Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Senior Manager
Joined: 20 Aug 2015
Posts: 378
Location: India

During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Feb 2016, 22:32
Question Stats:
23% (03:19) correct 77% (03:14) wrong based on 1810 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n in two cities A and B are denoted by TA(n) and TB(n) respectively. The average temperature in city A on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city A. The average temperature in city B on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city B. If TA(1) = 30, TA(2) = 35, TB(1) = 35 and TB(2) = 30, which of the following statements must be true? I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3 A. II only B. III only C. I and II only D. II and III only E. I, II and III
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 8792

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Feb 2016, 02:58
TeamGMATIFY wrote: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n in two cities A and B are denoted by TA(n) and TB(n) respectively. The average temperature in city A on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city A. The average temperature in city B on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city B. If TA(1) = 30, TA(2) = 35, TB(1) = 35 and TB(2) = 30, which of the following statements must be true?
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
A. II only B. III only C. I and II only D. II and III only E. I, II and III Hi, Although its testing our visualization power to realize a certain activity will make what difference to an equation, it is a tough Q, which is not likely to be confronted, if you are not doing extremely 2 well Now lets VISUALIZE what is happening in each case... Important take aways, which mat be helpful in such Qs Quote: FIRST IMPORTANT POINT: The difference is 5 in first two terms and since the next terms are average of the pervious two terms, the difference in alternate terms will be based on 5.. SECOND: if the pervious two terms are big and small, the next will be bigger than previous.. and if the pervious two terms are small and big, the next will be smaller than previous.. so in A since first is 30 and next is 35, the next will be smaller, then bigger... etc so even numbers will be larger than the previous odd.. in B it will be opposite... THIRD.. in A, odd numbers will increase from 32.5 to nearly 33.25, and even numbers will decrease from 33.75 to 33.25.. in B, even numbers will increase from 31.25 to 31.75, and odd numbers will decrease from 32.5 to 31.75 .. FOURTH A will have no number<32.5 and B will have no number>32.5 after the two terms.. There will be many points which can clear off with the above observations too .. but lets work out the nth term in each sequence to hit the answer straight A.. 30, 30+5, 30+55/2, 30+55/2+5/4... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+5/2+5/4,30+5/2+5/45/8... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+15/4,30+25/8... now lets remove 30 and work out.. 5,5/2,15/4,25/8.. 5, 5*1/2, 5*3/4, 5* 5/8.. so 2nd term= 5.. 3rd term= 5*1/2= 5* {2*35}/2^( 32) 4th term= 5*3/4= 5*{2* 4[/b]5}/2^( 42).. so nth term= 5*{2* n5}/2^( n2)..
so NTH term= 30 +5*{2 n5}/2^{( n2)} B... 35, 355, 355+5/2, 355+5/25/4.. here Nth term= 35  5*{2 n5}/2^{( n2)} let see the choices.. I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29)TA4= 30+5*25/4.. TB4= 355*25/4.. TA29= 30+5*53/2^27= nearly 30.. TB29= 355*53/2^27=nearly 35...substitute values.. TRUE II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29)TA4= 30+5*25/4.. TB4= 355*25/4.. TA29= 30+5*53/2^27= nearly 30.. TB29= 355*53/2^27=nearly 35...substitute values.. 30+35=30+35.. TRUE III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n)it basically is asking difference in two consecutive terms the values are equal for two sides but in opposite sign.. TRUE
_________________




Manager
Joined: 03 Jan 2017
Posts: 131

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Mar 2017, 09:05
I'd suggust approaching it differently: 1) from the given we can calculate that the 1st is true 2) second, let's look at answer choices: only C and E left, we need to test the 3rd case 3) 66,25/267,5/2=0,75 63,2562,5=0,75 hence 3rd is correct




Intern
Joined: 22 Oct 2016
Posts: 21

During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Mar 2017, 05:07
Hi Chetan2u, Is the formula you mentioned is applicable for any difference in values between the terms mentioned.? In this case the difference is 5 and hence the formula is = 5*(2n5)/2^(n2) In case the difference is 3 can the formula be = 3*(2n3)/2*(n2) TIA
_________________



Senior Manager
Joined: 21 Aug 2016
Posts: 253
Location: India
GPA: 3.9
WE: Information Technology (Computer Software)

