Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 08 Mar 2011
Posts: 47

Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Mar 2011, 22:52
1
This post was BOOKMARKED
Question Stats:
33% (02:40) correct
67% (02:04) wrong based on 52 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x OPEN DISCUSSION OF THIS QUESTION IS HERE: isapositivex22xaispositiveforallxax21is97302.html
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.



Manager
Joined: 05 Jan 2011
Posts: 177

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Mar 2011, 23:23
asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x x^2  2x + A >0 x^22x +1 +A1>0 (X1)^2 1 >A A>1(X1)^2 (flip the sign) if x is 1/2 A is positive no ... if x is 5 , A>15 so A could be either positive or negative 2 A x^2 +1>0 Ax^2>1 A=1/2 ,x=1 1/2>1 true A=1 X=2 4>1 true.. A could be negative eg (1/2) or positive ... Insufficient.. 1+2, Insufficient E Am I missing sth



Manager
Joined: 18 Oct 2010
Posts: 90

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 01:45
i think the answer should be E instead of A



SVP
Joined: 16 Nov 2010
Posts: 1663
Location: United States (IN)
Concentration: Strategy, Technology

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 02:21
I picked numbers and got E, basically the goal is to prove that the expression is +ve for both ve and +ve values for A. (1) is not sufficient 3^2  2*3 + 1/2 = +ve 3^2  2*3  1/2 = +ve A can be +ve or ve (2) Ax^2 is +ve and 1 is +ve 1/2 * (1/2)^2 + 1 is +ve 1/2 * (1/2)^2 + 1 is +ve So (2) is not sufficient From(1) and (2) (1/2)^2  2 * 1/2  1/2 is +ve (1/2)^2  2 * 1/2 + 1/2 is +ve Answer ie E.
_________________
Formula of Life > Achievement/Potential = k * Happiness (where k is a constant)
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



Manager
Joined: 14 Feb 2011
Posts: 194

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 02:58
asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x We need to answer the question "Is A positive?" Statement 1 says \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all x. Hence A can only take values that make the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) positive for all x. Now, the term \(x^22x\) will be always positive for all x greater than 2. Also, it will always be positive for all x less than zero and it will be zero in case x=0. So for all x greater than or equal to 2 and less than or equal to zero, A can be negative or positive and still the expression can be positive overall depending on magnitude of a and A. So, this does not give us a condition on A. Lets see when x lies between 0 and 2. In such a case, for both x =0 and x=2, the expression \(x^22x\) is zero and hence A needs to be positive. Between x=0 and x=2, the expression remains negative with minimum value of 1 at x=1. Hence, A needs to be greater than +1 to ensure that \(x^22x+A\) is greater than zero for all x when x lies between 0 and 2. So, we have seen that for all x, the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive if and only if A is greater than 1 always. Hence we can answer the question "Is A positive?" in affirmative and hence sufficient. Statement 2 says that \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive for all x. Clearly, \(x^2\) is always positive. So, if A is always positive than \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive. However, \(A*x^2+1\)is always positive also when A=0. Hence, Statement 2) will hold when A is 0 or positive and hence we cannot answer for sure the question "Is A positive?". Hence, insufficient. Answer is A.



Director
Joined: 01 Feb 2011
Posts: 755

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 19:30
1. sufficient, as A can only be +ve to satisfy the given condition. 2. Not sufficient as we could have A>0 or A=0
Answer is A.



Director
Joined: 01 Feb 2011
Posts: 755

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 19:40
I agree with beyondgmatscore. A has to be positive to satisfy the expression for all values of x. beyondgmatscore wrote: asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x We need to answer the question "Is A positive?" Statement 1 says \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all x. Hence A can only take values that make the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) positive for all x. Now, the term \(x^22x\) will be always positive for all x greater than 2. Also, it will always be positive for all x less than zero and it will be zero in case x=0. So for all x greater than or equal to 2 and less than or equal to zero, A can be negative or positive and still the expression can be positive overall depending on magnitude of a and A. So, this does not give us a condition on A. Lets see when x lies between 0 and 2. In such a case, for both x =0 and x=2, the expression \(x^22x\) is zero and hence A needs to be positive. Between x=0 and x=2, the expression remains negative with minimum value of 1 at x=1. Hence, A needs to be greater than +1 to ensure that \(x^22x+A\) is greater than zero for all x when x lies between 0 and 2. So, we have seen that for all x, the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive if and only if A is greater than 1 always. Hence we can answer the question "Is A positive?" in affirmative and hence sufficient. Statement 2 says that \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive for all x. Clearly, \(x^2\) is always positive. So, if A is always positive than \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive. However, \(A*x^2+1\)is always positive also when A=0. Hence, Statement 2) will hold when A is 0 or positive and hence we cannot answer for sure the question "Is A positive?". Hence, insufficient. Answer is A.



