Ahmed9955 wrote:
karlfurt wrote:
During the past decade, the labor market in France has not been operating according to free market principles, but instead stifling functioning through its various government regulations restricting the hiring and firing of workers
Hi,
BKimball GMATNinjaryanstarr,
can you guys please help me clarify my understanding?
1. Why the sentence is in the perfect tense, although it talks about a specific period- past decade?
2. If it reflects that the market is still not operating according to free-market principles, that is the effect is still present, then can we use 'Since' instead of 'during'?
Hey!
The present perfect tense gets used for an action (or effect) that starts in the past but continues to the present. So while it will still seem to cover a specific time period, the idea is that the time period hasn't yet necessarily come to an end. I know from your second question that this is something you're aware of, so really I think the thing to take away from this is the fact that
during the past ______ is the sort of time marker that often requires present perfect (especially because of the word
past--you'll often see the phrase
over the past _____ paired with present perfect as well).
This leads to the second question: can you use
since? Not exactly, but sort of. You can't say
since the past decade, because unlike
during and
over,
since doesn't pair as well with the word
past. It could have said
Starting a decade ago, but if you were to use
since it would probably have to go something like
Since 2011 or
Since <some action in the past. Basically,
since is idiomatically different from
over or
during, but it of course does still call for the present perfect much of the time it shows up.