Author 
Message 
VP
Joined: 29 Dec 2005
Posts: 1313

vivek123 wrote: Professor wrote: vivek123 wrote: This is my logic> We know that x<0, then x > 0. In other words, x*x = +x^2 so, sqrt(x*x) = sqrt(x^2) = +x or x. but since it is GIVEN that x < 0, answer should be "x".
(For any sqrt, answer is always "+" or "" ; but if some condition is given, we can arrive at whether "+" OR "") but we cannot have x as one of the value of sqrt(x^2) because sqrt(x^2) has only one value that is x. any square under radical sign has only +ve value. How do you say that? For example, "25" is a square of "5" & also of "5". sqrt(25) = +5 or 5. I didn't get your point.
lets see the following examples:
(I) x^2 = 25
(II) x = square root 25
these two are different conditions. so,
from (I), the value of x = + or  5
from (II), the value of x can only be +5.
i believe math experts like honghu and laxi are highly useful here. however, i found the following links to further clearification.
http://www.gmatclub.com/phpbb/viewtopic ... ght=#73232
http://www.jamesbrennan.org/algebra/rad ... _roots.htm
further to my replies, i have seen somewhere in OG that sqrt (x) = +x only. i will post the same when i find.



SVP
Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Posts: 1634

Professor wrote: vivek123 wrote: Professor wrote: vivek123 wrote: This is my logic> We know that x<0, then x > 0. In other words, x*x = +x^2 so, sqrt(x*x) = sqrt(x^2) = +x or x. but since it is GIVEN that x < 0, answer should be "x".
(For any sqrt, answer is always "+" or "" ; but if some condition is given, we can arrive at whether "+" OR "") but we cannot have x as one of the value of sqrt(x^2) because sqrt(x^2) has only one value that is x. any square under radical sign has only +ve value. How do you say that? For example, "25" is a square of "5" & also of "5". sqrt(25) = +5 or 5. I didn't get your point. lets see the following examples: (I) x^2 = 25 (II) x = square root 25
these two are different conditions. so,
from (I), the value of x = + or  5 from (II), the value of x can only be +5. i believe math experts like honghu and laxi are highly useful here. however, i found the following links to further clearification. http://www.gmatclub.com/phpbb/viewtopic ... ght=#73232http://www.jamesbrennan.org/algebra/rad ... _roots.htmfurther to my replies, i have seen somewhere in OG that sqrt (x) = +x only. i will post the same when i find.
What is the difference between (I) & (II)? I guess we arrive on (II) from (i) itself.
I have a very uneasy feeling on this.



VP
Joined: 29 Dec 2005
Posts: 1313

vivek123 wrote: Professor wrote: lets see the following examples: (I) x^2 = 25 (II) x = square root 25
these two are different conditions. so,
from (I), the value of x = + or  5 from (II), the value of x can only be +5. i believe math experts like honghu and laxi are highly useful here. however, i found the following links to further clearification. http://www.gmatclub.com/phpbb/viewtopic ... ght=#73232http://www.jamesbrennan.org/algebra/rad ... _roots.htmfurther to my replies, i have seen somewhere in OG that sqrt (x) = +x only. i will post the same when i find. What is the difference between (I) & (II)? I guess we arrive on (II) from (i) itself. I have a very uneasy feeling on this.
if x^2 = 25, x can be both +ve and ve but if x = square root (25) x can only be 5, not 5. thats it. i told you it is in OG but where? i am trying to find it. once i get it, i will let you know.



Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2006
Posts: 98

Professor wrote: vivek123 wrote: Professor wrote: vivek123 wrote: This is my logic> We know that x<0, then x > 0. In other words, x*x = +x^2 so, sqrt(x*x) = sqrt(x^2) = +x or x. but since it is GIVEN that x < 0, answer should be "x".
(For any sqrt, answer is always "+" or "" ; but if some condition is given, we can arrive at whether "+" OR "") but we cannot have x as one of the value of sqrt(x^2) because sqrt(x^2) has only one value that is x. any square under radical sign has only +ve value. How do you say that? For example, "25" is a square of "5" & also of "5". sqrt(25) = +5 or 5. I didn't get your point. lets see the following examples: (I) x^2 = 25 (II) x = square root 25 these two are different conditions. so, from (I), the value of x = + or  5 from (II), the value of x can only be +5. i believe math experts like honghu and laxi are highly useful here. however, i found the following links to further clearification. http://www.gmatclub.com/phpbb/viewtopic ... ght=#73232http://www.jamesbrennan.org/algebra/rad ... _roots.htmfurther to my replies, i have seen somewhere in OG that sqrt (x) = +x only. i will post the same when i find. i believe u have it mistaken. i'm sure i've seen cases contrary to your explanation for (II)