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Apr 2017, 10:02
chetan2u wrote: TeamGMATIFY wrote: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n in two cities A and B are denoted by TA(n) and TB(n) respectively. The average temperature in city A on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city A. The average temperature in city B on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city B. If TA(1) = 30, TA(2) = 35, TB(1) = 35 and TB(2) = 30, which of the following statements must be true?
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
A. II only B. III only C. I and II only D. II and III only E. I, II and III Hi , Although its testing our visualization power to realize a certain activity will make what difference to an equation, it is a tough Q, which is not likely to be confronted, if you are not doing extremely 2 well Now lets VISUALIZE what is happening in each case... Important take aways, which mat be helpful in such Qs Quote: FIRST IMPORTANT POINT: The difference is 5 in first two terms and since the next terms are average of the pervious two terms, the difference in alternate terms will be based on 5.. SECOND: if the pervious two terms are big and small, the next will be bigger than previous.. and if the pervious two terms are small and big, the next will be smaller than previous.. so in A since first is 30 and next is 35, the next will be smaller, then bigger... etc so even numbers will be larger than the previous odd.. in B it will be opposite... THIRD.. in A, odd numbers will increase from 32.5 to nearly 33.25, and even numbers will decrease from 33.75 to 33.25.. in B, even numbers will increase from 31.25 to 31.75, and odd numbers will decrease from 32.5 to 31.75 .. FOURTH A will have no number<32.5 and B will have no number>32.5 after the two terms.. There will be many points which can clear off with the above observations too .. but lets work out the nth term in each sequence to hit the answer straight A.. 30, 30+5, 30+55/2, 30+55/2+5/4... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+5/2+5/4,30+5/2+5/45/8... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+15/4,30+25/8... now lets remove 30 and work out.. 5,5/2,15/4,25/8.. 5, 5*1/2, 5*3/4, 5* 5/8.. so 2nd term= 5.. 3rd term= 5*1/2= 5* {2*35}/2^( 32) 4th term= 5*3/4= 5*{2* 4[/b]5}/2^( 42).. so nth term= 5*{2* n5}/2^( n2)..
so NTH term= 30 +5*{2 n5}/2^{( n2)} B... 35, 355, 355+5/2, 355+5/25/4.. here Nth term= 35  5*{2 n5}/2^{( n2)} let see the choices.. I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29)TA4= 30+5*25/4.. TB4= 355*25/4.. TA29= 30+5*53/2^27= nearly 30.. TB29= 355*53/2^27=nearly 35...substitute values.. TRUE II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29)TA4= 30+5*25/4.. TB4= 355*25/4.. TA29= 30+5*53/2^27= nearly 30.. TB29= 355*53/2^27=nearly 35...substitute values.. 30+35=30+35.. TRUE III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n)it basically is asking difference in two consecutive terms the values are equal for two sides but in opposite sign.. TRUE Hi chetan2u , Please explain how did you think in this way. Thanks 30, 30+5, 30+55/2, 30+55/2+5/4... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+5/2+5/4,30+5/2+5/45/8... .. 30, 30+5, 30+5/2, 30+15/4,30+25/8...



Senior Manager
Joined: 02 Apr 2014
Posts: 451
Location: India
GMAT 1: 700 Q50 V34
GPA: 3.5

