TheUltimateWinner wrote:
Quote:
A patient accusing a doctor of malpractice will find it difficult to prove damage if there is a lack of some other doctor to testify about proper medical procedures.
(A) if there is a lack of some other doctor to testify
(C) without another doctor’s testimony
It seems that choices A and C are same regarding meaning issue, aren't they? Could you share your thought on the basis of 'some other' and 'another' issue?
Generally, an infinitive (
to + VERB) expresses an INTENDED action -- an action that is not actually happening but is only intended.
As a result, option A does not convey that testimony from some other doctor is needed.
The usage of
to testify in A conveys only that testimony from some other doctor is INTENDED.
This meaning seems strange.
Common sense tells us the following:
For damage to be proven, some other doctor must do more than just INTEND to testify -- the doctor must ACTUALLY testify.
The meaning conveyed by the OA is far more logical.
OA:
A patient...will find it difficult to prove damage without another doctor's testimony.Here, the phrase in blue implies that testimony from another doctor is NEEDED -- that without the testimony, a patient will find it difficult to prove damage.
Since C conveys a more logical meaning than A, eliminate A and choose C.
Another error in A:
Generally,
a lack of must refer to a noun that can be modified by
much or
many.
Since it is possible to have
MUCH motivation, it is possible to suffer from
A LACK OF motivation.
Since it is possible to have
MUCH money, it is possible suffer from
A LACK OF money.
Since it is possible to have
MANY friends, it is possible to suffer from
A LACK OF friends.
A:
a lack of some other doctorIt is not possible to have
MUCH some other doctor or
MANY some other doctor.
Thus, the phrase above is nonsensical.
The following would be acceptable:
a lack of OTHER DOCTORSThe referent in green is viable because it is possible to have
MANY other doctors.
_________________
GMAT and GRE Tutor for over 20 years
Recent success stories for my students:admissions into Booth, Kellogg, HBS, Wharton, Tuck, Fuqua, Emory and others.
Available for live sessions in NYC and remotely all over the world
For more information, please email me at GMATGuruNY at gmail