Intern
Joined: 14 Feb 2006
Posts: 16

Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2006, 04:02
Square root of 25 is 5 as far as Gmat is concerned( it can be 5 of course, but not in Gmat)
The question is x<0 ,sqr (x * l x l= ?
let x be 2
sqr ( 2* l2l)= sqr( 2*2)= sqr(4) = 2
since x is 2 , 2 is x.
That is it.



SVP
Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Posts: 1634

Re: Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2006, 04:51
INSEAD1979 wrote: Square root of 25 is 5 as far as Gmat is concerned( it can be 5 of course, but not in Gmat)
This is something that I really wonder. It sounds like "whether" is preferred over "if" in GMAT
You guys might be correct, I'll really appreciate if you can PLEASE clarify on this part



Director
Joined: 17 Dec 2005
Posts: 536
Location: Germany

Re: Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2006, 09:26
INSEAD1979 wrote: Square root of 25 is 5 as far as Gmat is concerned( it can be 5 of course, but not in Gmat)
You aren't right. The square root of a negative number isn't mathematically defined.
As Professor said:
(I) x^2 = 25
(II) x = square root 25
Statement II says that x has the value 5 and nothing else. Per definition you can take the square root soleily of a positive number or 0. Negative values aren't defined.
The thing why we consider 5 and +5 in statement I is that a number squared always yields a positive value, you know that of course. In two we don't square a number, and if we would we already knew that x is positive since it is sqrt25.
Of course if you consider sqrt (x^2) x can be positive or negative.
Hope that clarifies



SVP
Joined: 05 Apr 2005
Posts: 1649

Re: Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2006, 18:19
allabout wrote: The square root of a negative number isn't mathematically defined.
As Professor said: (I) x^2 = 25 (II) x = square root 25
Statement II says that x has the value 5 and nothing else. Per definition you can take the square root soleily of a positive number or 0. Negative values aren't defined.
The thing why we consider 5 and +5 in statement I is that a number squared always yields a positive value, you know that of course. In two we don't square a number, and if we would we already knew that x is positive since it is sqrt25.
the important concept is: sqrt (x) has only one value i.e. +ve.
x = sqrt (25) = only 5.
x^2 = 25 = 5 or 5.



Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2006
Posts: 98

Re: Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2006, 19:52
HIMALAYA wrote: allabout wrote: The square root of a negative number isn't mathematically defined.
As Professor said: (I) x^2 = 25 (II) x = square root 25
Statement II says that x has the value 5 and nothing else. Per definition you can take the square root soleily of a positive number or 0. Negative values aren't defined.
The thing why we consider 5 and +5 in statement I is that a number squared always yields a positive value, you know that of course. In two we don't square a number, and if we would we already knew that x is positive since it is sqrt25. the important concept is: sqrt (x) has only one value i.e. +ve. x = sqrt (25) = only 5. x^2 = 25 = 5 or 5. i really don't understand the thinking behind this. why would sqrt have only one value?



Intern
Joined: 14 Feb 2006
Posts: 16

sqr root
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Mar 2006, 01:13
I repeat
Square root of 25 in GMAT: 5 ,nothing else.
BUT if you wanna go and check high math books,you can see that it can be 5.
What I dont understand : Why you guys lose time with unimportant stuff. Look at my solution. The answer to the original question is x. And that is it. It has nothing to do with sqrt of 25 = 5 or 5!
p.s: By the way, if is only correct if it is used to convey the meaning of a possibility. Whether is always correct when you talk about alternatives.



Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2006
Posts: 98

Re: sqr root
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Mar 2006, 07:35
INSEAD1979 wrote: I repeat
Square root of 25 in GMAT: 5 ,nothing else.
BUT if you wanna go and check high math books,you can see that it can be 5.
What I dont understand : Why you guys lose time with unimportant stuff. Look at my solution. The answer to the original question is x. And that is it. It has nothing to do with sqrt of 25 = 5 or 5!
p.s: By the way, if is only correct if it is used to convey the meaning of a possibility. Whether is always correct when you talk about alternatives. If it's unimportant you don't have to bother replying the thread.



