Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 24 Jun 2010
Posts: 8

If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 04:32
Question Stats:
48% (00:39) correct 52% (00:49) wrong based on 320 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true? (A) If D, then A. (B) If not B, then not C. (C) If not D, then not A. (D) If D, then E. (E) If not A, then not D. Why is the official answer C ?
For example, choice B could be correct too. If not B then not C.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.




Manager
Joined: 06 Aug 2010
Posts: 190
Location: Boston

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 08:29
utin wrote: TehJay wrote: kimakim wrote: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?
(A) If D, then A. (B) If not B, then not C. (C) If not D, then not A. (D) If D, then E. (E) If not A, then not D.
Why is the official answer C ?
For example, choice B could be correct too. If not B then not C. We're given A > B, B > C, and C > D, and told they're all true. Since they're all true, you can say A > D. Then by the law of contrapositive, ~D > ~A. The answer is (C). (B) isn't correct  this is the inverse of B > C and does not have the same truth table. CAN'T UNDERSTAND STILL!!! Ok, consider a simple example: If I eat dinner now, I will eat dessert later. (A > B) You're told this is a TRUE statement  in other words, eating dinner absolutely, positively, no question about it, 100% results in eating dessert after. There's no possible situation that can exist where I will eat dinner now and then NOT eat dessert later. Now consider the below statements: If don't eat dessert later, I didn't eat dinner now. (contrapositive: ~B > ~A) Since we KNOW FOR A FACT that eating dinner now results in eating dessert later, we can conclude without a doubt that if I don't eat dessert, I most definitely did not eat dinner (because if I had eaten dinner, I would have eaten dessert). This is called the contrapositive and is logically equivalent to the original statement. (This is answer C) If I don't eat dinner now, I won't eat dessert later. (inverse: ~A > ~B) We know for a fact that eating dinner will lead to eating dessert. However, we know absolutely nothing about the result of NOT eating dinner. I didn't say to you that I would ONLY eat dessert if I eat dinner first  only that I would definitely eat it after eating dinner. This statement is not logically equivalent to the original. This is called the inverse, and is answer B. Does this help?




SVP
Status: Three Down.
Joined: 09 Jun 2010
Posts: 1868
Concentration: General Management, Nonprofit

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 12:44
How this in Critical Reasoning?



Manager
Joined: 06 Aug 2010
Posts: 190
Location: Boston

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 17:56
kimakim wrote: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?
(A) If D, then A. (B) If not B, then not C. (C) If not D, then not A. (D) If D, then E. (E) If not A, then not D.
Why is the official answer C ?
For example, choice B could be correct too. If not B then not C. We're given A > B, B > C, and C > D, and told they're all true. Since they're all true, you can say A > D. Then by the law of contrapositive, ~D > ~A. The answer is (C). (B) isn't correct  this is the inverse of B > C and does not have the same truth table.



Manager
Joined: 11 May 2010
Posts: 185

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 22:02
C it is.
Just like what Tej Jay said.



Intern
Joined: 24 Jun 2010
Posts: 8

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 22:24
TehJay wrote: kimakim wrote: We're given A > B, B > C, and C > D, and told they're all true. Since they're all true, you can say A > D. Then by the law of contrapositive, ~D > ~A. The answer is (C).
(B) isn't correct  this is the inverse of B > C and does not have the same truth table.
Yes, the logic is right, if we assume that ALL of the statement should be exist at the same time. But consider if there is only C. Then C>D, and we don;t need A or B to come up with D. Hence if "not D" doesn't imply "not A". On the other hand answer B "If not B then not C" is right, when we assume that all statements can exist independently of each other. So, I am still confused



Manager
Joined: 06 Aug 2010
Posts: 190
Location: Boston

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 02:30
kimakim wrote: TehJay wrote: kimakim wrote: We're given A > B, B > C, and C > D, and told they're all true. Since they're all true, you can say A > D. Then by the law of contrapositive, ~D > ~A. The answer is (C).
(B) isn't correct  this is the inverse of B > C and does not have the same truth table.
Yes, the logic is right, if we assume that ALL of the statement should be exist at the same time. But consider if there is only C. Then C>D, and we don;t need A or B to come up with D. Hence if "not D" doesn't imply "not A". On the other hand answer B "If not B then not C" is right, when we assume that all statements can exist independently of each other. So, I am still confused You're told that all of them are true, so you can't just take them independently and pretend that A doesn't exist. Also, irregardless of whether you're looking at A or not, (B) cannot be correct. This is the logical inverse, which is a fallacy. In logic, when dealing with implications, p > q is equivalent to ~q > ~p, but not equivalent to ~p > ~q (inverse) or q > p (converse). To see this, you can draw up the truth tables: Attachment:
Truth Table.jpg [ 59.45 KiB  Viewed 8360 times ]



Manager
Joined: 27 Mar 2010
Posts: 100

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 07:50
TehJay wrote: kimakim wrote: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true?
(A) If D, then A. (B) If not B, then not C. (C) If not D, then not A. (D) If D, then E. (E) If not A, then not D.
Why is the official answer C ?
For example, choice B could be correct too. If not B then not C. We're given A > B, B > C, and C > D, and told they're all true. Since they're all true, you can say A > D. Then by the law of contrapositive, ~D > ~A. The answer is (C). (B) isn't correct  this is the inverse of B > C and does not have the same truth table. CAN'T UNDERSTAND STILL!!!



