If y is a positive integer, what is the units digit of y?

Keyword: y is a positive integer

from 1, we can get 2 values 4 and 6

from 2, we get only one value i.e = 4
Sufficient

I have doubt for statement 2. The question stem says y=integer, and you have to find y's units digit, and the statement 2 says units digit of (y+1)^2 =5. Now what I found is y could be 4,14,24,34.....etc to get the units digit of 5. Also, nowhere in the question it is mentioned anything about the number of digits. So shouldn't this statement be insufficient? And overall the answer should be E? Bunuel pls help.

Thank you Bunuel for pointing out my mistake!

B is correct
A. says it can be 4^ 2 = 16 & 6^2 = 36. Now 2 options are there 4 or 6 , so Not sufficient
B. says y is definitely 4. (4 + 1)^2 = 25 Hence option B

#1
y=4 or 6 insufficieint
#2
y=4 only possible
IMO B
sufficient

Just to add on..
Whenever we are looking at units digit, we should remember the cyclicity rules.
And these rules can be applied in various ways.
For example here, had it been something else other than 5 and 0, ans would be insufficient..
When positive numbers are squared..say z^2
1 can be the units digit when z is 1 or 9
2, 3, 7, 8 will never be a digit.. where does this help you.. if you are looking large numbers and you have to choose perfect square in the options. You can straightforward discard choices with these units digit.
4 can come from 2 and 8
0 and 5 can come only when the digits are 0 and 5 respectively
6 can come from 4 and 6
9 can come from 3 and 7
Thus, statement II would be sufficient only when the units digit shown was 0 and 5.

There are various ways in which the property of units digit can be tested on GMAT.