It is currently 13 Dec 2017, 22:33

# Decision(s) Day!:

CHAT Rooms | Ross R1 | Kellogg R1 | Darden R1 | Tepper R1

### GMAT Club Daily Prep

#### Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

# Events & Promotions

###### Events & Promotions in June
Open Detailed Calendar

# Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a

Author Message
TAGS:

### Hide Tags

VP
Joined: 16 Jul 2009
Posts: 1481

Kudos [?]: 1520 [0], given: 2

Schools: CBS
WE 1: 4 years (Consulting)
Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a [#permalink]

### Show Tags

17 Jul 2010, 15:13
1
This post was
BOOKMARKED
00:00

Difficulty:

85% (hard)

Question Stats:

48% (01:28) correct 52% (01:55) wrong based on 142 sessions

### HideShow timer Statistics

Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a ring of stones thousands of years ago in Britain were knowledgeable about celestial events. The ground for this claim is that two of the stones determine a line pointing directly to the position of the sun at sunrise at the spring equinox. There are many stones in the ring, however, so the chance that one pair will point in a celestially significant direction is large. Therefore, the people who built the ring were not knowledgeable about celestial events.
Which one of the following is an error of reasoning in Dobson’s argument?
(A) The failure of cited evidence to establish a statement is taken as evidence that that statement is false.
(B) Dobson’s conclusion logically contradicts some of the evidence presented in support of it.
(C) Statements that absolutely establish Dobson’s conclusion are treated as if they merely give some support to that conclusion.
(D) Something that is merely a matter of opinion is treated as if it were subject to verification as a matter of fact.
(E) Dobson’s drawing the conclusion relies on interpreting a key term in two different ways.
[Reveal] Spoiler: OA

_________________

The sky is the limit
800 is the limit

GMAT Club Premium Membership - big benefits and savings

Kudos [?]: 1520 [0], given: 2

Manager
Joined: 09 Jul 2010
Posts: 140

Kudos [?]: 34 [0], given: 3

### Show Tags

17 Jul 2010, 19:57
A it is

Statement: Some historians claim that the people who built a ring of stones thousands of years ago in Britain were knowledgeable about celestial events.
Evidence: The ground for this claim is that two of the stones determine a line pointing directly to the position of the sun at sunrise at the spring equinox. There are many stones in the ring, however, so the chance that one pair will point in a celestially significant direction is large.
Statement: Therefore, the people who built the ring were not knowledgeable about celestial events.
Which one of the following is an error of reasoning in Dobson’s argument?
(A) The failure of cited evidence to establish a statement is taken as evidence that that statement is false>>CORRECT
(B) Dobson’s conclusion logically contradicts some of the evidence presented in support of it.>>thought that this one is close, but..the conclusion in the argumnt is strongly suported by the premise(evidence).
(C) Statements that absolutely establish Dobson’s conclusion are treated as if they merely give some support to that conclusion>>OOS
(D) Something that is merely a matter of opinion is treated as if it were subject to verification as a matter of fact>>OOS
(E) Dobson’s drawing the conclusion relies on interpreting a key term in two different ways>>just 1n only way. no 2 ways
_________________

consider cudos if you like my post

Kudos [?]: 34 [0], given: 3

Director
Status: Impossible is not a fact. It's an opinion. It's a dare. Impossible is nothing.
Affiliations: University of Chicago Booth School of Business
Joined: 26 Nov 2009
Posts: 953

Kudos [?]: 931 [1], given: 36

Location: Singapore
Concentration: General Management, Finance
Schools: Chicago Booth - Class of 2015

### Show Tags

18 Jul 2010, 02:19
1
KUDOS
Conclusion : is based upon the "chance that " ---> this is NOT a proof. Hence its failing to ESTABLISH a statement. the people "were not knowledgeable about celestial events."

A it is.

E : interpreting a key term ----> If this is referring to "pair of stones". In both instances the pair points in the significant direction. Interpretation was not done in different way - just one way.

Kudos [?]: 931 [1], given: 36

Joined: 19 Feb 2010
Posts: 390

Kudos [?]: 205 [0], given: 76

### Show Tags

18 Jul 2010, 03:00
Dobson's problem is that he fails to make a statement.
The statement should be something like: the pair of stones doesn't point in a celestially significant direction.
The way he put it is just a doubt. If his conclusion was this one instead: "there is a large chance that the people who build the ring were not knowledgeable about celestial events", then his reasoning would be correct. So he didn't make a statement yet, but he brings up a strong conclusion, so the problem is either his reasoning or his conclusion. Since this exercise counts on Dobson keeping his conclusion unchanged, then the problem is his reasoning.