Retired Moderator
Joined: 02 Sep 2010
Posts: 774
Location: London

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 08:22
the statement "if A then B" is exactly the mathematical equation (A or not(B)) the three statements together, are three simultaneous equations which solve to give (A or (not(D)) [which logical deduction can tell you] and finally : (A or Not(D)) = (not(not(A)) or not(D)) = (not(D) or not(not(A))) = "if not D then not A"
_________________
Math writeups 1) Algebra101 2) Sequences 3) Set combinatorics 4) 3D geometry
My GMAT story
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



Senior Manager
Joined: 28 Jun 2009
Posts: 408
Location: United States (MA)

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 08:28
Good explanation TehJay. +1 to u!



Intern
Joined: 04 Sep 2010
Posts: 18

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 09:06
Good one TehJay. Kudos for you.



Intern
Joined: 24 Jun 2010
Posts: 8

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 22:35
The explanation with deserts was really helpful. Thank you, Kudos for you TehJay!



Manager
Joined: 06 Aug 2010
Posts: 190
Location: Boston

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Sep 2010, 02:28
kimakim wrote: The explanation with deserts was really helpful. Thank you, Kudos for you TehJay! Glad I could help!



Manager
Joined: 02 Jan 2010
Posts: 116

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Sep 2010, 03:20
chose B..But is this critical reasoning?
_________________
Regards Ganesh Class of 2012 Great Lakes Institute of Management http://greatlakes.edu.in



Manager
Joined: 04 Apr 2009
Posts: 58
Location: United Kingdom
Schools: Cornell

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Sep 2010, 12:14
I learned this today (forgot the original poster but kudos to him). His/her quote went as If A then B , could be rephrased as if Not B then Not A and if B then may be A.
Take the example of: If I am in France, I am in Europe
If I am not in Europe, I am not in France. ( Not B then Not A)
If I am in Europe, I may be in France ( B then may be A).
All other violate this logical rule or add extra information.
So in the given example by reversing all the signs we get.... ~D => ~C ~C => ~B ~B => ~A Thus simply substituting.... ~D => ~A



Manager
Status: Trying.... & desperate for success.
Joined: 17 May 2012
Posts: 68
Location: India
Concentration: Leadership, Entrepreneurship
GPA: 2.92
WE: Analyst (Computer Software)

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Jun 2012, 10:35
Take A, B, C & D as people. 1. A > B: If Alice comes then Bella will come. 2. B > C: If Bella comes then Charlie will come. 3. C > D: If Charlie comes then Dan will come.
Now, per OA, if Dan doesn't come, what impact does it have on Alice?



Manager
Status: mba here i come!
Joined: 07 Aug 2011
Posts: 230

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Jun 2012, 04:54
a>b>c>d so, a>d contrapositive: not d > not a
_________________
press +1 Kudos to appreciate posts Download Valuable Collection of Percentage Questions (PS/DS)



Manager
Joined: 03 May 2015
Posts: 90

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Aug 2015, 16:23
Request you not to write your queries/answers/opinions in question window. It prevents ppl from analysing the question. The whole purpose of GMAT Club forum goes wasted by doing so.



Intern
Joined: 21 Jan 2017
Posts: 32

Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2018, 18:21
kimakim wrote: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the statements above are true, which of the following must also be true? (A) If D, then A. (B) If not B, then not C. (C) If not D, then not A. (D) If D, then E. (E) If not A, then not D. Why is the official answer C ?
For example, choice B could be correct too. If not B then not C. This question requires a good calculation in the background. One thing to remember is "if A then B does not imply the presence of B is only by A". It only implies that "if A is present, then B must be present". Option A is incorrect because D might not necessarily imply that C is present and so B and A. Option B is incorrect as if not B , there are chances of C to be present. Not necessarily true. Option C is correct as if not D then no C.There is no B without C. There is no A without B. Option D is irrelevant Option E is also incorrect as if not A, there can be B. So with C and D. The correct answer is C Thanks, Uma




Re: If A, then B. If B, then C. If C, then D. If all of the &nbs
[#permalink]
03 Aug 2018, 18:21






