Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 14 Dec 2016, 00:02
Question Stats:
39% (01:38) correct 61% (01:50) wrong based on 500 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics




eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 25 May 2015, 22:16
Official ExplanationCorrect Answer: CWe are asked to find if a > b Note that in order for the answer to be YES: i) a should be positive, AND ii) a should be greater than the magnitude of b. If we find that a is negative or that a is positive but its magnitude is lesser than that of b, then our answer will be NO. Analysing Statement 1\(2^{ab} > 16\) \(2^{ab} > 2^4\) This means, a – b > 4 That is, a > b However, note that we cannot say for sure if a is positive or not. For example, a = 2, b = 6 also satisfy the inequality a – b > 4. So, Statement 1 alone is not sufficient to answer the question. Analysing Statement 2a  b  < b For all possible values of a and b, ab will be nonnegative (that is, greater than or equal to zero) So, if b > ab (as given in Statement 2), This means b is positive. But in order to answer the question asked, we need to find if a is positive AND its magnitude is greater than that of b. Since we are not able to answer this, St. 2 is clearly not sufficient. Combining the two statementsFrom Statement 1, a > b From Statement 2, b is positive. Since b is positive, b = b . . . (1) Substituting Equation 1 in the inequality from Statement 1: a > b Thus, the two statements together are sufficient to answer the question.
_________________
Ace GMAT quant Articles and Question to reach Q51  Question of the week
Must Read Articles Number Properties – Even Odd  LCM GCD Word Problems – Percentage 1  Percentage 2  Time and Work 1  Time and Work 2  Time, Speed and Distance 1  Time, Speed and Distance 2 Advanced Topics Permutation and Combination 1  Permutation and Combination 2  Permutation and Combination 3  Probability Geometry Triangles 1  Triangles 2  Triangles 3  Common Mistakes in Geometry Algebra Wavy line Practice Questions Number Properties 1  Number Properties 2  Algebra 1  Geometry  Prime Numbers  Absolute value equations  Sets
 '4 out of Top 5' Instructors on gmatclub  70 point improvement guarantee  www.egmat.com




Manager
Joined: 18 Nov 2013
Posts: 82
Concentration: General Management, Technology

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 May 2015, 10:59
Is \(a > b?\) Stmt (1) \(2^{ab} > 16\) ab > 4 a >b+4 clearly not sufficient as we can have (a,b) pair as i) (2,6) and ii) (5,1) in i) a > b = no ; ii) a > b = yes Stmt (2) \(a – b < b\) two cases : when (a – b) > 0 ; a – b = (a  b) when (a – b) < 0 ; ; a – b = (a  b)
case 1 : (a  b) < b a < 2b
case 2 : (a  b) < b a < 0 a < 0 (bit confused here , not sure if we multiply both sides with 1, should the sign flip ? ) but anyways with case 1, 2 we get two different solutions , case 1 ( say a=3, b=2 ; a < 2b true & a > b No ) not sufficient
Note that b is nonnegative as b > some absolute value
combining both 1 & 2 a >b+4 ; b>=0 (note i am just using part of info from Stmt 2)
as b is positive , a is going to be positive too , so a > b+4 ; implies a > b sufficient
Ans C
_________________
_______  Cheers
+1 kudos if you like




Intern
Joined: 16 May 2015
Posts: 35

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
20 May 2015, 11:21
C statement 1, depending on whether a is positive or negative statement 2, tell us that a is negative so both together are sufficient.



Retired Moderator
Joined: 29 Apr 2015
Posts: 863
Location: Switzerland
Concentration: Economics, Finance
WE: Asset Management (Investment Banking)

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
20 May 2015, 13:37
EgmatQuantExpert wrote: Is \(a > b?\) (1) \(2^{ab} > 16\) (2) \(a – b < b\) This is Question 6 of the eGMAT Question Series on Absolute Value.Provide your solution below. Kudos for participation. The Official Answer and Explanation will be posted on 22nd May. Till then, Happy Solving! Best Regards The eGMAT Team Im having troubles with absolute value, im never sure if I considered all the options. Let me try: Statement 1:\(2^{ab} > 16\) can be rewritten as \(2^{ab} > 2^4\). This means ab must be > 4 in order to be true. Therefore a > 4 + b. However if B is negative, e.g. 10 and a is 3, the statement 1 is still true but it changes the answer to the question. Statement 1 = Insufficient. Statement 2Shows us that ab<b and a+b<b because of the absolute values. Change the latter and you arrive at a<0. All this on it's own doesn't help. Insufficient. Combined: a > 4 + b a<0 Plug in: a = 10 and b 15 > Is \(a > b?\) > NO Sufficient if you combine it.
_________________
Saving was yesterday, heat up the gmatclub.forum's sentiment by spending KUDOS!
PS Please send me PM if I do not respond to your question within 24 hours.



eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 May 2015, 04:45
katzzzz wrote: C statement 1, depending on whether a is positive or negative statement 2, tell us that a is negative so both together are sufficient. Dear katzzzzPlease elaborate how you inferred from Statement 2 that a is negative. Best Regards Japinder
_________________
Ace GMAT quant Articles and Question to reach Q51  Question of the week
Must Read Articles Number Properties – Even Odd  LCM GCD Word Problems – Percentage 1  Percentage 2  Time and Work 1  Time and Work 2  Time, Speed and Distance 1  Time, Speed and Distance 2 Advanced Topics Permutation and Combination 1  Permutation and Combination 2  Permutation and Combination 3  Probability Geometry Triangles 1  Triangles 2  Triangles 3  Common Mistakes in Geometry Algebra Wavy line Practice Questions Number Properties 1  Number Properties 2  Algebra 1  Geometry  Prime Numbers  Absolute value equations  Sets
 '4 out of Top 5' Instructors on gmatclub  70 point improvement guarantee  www.egmat.com



eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 May 2015, 05:05
reto wrote: Im having troubles with absolute value, im never sure if I considered all the options. Let me try:
Statement 1: \(2^{ab} > 16\) can be rewritten as \(2^{ab} > 2^4\). This means ab must be > 4 in order to be true. Therefore a > 4 + b. However if B is negative, e.g. 10 and a is 3, the statement 1 is still true but it changes the answer to the question. Statement 1 = Insufficient.
Statement 2 Shows us that ab<b and a+b<b because of the absolute values. Change the latter and you arrive at a<0. All this on it's own doesn't help. Insufficient.
Combined: a > 4 + b a<0
Plug in: a = 10 and b 15 > Is \(a > b?\) > NO
Sufficient if you combine it.
Dear retoThe key to getting comfortable with Absolute Value questions is: 1. Understanding what Absolute Value means in the first place. We should not try to solve questions just by applying formulae without understanding why we are doing what we are doing. For example, in an expression something < c, why do we FLIP the sign of inequality and put a  sign before c when the 'something' is negative? You should feel confident about the logic behind this. 2. When you practice Absolute Value questions, do them stepbystep. DO NOT try to skip steps or do calculations in the air. This leads to mistakes that could have been easily avoided if we were writing each step down. Keeping this in mind, would you want to give the red part in your solution another try? Hope you found this discussion useful! Best Regards Japinder
_________________
Ace GMAT quant Articles and Question to reach Q51  Question of the week
Must Read Articles Number Properties – Even Odd  LCM GCD Word Problems – Percentage 1  Percentage 2  Time and Work 1  Time and Work 2  Time, Speed and Distance 1  Time, Speed and Distance 2 Advanced Topics Permutation and Combination 1  Permutation and Combination 2  Permutation and Combination 3  Probability Geometry Triangles 1  Triangles 2  Triangles 3  Common Mistakes in Geometry Algebra Wavy line Practice Questions Number Properties 1  Number Properties 2  Algebra 1  Geometry  Prime Numbers  Absolute value equations  Sets
 '4 out of Top 5' Instructors on gmatclub  70 point improvement guarantee  www.egmat.com



Manager
Joined: 18 Nov 2013
Posts: 82
Concentration: General Management, Technology

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 May 2015, 10:33
katzzzz wrote: C statement 1, depending on whether a is positive or negative statement 2, tell us that a is negative so both together are sufficient. one correction katzzzz, if statement 2, tells you that a is negative ; then a > b should be sufficient ? absolute value of any xyz is nonnegative (can be 0 or >0 ) BTW, there is one more piece of information in stmt 2 (not much useful in this context , maybe) but good to know \(a–b<b\) it tells us that b is non negative \(b > absolute\)
_________________
_______  Cheers
+1 kudos if you like



Retired Moderator
Joined: 29 Apr 2015
Posts: 863
Location: Switzerland
Concentration: Economics, Finance
WE: Asset Management (Investment Banking)