Kudos [?]: 205 [0], given: 76

Senior Manager
Joined: 23 May 2010
Posts: 414

Kudos [?]: 145 [0], given: 112

### Show Tags

23 Jul 2010, 10:12
A for me..

Kudos [?]: 145 [0], given: 112

Manager
Joined: 08 Jan 2010
Posts: 177

Kudos [?]: 3 [0], given: 13

### Show Tags

31 Jul 2010, 13:12
got it wrong need to look in again .......went with E

Kudos [?]: 3 [0], given: 13

Senior Manager
Affiliations: Volunteer Operation Smile India, Creative Head of College IEEE branch (2009-10), Chief Editor College Magazine (2009), Finance Head College Magazine (2008)
Joined: 25 Jul 2010
Posts: 456

Kudos [?]: 176 [0], given: 24

Location: India
WE2: Entrepreneur (E-commerce - The Laptop Skin Vault)
Concentration: Marketing, Entrepreneurship
GMAT 1: 710 Q49 V38
WE: Marketing (Other)

### Show Tags

12 Sep 2010, 03:33
IMO A
_________________

Kidchaos

http://www.laptopskinvault.com

Follow The Laptop Skin Vault on:

Consider Kudos if you think the Post is good
Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot. Nothing is going to change. It's not. - Dr. Seuss

Kudos [?]: 176 [0], given: 24

Manager
Joined: 22 Jul 2010
Posts: 137

Kudos [?]: 10 [0], given: 13

### Show Tags

12 Sep 2010, 03:47
I will go with A

B out of scope
C weak or general statement but a close call
D trap with intricate language.
E key term?? OOS
_________________

Whatever you do, Do it SINCERELY!!!

GOD help those who help themselves....

Kudos [?]: 10 [0], given: 13

Manager
Joined: 08 Feb 2010
Posts: 129

Kudos [?]: [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

16 Sep 2010, 05:52
will go for A

Kudos [?]: [0], given: 0

Senior Manager
Status: Upset about the verbal score - SC, CR and RC are going to be my friend
Joined: 30 Jun 2010
Posts: 316

Kudos [?]: 23 [0], given: 6

### Show Tags

16 Sep 2010, 06:12
I will go with A.
_________________

My gmat story
MGMAT1 - 630 Q44V32
MGMAT2 - 650 Q41V38
MGMAT3 - 680 Q44V37
GMATPrep1 - 660 Q49V31
Knewton1 - 550 Q40V27

Kudos [?]: 23 [0], given: 6

Intern
Joined: 16 Jul 2010
Posts: 8

Kudos [?]: [0], given: 0

### Show Tags

16 Sep 2010, 06:17
IMO A.

Kudos [?]: [0], given: 0

TOEFL Forum Moderator
Joined: 16 Nov 2010
Posts: 1586

Kudos [?]: 607 [0], given: 40

Location: United States (IN)
Concentration: Strategy, Technology

### Show Tags

10 Apr 2011, 18:02
_________________

Formula of Life -> Achievement/Potential = k * Happiness (where k is a constant)

GMAT Club Premium Membership - big benefits and savings

Kudos [?]: 607 [0], given: 40

VP
Status: There is always something new !!
Affiliations: PMI,QAI Global,eXampleCG
Joined: 08 May 2009
Posts: 1268

Kudos [?]: 291 [0], given: 10

### Show Tags

14 Jun 2011, 02:48
Crystal A here,as the evidence itself has been used to falsify the interpretation.
_________________

Visit -- http://www.sustainable-sphere.com/
Promote Green Business,Sustainable Living and Green Earth !!

Kudos [?]: 291 [0], given: 10

Math Forum Moderator
Joined: 20 Dec 2010
Posts: 1949

Kudos [?]: 2137 [0], given: 376

### Show Tags

14 Jun 2011, 12:07
noboru wrote:
Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a ring of stones thousands of years ago in Britain were knowledgeable about celestial events. The ground for this claim is that two of the stones determine a line pointing directly to the position of the sun at sunrise at the spring equinox. There are many stones in the ring, however, so the chance that one pair will point in a celestially significant direction is large. Therefore, the people who built the ring were not knowledgeable about celestial events.
Which one of the following is an error of reasoning in Dobson’s argument?
(A) The failure of cited evidence to establish a statement is taken as evidence that that statement is false.
(B) Dobson’s conclusion logically contradicts some of the evidence presented in support of it.
(C) Statements that absolutely establish Dobson’s conclusion are treated as if they merely give some support to that conclusion.
(D) Something that is merely a matter of opinion is treated as if it were subject to verification as a matter of fact.
(E) Dobson’s drawing the conclusion relies on interpreting a key term in two different ways.

Good one!!!

"A"
Dobson conclusion is flawed because it concluded the theory WRONG just because the reasoning used in support of the historians' claim was flawed or inept.

I was stuck because I thought "A" was mere a method of reasoning, and not the reasoning error and then I saw "statement is FALSE". The claim by historians may not be false, Dobson, the reasoning used to support historians' claim was false.
_________________

Kudos [?]: 2137 [0], given: 376

Non-Human User
Joined: 01 Oct 2013
Posts: 10199

Kudos [?]: 277 [0], given: 0

Re: Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a [#permalink]

### Show Tags

20 Feb 2016, 02:16
Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Kudos [?]: 277 [0], given: 0

Re: Dobson: Some historians claim that the people who built a   [#permalink] 20 Feb 2016, 02:16
Display posts from previous: Sort by