people = n+2 => 38<= n+2 <= 44 => 38<= current_people <= 44  I
Combining I and II
current_people = 38 Hence C



Current Student
Joined: 04 Jun 2018
Posts: 156
GMAT 1: 610 Q48 V25 GMAT 2: 690 Q50 V32 GMAT 3: 710 Q50 V36

Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Dec 2018, 03:14
chetan2u wrote: Graina wrote: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Following the toast, each person must clink glasses exactly once with each of the other people at the table. If each clink is produced by the glasses of only two people, how many people are seated at the table?
1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks.
2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. let there be n people, so basically we are asked to find 2 out of n people. nC2.. let us see each choice now... 1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(17\leq{nC2(n2)C2}\leq{19}\). let us find (n)C2(n2)C2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(17\leq{2n3}\leq{19}=20\leq{2n}\leq{22}\)=\(10\leq{n}\leq{11}\).. so n can be 10 or 11 insuff.. 2. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 18 but no more than 21 fewer clinks. Now, the strength becomes n2, so ways you can choose 2 out of n2 = (n2)C2 So, \(18\leq{nC2(n2)C2}\leq{21}\). let us find nC2(n2)C2 => \(\frac{n!}{(n2)!2!}\frac{(n2)!}{(n22)!2!}=\frac{n(n1)}{2}\frac{(n2)(n3)}{2}=\frac{n^2nn^2+5n6}{2}=2n3\).. so \(18\leq{2n3}\leq{21}=21\leq{2n}\leq{24}\)=\(10.5\leq{n}\leq{12}\).. so n can be 11 or 12 insuff.. Combined.. n can be 11.. sufficient.. C You can also work with taking different values of n.. find 8C26C2 and then 9C27C2 and so on.. match with your statement and you will get your answer.. example 9C27C2 = 9*47*3=3621=15, so increase n by 1.. 10C28C2=5*94*7=4528=17.. 11C29C2=11*59*4=5536=19.. so n as 10 and 11 are correct. As we can see with increase of 1 in n, the possible value of n increases by 2.. so, if 10C28C2=17, 11C29C2=19, 12C211C2=21.. so statement I gives us 17 and 19 and statement II gives us 19 and 21.. Thus, 19 is the answer.. C HI chetan2u1. If two fewer people were seated at the table, there would be at least 17 but no more than 19 fewer clinks. I cannot understand this statement. According to me, it means: if there are n people then it becomes n2 So 17<n2c2<19 if there are 2 fewer people seated at the table, there would min 17 and max of 19. Why are you saying that th DIFFERENCE will be min 17 and max 19. you could simply also say that with 2 fewer people, the clinks shall be min 17 and max 19. Please tell me if I am going wrong t=somewhere. Regards




Re: A group of people is seated at a table at which a toast is made. Follo
[#permalink]
12 Dec 2018, 03:14