During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Oct 2017, 22:40
I solved it like this, still time consuming one
A:
day 1 temp: 60/2 , diff from prev: 0 day 2 temp: 70/2 = (140/4) , diff from prev: +10/(2) day 3 temp: 130/4 = (260/8) , diff from prev: 10/ (2 ^ 2) day 4 temp: 270/8 = (540/16) , diff from prev: +10/(2^3) . . and goes on
So the point is diff between (n th) and (n1 th) day is (1) +10/(2^(n1)) => if n is even 10/(2^(n1)) => if n is odd
Now B: day 1 temp: 70/2 , diff from prev: 0 day 2 temp: 60/2 = (120/4) , diff from prev: 10/(2) day 3 temp: 130/4 = (260/8) , diff from prev: +10/ (2 ^ 2) day 4 temp: 250/8 = (500/16) , diff from prev: 10/(2^3) day 5 temp: 510/16 , diff from prev: +10/(2^4) . . and goes on
So the point is diff between (n th) and (n1 th) day is (1) 10/(2^(n1)) => if n is even +10/(2^(n1)) => if n is odd
TA(4) = 30 + (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3) TA(29) = 30 + (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3)  ...................................... (10/2^28)
TB(4) = 35  (10/2) + (10/2^2)  (10/2^3) TB(29) = 35  (10/2) + (10/2^2)  (10/2^3)  ...................................... +(10/2^28)
Let a = (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3), b = (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3)  (10/2^4)...................................... (10/2^28)
Also let us check if a > b, (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3) > (10/2)  (10/2^2) + (10/2^3)  (10/2^4)...................................... (10/2^28) => 0 >  (10/2^4) + (10/2^5)  ....................... (10/2^28) => this is definitely true => so a > b  eqn (2)
so TA(4) = 30 + a, TA(29) = 30 + b TB(4) = 35  a , TB(29) = 35  b
Now let us see the answer choices
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29)
from above, (30 + a)  (35  a) > (30 + b)  (35  b) => rearranging => 2a > 2b => a > b from eqn (2) => a > b So this choice is true
II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) from above, (30 + a) + (35  a) = (30 + b) + (35  b) => rearranging 65 = 65 => which is true. so this choice also true
III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
From above eqn (1), for all n for both the cities, the absolute of diff between two days , 10/2^(n1). So this choice also true
Hence E



Manager
Joined: 21 Jul 2017
Posts: 180
Location: India
Concentration: Social Entrepreneurship, Leadership
GPA: 4
WE: Project Management (Education)

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jun 2018, 09:52
VeritasPrepKarishma is there an easy and quick approach to this question?



Manager
Joined: 16 Aug 2014
Posts: 53

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Jul 2018, 00:58
Is there any short approach for this question KarishmaB Bunuel or chetan2u please explain.



Intern
Joined: 19 Jan 2018
Posts: 1

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
31 Jul 2018, 21:39
Let us try to visualise this problem by assuming two variables in place of real values.
Let us consider TA(1)=a, TA(2)=b and therefore TB(1)=b, TB(2)=a.
Now look at the series: TA(3) = (a/2)+(b/2) TB(3) = (a/2)+(b/2) TA(4) = (a/4)+(3b/4) TB(4) = (3a/4)+(b/4) TA(5) = (3a/8)+(5b/8) TB(5) = (5a/8)+(3b/8)
If you look closely, coefficients of a and b are getting interchanged in both the expressions TA and TB. Also, the interchanged coefficients in TB are (1coefficient of TA)
Therefore, if we assume TA(n) = La+Mb, then TB(n) = (1L)a+(1M)b; L and M are assumed coefficients of a and b respectively in nth expression.
Now, coming to options.
Option (2) = TA(n)+TB(n) = La+Mb+ (1L)a+(1M)b = a+b, which is constant and independent of n Hence option(2) is correct
Option (3): TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
Let us consider TA(n+1) = La+Mb TA(n) = Pa+Qb
Hence, TB(n+1) = (1L)a+(1M)b TB(n) = (1P)a+(1Q)b
Put both the values in expression of Option 3: L.H.S = (LP)a+(MQ)b R.H.S = (PL)a+(QM)b
Hence L.H.S= R.H.S
Option 1:TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) Let us consider TA(n) = La+Mb TB(n) = (1L)a+(1M)b
Therefore, TA(n)  TB(n) = 2(La+Mb)(a+b)= 2TA(n)  (a+b)
Hence, TA(n)  TB(n) is proportional to TA(n) Please note that TA(n) decreased as n increases, therefore TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29).



Intern
Joined: 29 Aug 2017
Posts: 32

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2018, 08:38
I didnt get the solution to this problem in the first attempt. However, on my second attempt, the underlying concept which is tested in the question became crystal clear to me. Evaluate TA and TB upto n=4, then draw out a number line to visualize the concept of averages. 3032.535 Remove 30 02.55 Now the no line is divided into equal parts as we keep on taking the averages: 01.252.53.755 TA4= 3.75 TB4= 1.75 Hence TA4 will keep decreasing towards 2.5 and TB4 will keep increasing towards 2.5 . Therefore the first statement can be proved TA29 <TA4 and TB29 >TB4. Now lets directly take statement 3. since both Ta and TB are moving towards 2.5 in equal amounts. On any day, the difference from the previous day for both A and B will be same ( Please refer the image) and statement 2 is a direct result of statement 3. Kudos the post if you liked my solution. Thanks
Attachments
20180803_215738.jpg [ 3.81 MiB  Viewed 24643 times ]



