It is currently 19 Oct 2017, 17:27

### GMAT Club Daily Prep

#### Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

# Events & Promotions

###### Events & Promotions in June
Open Detailed Calendar

# George is a dog rather than a cat.

Author Message
Senior Manager
Joined: 19 Mar 2008
Posts: 351

Kudos [?]: 68 [0], given: 0

George is a dog rather than a cat. [#permalink]

### Show Tags

29 Jun 2008, 08:23
I learnt form this forum - "George is a dog rather than a cat." is wrong

Someone said "rather than" show preference. Georage does not have a choice between dog and cat. We should use instead of.

Question from OG:

Recently discovered fossil remains strongly suggest that the Australian eff-laying mammals of today are a branch of the main stern of mammalian evolution rather than developing independently from a common ancestor of mammals more than 220 million years ago.

(A) ...
(B) rather than a type that developed independently from
(C) rather than a type whose development was independent of
(D) instead of developing independently from
(E) instead of a development that was independent of

I immediately rule out (A), (B) and (C) because of the dog-cat rule above.

The OA is (B) and the explanation said both "rather than" and "instead of" are ok.

Million thanks.

Kudos [?]: 68 [0], given: 0

Manager
Joined: 23 Jun 2008
Posts: 85

Kudos [?]: 46 [0], given: 24

Location: Australia
Schools: AGSM '22
GMAT Date: 04-01-2014
Re: George is a dog rather than a cat. [#permalink]

### Show Tags

30 Jun 2008, 00:55
I would go for (B) as well...

This question however cannot be immediately reduced to a choice between 'rather than' and 'instead of'. We should first look if the two terms on both side of 'rather than' or 'instead of' are 'parallel' .

X rather than Y

X = a branch of the main stern of mammalian evolution
Y = ?

Comparing "a branch" with "a type" sounds reasonable.

Have a look at this site for comparison of 'rather than' and 'instead of': http://www.englishrules.com/writing/200 ... ead-of.php
_________________

Kudos (+1) if you find this post helpful.

Kudos [?]: 46 [0], given: 24

SVP
Joined: 04 May 2006
Posts: 1881

Kudos [?]: 1399 [0], given: 1

Schools: CBS, Kellogg
Re: George is a dog rather than a cat. [#permalink]

### Show Tags

30 Jun 2008, 01:21
judokan wrote:
I learnt form this forum - "George is a dog rather than a cat." is wrong

Someone said "rather than" show preference. Georage does not have a choice between dog and cat. We should use instead of.

Question from OG:

Recently discovered fossil remains strongly suggest that the Australian eff-laying mammals of today are a branch of the main stern of mammalian evolution rather than developing independently from a common ancestor of mammals more than 220 million years ago.

(A) ...
(B) rather than a type that developed independently from
(C) rather than a type whose development was independent of
(D) instead of developing independently from
(E) instead of a development that was independent of

I immediately rule out (A), (B) and (C) because of the dog-cat rule above.

The OA is (B) and the explanation said both "rather than" and "instead of" are ok.

Million thanks.

You should not be victim of the rule. Better is Be flexible! Because the sentence here relies on the parallelism: "a branch"...."a type" or branch. In addition, you should find out what modifies best "a type", it will be correct option!
_________________

Kudos [?]: 1399 [0], given: 1

Senior Manager
Joined: 19 Mar 2008
Posts: 351

Kudos [?]: 68 [0], given: 0

Re: George is a dog rather than a cat. [#permalink]

### Show Tags

30 Jun 2008, 07:35
thanks all. Now I know it is not a strict rule.

Kudos [?]: 68 [0], given: 0

Re: George is a dog rather than a cat.   [#permalink] 30 Jun 2008, 07:35
Display posts from previous: Sort by