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 May 2015, 11:03
EgmatQuantExpert wrote: reto wrote: Im having troubles with absolute value, im never sure if I considered all the options. Let me try:
Statement 1: \(2^{ab} > 16\) can be rewritten as \(2^{ab} > 2^4\). This means ab must be > 4 in order to be true. Therefore a > 4 + b. However if B is negative, e.g. 10 and a is 3, the statement 1 is still true but it changes the answer to the question. Statement 1 = Insufficient.
Statement 2 Shows us that ab<b and a+b<b because of the absolute values. Change the latter and you arrive at a<0. All this on it's own doesn't help. Insufficient.
Combined: a > 4 + b a<0
Plug in: a = 10 and b 15 > Is \(a > b?\) > NO
Sufficient if you combine it.
Dear retoThe key to getting comfortable with Absolute Value questions is: 1. Understanding what Absolute Value means in the first place. We should not try to solve questions just by applying formulae without understanding why we are doing what we are doing. For example, in an expression something < c, why do we FLIP the sign of inequality and put a  sign before c when the 'something' is negative? You should feel confident about the logic behind this. 2. When you practice Absolute Value questions, do them stepbystep. DO NOT try to skip steps or do calculations in the air. This leads to mistakes that could have been easily avoided if we were writing each step down. Keeping this in mind, would you want to give the red part in your solution another try? Hope you found this discussion useful! Best Regards Japinder Hello Japinder Thanks for your comments. It's always nice to experience this spirit here on gmatclub.com (people helping each other). Im honest, yesterday I had to reread some theory about absolut value before I could start to solve your questions. Im still in the early stages of my preperation. Okay, the red part:ab<b This is correct, rewrite as a<2b a+b<b Wow that's ugly, for the negative scenario the term needs to look like this with flipped sign: ab > b, which then translates into a>0 All in all Statement 2 tells us:b > ab this means, that b is 0 or positive right? That's what I should have discovered at first! a<2b a>0 Is it that what you were missing in my remarks? If I now combine everything: From Statement 1 a>4+b From Statement 2 a>0 this is useless in combination with St. 1 a<2b this is useless in combination with St. 1 The most important is to see that b is 0 or positive. Combined with statement 1 then it will be sufficient. Any Remarks? Thx
_________________
Saving was yesterday, heat up the gmatclub.forum's sentiment by spending KUDOS!
PS Please send me PM if I do not respond to your question within 24 hours.



Intern
Joined: 02 Jun 2014
Posts: 41

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 May 2015, 23:18
Hii Here is my approach
Statement 1 gives ab>4 a> b+4. Now putting values of b as +2 we get a=6 In this case ans to thw ques is yes Now put b= 5 then a= 1. In this case ans is no.
Statement 1 insufficient
Statement 2 ab<b
We can infer b is positive since b > positive value
ab is always positive
Now on a number line ab means distance between a and b
We inferred b is positive So following 2 cases are possible on number line Case1 <0ab> In this case ans to the ques is No
Case 2 <0ba> In this case ans to the ques is Yes
Hence statement 2 is also insufficient
Combining 1+2 we are left with only the case 2 which I mentioned above on number line as statement 1 gives a>b hence case 1 is eliminated. From case 2 on number line we get a definite Yes
Hence C
Regards Abhishek



Manager
Joined: 16 Jan 2015
Posts: 50
Location: United States
GMAT Date: 05202015
GPA: 3.06
WE: Business Development (Commercial Banking)

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 May 2015, 23:58
Hi EGMAT , First of all , Thanks for this question ; Solving this helped me realizing the concepts of Inequalities Please correct me if I am wrong Is a>b? OPTION A : 2^(a−b)>16 Solving : 2^(ab) > 2^4 so , (ab) > 4= a>b+4 So , this can take multiple values and as such is NOT SUFFICIENT OPTION B : a–b<b case 1 : (a  b) < b a < 2b case 2 : (a  b) < b a < 0 Clearly NOT SUFFICIENT Also we have b as nonnegative as b > some absolute value combining both 1 & 2 a >b+4 ; b>=0 Ans C We can solve using both the options together



Intern
Joined: 02 Jun 2014
Posts: 41

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
23 May 2015, 00:22
Here I guess it does not make much difference but still want to put up that we cannot say b is non negative in statement 2.
B has to be positive I agree ab can be equal to zero when a is equal to b But we are given that b>ab so even if RHS here is zero, b has to be greater than zero which follows b cannot be equal to zero and hence b cannot be inferred as non negative as this will include b=0.



eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
25 May 2015, 22:14
UJs wrote: Is \(a > b?\) Stmt (2) \(a – b < b\) two cases : when (a – b) > 0 ; a – b = (a  b) when (a – b) < 0 ; ; a – b = (a  b)
case 1 : (a  b) < b a < 2b
case 2 : (a  b) < b a < 0 a < 0 (bit confused here , not sure if we multiply both sides with 1, should the sign flip ? ) but anyways with case 1, 2 we get two different solutions , case 1 ( say a=3, b=2 ; a < 2b true & a > b No ) not sufficient
Note that b is nonnegative as b > some absolute value
Dear UJsYes, when we multiply both sides of an inequality with a negative number (like 1 here), the sign of inequality always flips. So, in Case 2, The inequality a < 0 becomes a > 0 . . . (1) Now, what was the defining condition of Case 2? That a  b < 0 (that is why you wrote ab = (ab) in this case) That is, a < b . . . (2) By combining Inequalities 1 and 2, you get that in Case 2, 0 < a < b Since from this inequality, it is clear that b is positive, b = b. So, the answer to the question 'is a > b' will be NO in this case. In Case 1,The defining condition was a  b >= 0 (that is why you wrote ab = ab in Case 1) That is, a > = b . . . (1') Then, by processing the inequality ab < b for this case, you got a < 2b . . . (2') By combining inequalities 1' and 2' we get: b =< a < 2b Again, since b is positive, b = b So, in this case, the answer to the question 'is a > b' will be YES (if a ≠ b) or NO (if a = b). Since we're not able to get a unique YES/NO answer from St. 2, this statement is not sufficient. Hope this helped! Best Regards Japinder
_________________
Ace GMAT quant Articles and Question to reach Q51  Question of the week
Must Read Articles Number Properties – Even Odd  LCM GCD Word Problems – Percentage 1  Percentage 2  Time and Work 1  Time and Work 2  Time, Speed and Distance 1  Time, Speed and Distance 2 Advanced Topics Permutation and Combination 1  Permutation and Combination 2  Permutation and Combination 3  Probability Geometry Triangles 1  Triangles 2  Triangles 3  Common Mistakes in Geometry Algebra Wavy line Practice Questions Number Properties 1  Number Properties 2  Algebra 1  Geometry  Prime Numbers  Absolute value equations  Sets
 '4 out of Top 5' Instructors on gmatclub  70 point improvement guarantee  www.egmat.com



eGMAT Representative
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 1755

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
25 May 2015, 23:08
reto wrote: Hello Japinder
Thanks for your comments. It's always nice to experience this spirit here on gmatclub.com (people helping each other). Im honest, yesterday I had to reread some theory about absolut value before I could start to solve your questions. Im still in the early stages of my preperation.
Okay, the red part:
ab<b This is correct, rewrite as a<2b a+b<b Wow that's ugly, for the negative scenario the term needs to look like this with flipped sign: ab > b, which then translates into a>0
All in all Statement 2 tells us: b > ab this means, that b is 0 or positive right? That's what I should have discovered at first! a<2b a>0
Is it that what you were missing in my remarks? If I now combine everything:
From Statement 1 a>4+b
From Statement 2 a>0 this is useless in combination with St. 1 a<2b this is useless in combination with St. 1 The most important is to see that b is 0 or positive. Combined with statement 1 then it will be sufficient.
Any Remarks? Thx Dear reto2 remarks, both pertaining to Statement 2 analysis: 1. Please look at the highlighted part. The correct statement would be: ab can be positive or 0. Since b > ab, this means b will be strictly greater than 0. 2. When you are considering different cases, always remember to also consider the defining conditions of those cases.Let me explain what I mean: Look at the pink line in the quote above. This is your case 1. What is the defining condition of Case 1? That a  b ≥ 0 (this is why you wrote ab = a  b) So, a ≥ b So, you should combine the inequality you obtained from the pink line with this inequality to get: b ≤ a < 2bThis can also be written as b ≤ a < 2b (b = b since b is positive) Looking at this inequality, you can say that the answer to 'Is a > b' is YES (if a ≠ b) or NO (if a = b) Now, look at the orange line in the quote above. You are absolutely right in the way you processed the negative scenario, but remember to also consider that the defining condition of this case is that a  b < 0, that is, a < b Therefore, the overall inequality that will result in this case will be: 0 < a < b.This can also be written as 0 < a < b (b = b since b is positive) Looking at this inequality, you can say that the answer to 'Is a > b' is NO Since we do not get a unique YES/NO answer from St. 2, it is not sufficient. Look at the blue part in the quote above. I hope that you are now able to see that the 2 cases of St. 2 felt useless in combination with St. 1 only because you did not take the defining conditions of the 2 cases into consideration. Best Regards Japinder
_________________
Ace GMAT quant Articles and Question to reach Q51  Question of the week
Must Read Articles Number Properties – Even Odd  LCM GCD Word Problems – Percentage 1  Percentage 2  Time and Work 1  Time and Work 2  Time, Speed and Distance 1  Time, Speed and Distance 2 Advanced Topics Permutation and Combination 1  Permutation and Combination 2  Permutation and Combination 3  Probability Geometry Triangles 1  Triangles 2  Triangles 3  Common Mistakes in Geometry Algebra Wavy line Practice Questions Number Properties 1  Number Properties 2  Algebra 1  Geometry  Prime Numbers  Absolute value equations  Sets
 '4 out of Top 5' Instructors on gmatclub  70 point improvement guarantee  www.egmat.com