SVP
Joined: 05 Apr 2005
Posts: 1649

Re: Square roots
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Mar 2006, 11:07
guys, lets be polite and respectful to each other in expressing our views. its one's freedom whether to take the views expressed here.
I also agree with that SQRT (25) = 5. but the reason .
i believe Honghu can explain.



SVP
Joined: 03 Jan 2005
Posts: 2159

Square root of any positive number is a positive number. When we say x^2=a, we know that x=+/sqrt(a). You can see that sqrt(a) itself is positive, but x could be positive sqrt(a) or negative sqrt(a).
Using an example, say x^2=25. We know that x=+/sqrt(25), where sqrt(25)=5.
Hope this helps.
_________________
Keep on asking, and it will be given you;
keep on seeking, and you will find;
keep on knocking, and it will be opened to you.



Director
Joined: 04 Jan 2006
Posts: 902

square root of a positive number is a positive number..
x^2 = 4, x = + or 2
if x = sqrt(4), x = 2
nothing else.
sqrt(4) = 2i
so in this case.. the answer is sqrt(xx)
since x is < 0,so pick x = 4, we have sqrt((4)*4)
==> 4
This is what I learnt at school.. Now I am totally lost if this IS WRONG.
Please explain!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



Senior Manager
Joined: 05 Jan 2006
Posts: 376

Just to End this discussion let me quote from the bible ( OG11, Page 126)
9. Absolute Value
The absolute value of x is denoted x, is defined to be x if x>=0 and â€“x is x<0. Note that sqrt(x^2) denotes that nonnegative square root of x^2 and so sqrt(x^2) = x
Following this answer of the question should be â€“x, as x is already negative and we need positive answer.
I hope this helps.



SVP
Joined: 03 Jan 2005
Posts: 2159

Re: absolute value
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Mar 2006, 00:43
believe2 wrote: if x <0 , then sqrt (x x) equals
1. x 2. 1 3. 1 4. x 5. sqrt(x)
If x<0, the x=x. sqrt(xx)=sqrt((x)^2)=x.
Look at the options, you know that 2 and 3 can be thrown out right away. sqrt(x) is wrong because for GMAT only positive number can be inside a square root. Compare 1 and 4, you want a positive number, which would be x since x is negative.
_________________
Keep on asking, and it will be given you;
keep on seeking, and you will find;
keep on knocking, and it will be opened to you.



SVP
Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Posts: 1634

Re: absolute value
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Mar 2006, 04:37
HongHu wrote: believe2 wrote: if x <0 , then sqrt (x x) equals
1. x 2. 1 3. 1 4. x 5. sqrt(x) If x<0, the x=x. sqrt(xx)=sqrt((x)^2)=x. Look at the options, you know that 2 and 3 can be thrown out right away. sqrt(x) is wrong because for GMAT only positive number can be inside a square root. Compare 1 and 4, you want a positive number, which would be x since x is negative.
I guess this is how I arrived at my answer x
But I was totally confused with what is needed in GMAT etc.
Anyways, thanks Hong
Cheers



VP
Joined: 29 Dec 2005
Posts: 1313

HongHu wrote: Square root of any positive number is a positive number. When we say x^2=a, we know that x=+/sqrt(a). You can see that sqrt(a) itself is positive, but x could be positive sqrt(a) or negative sqrt(a). Using an example, say x^2=25. We know that x=+/sqrt(25), where sqrt(25)=5. Hope this helps.
i just want to be/make clear on why sqrt (25) = 5.
suppose x^2 = 25
x = sqrt (25) or  sqrt (25)
and we are here dealing with only "sqrt (25)".
therefore, sqrt (25) = 5
thank you honghu.



Director
Joined: 04 Jan 2006
Posts: 902

I still dont understand..
isnt x just the positive value of the number x?



VP
Joined: 21 Sep 2003
Posts: 1045
Location: USA

willget800 wrote: I still dont understand..
isnt x just the positive value of the number x?
Yes. But what if the x is ve (say x = 2), then the absolute value of x is 2
x = 2
x = 2 = (2) = x
For more gyan (Hindi word for knowledge) see..
http://www.purplemath.com/modules/absolute.htm
_________________
"To dream anything that you want to dream, that is the beauty of the human mind. To do anything that you want to do, that is the strength of the human will. To trust yourself, to test your limits, that is the courage to succeed."
 Bernard Edmonds







Go to page
Previous
1 2 3
Next
[ 56 posts ]



