Question 6
waytowharton wrote:
GMATNinja Sajjad1994 CrackverbalGMAT KarishmaB egmat MagooshCan you help me understand why Option B is incorrect in Que 6.
Que - The author asserts which of the following about Arboria's trade policy?
Option B - The most crucial issue facing Arborian trade policymakers is that of free trade versus protectionism.
Here protectionism refers to fair trade. The most crucial issue faced by them is that of free trade vs fair trade. Please me on this.
The author spends a good amount of time discussing free trade and fair trade, but he/she would
not agree that this is a "crucial issue." Instead, the author thinks that the free trade vs. fair trade argument completely misses the
actual issues with Arboria's economy. This is a pretty important piece of the author's argument, and you really want to wrap your head around this kind of thing before you dive into the weeds of the particular questions.
To pick up on the key components of the author's argument, consider why he/she write each paragraph, and how those paragraphs fits together. As an example, here's a breakdown of this passage:
Paragraph 1: the author introduces a problem, rules out one aspect of that problem, and focuses on another aspect of the problem.
- The problem: "Arboria's trade policy."
- Something that's NOT an important piece of the problem: "free trade versus protectionism."
- Something that IS an important piece of the problem: "diminishing trade versus expanding trade."
Paragraph 2: The author states that Arboria's trade policy is obsolete.
Paragraph 3: The author outlines the argument between free trade and fair trade, and lists 2 assumptions on which BOTH sides rely.
Paragraph 4: The author explains that the assumptions from Paragraph 3 are incorrect, and thus demonstrates why the free vs. fair trade discussion isn't relevant.
From the above analysis, you can see that the author doesn't think that the free vs. fair trade argument is that important at all -- he/she thinks that both sides of that debate rely on incorrect assumptions. Instead of that debate, the author thinks that Arborian trade policy should focus on expansion.
Eliminate (B) for question 6.
I hope that helps!