Intern
Joined: 25 Mar 2016
Posts: 42
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, General Management
WE: Other (Other)

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Jul 2016, 10:21
justdoitxxxxx wrote: C statement 1, depending on whether a is positive or negative statement 2, tell us that a is negative so both together are sufficient. If we will put the value of a as 7 and b as 5 then also it satisfies the equation. so how we determine a as negative.



Intern
Joined: 09 Mar 2017
Posts: 38

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Aug 2017, 11:10
EgmatQuantExpert wrote: Official Explanation
Correct Answer: C
We are asked to find if a > b
Note that in order for the answer to be YES:
i) a should be positive, AND ii) a should be greater than the magnitude of b.
If we find that a is negative or that a is positive but its magnitude is lesser than that of b, then our answer will be NO.
Analysing Statement 1 \(2^{ab} > 16\) \(2^{ab} > 2^4\)
This means, a – b > 4 That is, a > b
However, note that we cannot say for sure if a is positive or not. For example, a = 2, b = 6 also satisfy the inequality a – b > 4.
So, Statement 1 alone is not sufficient to answer the question.
Analysing Statement 2
a  b  < b
For all possible values of a and b, ab will be nonnegative (that is, greater than or equal to zero) So, if b > ab (as given in Statement 2), This means b is positive.
But in order to answer the question asked, we need to find if a is positive AND its magnitude is greater than that of b.
Since we are not able to answer this, St. 2 is clearly not sufficient.
Combining the two statements
From Statement 1, a > b From Statement 2, b is positive. Since b is positive, b = b . . . (1)
Substituting Equation 1 in the inequality from Statement 1: a > b
Thus, the two statements together are sufficient to answer the question. How does 2 and 6 satisfy the inequality? 2  (6) =4, 4 is not > 4.



Intern
Joined: 16 Oct 2016
Posts: 12

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Nov 2017, 04:21
Could someone please elaborate why my chain of thoughts is incorrect for statement 2?
I was able to eliminate statement 1 as Insuffcieint. but I marked statement 2 as Sufficient for the following reasons
l a  b l < b
Hence  b < a  b < b Add b to all parts 0 < a < 2b
Hence, A and B are both positives. and 2b > b > a Since B and A are both positives, the statement will always be No, a is not bigger than lbl



Senior Manager
Joined: 06 Jul 2016
Posts: 417
Location: Singapore
Concentration: Strategy, Finance

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Nov 2017, 04:45
EgmatQuantExpert wrote: Is \(a > b?\)
Absolute Value of any number means, the distance of that number from zero without the sign => The value is positive. => b means the value will be positive. a > b => We need to be see if a > 0 and it's also greater than b. Quote: (1) \(2^{ab} > 16\) (2) \(a – b < b\)
1) \(2^{ab}\) > 16 => a > b + 4 b = 1, a = 5 => a > b b = 3, a = 1 => a < b Insufficient. 2) ab < b a  b means the value will be positive. This means that b > 0 but we have no information about a. Insufficient. Quote: Statements 1 & 2 together From S1 > a > b + 4 From S2 > b > 0 => a > b Sufficient. C is the answer.
_________________
Put in the work, and that dream score is yours!



PS Forum Moderator
Joined: 25 Feb 2013
Posts: 1182
Location: India
GPA: 3.82

Re: Is a > b? [#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Nov 2017, 07:16
Harshani wrote: Could someone please elaborate why my chain of thoughts is incorrect for statement 2?
I was able to eliminate statement 1 as Insuffcieint. but I marked statement 2 as Sufficient for the following reasons
l a  b l < b
Hence  b < a  b < b Add b to all parts 0 < a < 2b
Hence, A and B are both positives. and 2b > b > a Since B and A are both positives, the statement will always be No, a is not bigger than lbl hi Harshanican you explain how you arrived at the highlighted part? As per your working you only got 0<a<2b but this statement does not provide relation between a & b so if a=3 and b=2 then 3<4 but 3>2 i.e a<2b but a>b and if a=1 b=2 then a<b<2b