Intern
Joined: 20 Aug 2017
Posts: 1

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Aug 2018, 18:56
TA(n) > even > odd so ; TA(4) > TA(29) TB(n) > odd > even so ; TB(4) < TB(29)
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) > TA(4)  TA(29) > TB(4)  TB(29) > (+) > () ; True
II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) > I try if n = 3, 4 > TA(n) + TB(n) = 65 ; True
III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3 > ΔTA(n) = ΔTB(n) ; True



Director
Joined: 16 Jan 2019
Posts: 665
Location: India
Concentration: General Management
WE: Sales (Other)

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Apr 2019, 12:01
TeamGMATIFY wrote: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n in two cities A and B are denoted by TA(n) and TB(n) respectively. The average temperature in city A on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city A. The average temperature in city B on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city B. If TA(1) = 30, TA(2) = 35, TB(1) = 35 and TB(2) = 30, which of the following statements must be true?
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
A. II only B. III only C. I and II only D. II and III only E. I, II and III The quickest way to approach this would be graphical. We can see the when n>3, the temperatures TA(n) and TB(n) progress symmetrically about y=32.5 and tends to flatten out I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) As for the first statement, the gap between TA(4) and TB(4) will obviously be much larger than that between TA(29) and TB(29) So I is true II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) Since the projections are symmetrical about y=32.5, the average temperatures of TA(n) and TB(n) for any n>3 will be the same So [TA(4)+TB(4)]/2 = [TA(29)+TB(29)]/2 => TA(4)+TB(4) = TA(29)+TB(29) So II is also true III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3 For any n>3, the rise of TA(n) will be equal to fall of TB(n) and vice versa So, III is also true Answer is (E)Posted from my mobile device
Attachments
IMAG0778.jpg [ 2.11 MiB  Viewed 15367 times ]



Manager
Joined: 31 Jul 2017
Posts: 195
Location: Tajikistan

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
30 May 2019, 00:47
SeregaP wrote: I'd suggust approaching it differently: 1) from the given we can calculate that the 1st is true 2) second, let's look at answer choices: only C and E left, we need to test the 3rd case 3) 66,25/267,5/2=0,75 63,2562,5=0,75 hence 3rd is correct Hi, Could you please clarify what you did with case 2. Your analysis of case 1 and 3 are easy to follow, thank you.



Manager
Joined: 20 Feb 2018
Posts: 59
Location: India

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Jun 2019, 21:37
TeamGMATIFY wrote: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n in two cities A and B are denoted by TA(n) and TB(n) respectively. The average temperature in city A on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city A. The average temperature in city B on any day is the average of the average temperatures of the previous two days in city B. If TA(1) = 30, TA(2) = 35, TB(1) = 35 and TB(2) = 30, which of the following statements must be true?
I. TA(4)  TB(4) > TA(29)  TB(29) II. TA(4) + TB(4) = TA(29) + TB(29) III. TA(n+1)  TA(n) = TB(n+1)  TB(n) for n>3
A. II only B. III only C. I and II only D. II and III only E. I, II and III Hi Bunuel, Could you please advise a better way to solve this question. This question seems to be very tough so when we face these kind of questions in the exam how to approach?



Intern
Joined: 13 Mar 2019
Posts: 27

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Aug 2019, 07:15
The Strategy to above question lies like this 1.Don't solve it (Based on factors like if you are not doing very well ) 2.Solve it  In that case, i think this approach is good 
Since the option includes I in C and E, try to eliminate by calculating I  Following the explanation given by chetan2u follow till end of second point and rearrange the equation as  TB(29)  TB(4) > TA (29) TA (4).
So I is in the answer which eliminates A,B and D Now just check the validity of III.
I checked till 4,5 and realized why the modulus of difference will always be the same. So E it is.
Please press kudos, if I was able to help you. Thank you.



Intern
Joined: 11 Apr 2020
Posts: 5

Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Apr 2020, 06:18
i calculated till TA(5) and TB(5) and then answered correctly but took me good 6.5 mins.... should i be doing that?




Re: During the month of April, the average temperatures on day n
[#permalink]
25 Apr 2020, 06:18




