Hi friends
ShankSouljaBoi,
MayankSingh, and
Anki2609I can feel your resentment. These are not official problems, so… you know what I mean.
Note that C is also flawed for the illogical modification of “ice sheet”.
If I say “someone should already fix the blue chair
broken during the fight between two colleagues”, then you understand that the chair did not break itself, but was broken by someone else. So, someone else broke it.
If, instead, I said “…the blue chair
broking during the fight…”, then that would be nonsense because the chair is not breaking itself.
On the other hand, “he has an enormous yacht
extending almost 150 meters” logically implies that the yacht itself extends so many meters.
However, “…has an enormous yacht
extended almost 150 meters” would be illogical because no one is extending his yacht. It itself extends.
Similarly, as an adjective, “stretched” means that someone stretches, whereas “stretching” means that the thing itself stretches. Now let’s take C:
C) Siberia… has a continuous ice sheet
stretched as an impossible barrier…
Since choice C already has a verb “has”, we cannot have another verb without any conjunction. Hence, as you said, “stretched” has to be a modifier / adjective describing “ice sheet”.
As a modifier, though, “stretched” doesn’t make sense because “ice sheet stretched” means that someone else stretches the ice sheet. That’s nonsense. Ice sheet is not from a gum. Rather, ice sheet itself stretches to Canada, and hence we need to use “stretching”, not” stretched”.
A similar construction:
- Only a few feet wide but
spanning a continent, the railroad changed the history. (“spanned” would be wrong)
Here are official problems that test the conception:
https://gmatclub.com/forum/advanced-sc- ... 97101.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/scientists-h ... -9394.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/the-growth-o ... 75679.html After completing all the links, I hope you will be able to discern why C is wrong.
Edit:
Here are some examples from science journals:
- At such times, there was a contiguous ice sheet
stretching from north of Spitsbergen to the Netherlands and from the Norwegian Sea to the Taimyr Peninsula
- An ice sheet
stretching into the distance.
- ...ice sheet
stretching as long as 20 kilometres.
- …except for the presence of a large ice sheet
stretching from Alaska across the Bering Strait to most of eastern Siberia.