Manager
Joined: 05 Jan 2011
Posts: 177

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 20:30
beyondgmatscore wrote: asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x We need to answer the question "Is A positive?" Statement 1 says \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all x. Hence A can only take values that make the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) positive for all x. Now, the term \(x^22x\) will be always positive for all x greater than 2. Also, it will always be positive for all x less than zero and it will be zero in case x=0. So for all x greater than or equal to 2 and less than or equal to zero, A can be negative or positive and still the expression can be positive overall depending on magnitude of a and A. So, this does not give us a condition on A. Lets see when x lies between 0 and 2. In such a case, for both x =0 and x=2, the expression \(x^22x\) is zero and hence A needs to be positive. Between x=0 and x=2, the expression remains negative with minimum value of 1 at x=1. Hence, A needs to be greater than +1 to ensure that \(x^22x+A\) is greater than zero for all x when x lies between 0 and 2. So, we have seen that for all x, the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive if and only if A is greater than 1 always. Hence we can answer the question "Is A positive?" in affirmative and hence sufficient. Statement 2 says that \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive for all x. Clearly, \(x^2\) is always positive. So, if A is always positive than \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive. However, \(A*x^2+1\)is always positive also when A=0. Hence, Statement 2) will hold when A is 0 or positive and hence we cannot answer for sure the question "Is A positive?". Hence, insufficient. Answer is A. Assume x =5 x^2  2x=> 2510 =15 for x^2  2x + A to be positive A can be either positive no or negative no if A= 1 (Statement A is still valid x^2  2x + A>0) if A=1 (Statement A is still valid x^2  2x + A>0) A can be either positive no or negative no ..So How could you say A>0 ....Am I missing something ?



Director
Status: Impossible is not a fact. It's an opinion. It's a dare. Impossible is nothing.
Affiliations: University of Chicago Booth School of Business
Joined: 03 Feb 2011
Posts: 900

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 20:42
I think the designer would have rephrased the question as if I make x=0 then will the "A" stand the test of being positive.
Posted from my mobile device



Manager
Joined: 14 Feb 2011
Posts: 194

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Mar 2011, 22:34
Onell wrote: beyondgmatscore wrote: asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x We need to answer the question "Is A positive?" Statement 1 says \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all x. Hence A can only take values that make the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) positive for all x. Now, the term \(x^22x\) will be always positive for all x greater than 2. Also, it will always be positive for all x less than zero and it will be zero in case x=0. So for all x greater than or equal to 2 and less than or equal to zero, A can be negative or positive and still the expression can be positive overall depending on magnitude of a and A. So, this does not give us a condition on A. Lets see when x lies between 0 and 2. In such a case, for both x =0 and x=2, the expression \(x^22x\) is zero and hence A needs to be positive. Between x=0 and x=2, the expression remains negative with minimum value of 1 at x=1. Hence, A needs to be greater than +1 to ensure that \(x^22x+A\) is greater than zero for all x when x lies between 0 and 2. So, we have seen that for all x, the expression \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive if and only if A is greater than 1 always. Hence we can answer the question "Is A positive?" in affirmative and hence sufficient. Statement 2 says that \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive for all x. Clearly, \(x^2\) is always positive. So, if A is always positive than \(A*x^2+1\) is always positive. However, \(A*x^2+1\)is always positive also when A=0. Hence, Statement 2) will hold when A is 0 or positive and hence we cannot answer for sure the question "Is A positive?". Hence, insufficient. Answer is A. Assume x =5 x^2  2x=> 2510 =15 for x^2  2x + A to be positive A can be either positive no or negative no if A= 1 (Statement A is still valid x^2  2x + A>0) if A=1 (Statement A is still valid x^2  2x + A>0) A can be either positive no or negative no ..So How could you say A>0 ....Am I missing something ? Onell  you are right in deducing that for x=5 A can be either positive or negative. In fact, if you see my response, I have reached a similar conclusion as well. However, we need the value of A for which the expression \(x^2  2x + A\)is positive for ALL x. As I explained earlier, for x between 0 and 2, this can be true only if A is greater than 1. So, \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for ALL x only when A is greater than 1. For some x, it can be positive even when A is negative, but it is positive for ALL x if and only if A is greater than +1. Does this clarify your doubt now?



Intern
Joined: 30 Mar 2011
Posts: 8

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Apr 2011, 09:57
The first statement can be solved with some calculus. Differentiating x^2  2x + A yields 2x  2. If we assume 2x  2 = 0 and x = 1, we know that the quadratic curve is at its minimum (lowest value possible) when x = 1.
Therefore, substituting x = 1 into x^2  2x + A, we get 1 + A. This is the lowest value possible and since 1 + A > 0 (always positive), A > 1 and always positive.
So it's sufficient.
I'm inclined to say the second statement is true as well. If A < 0, the quadratic curve will have a maximum, which means it will definitely go negative, hence contradicting the statement ("(A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x "). The only way to make it always positive is if A > 0.
So I personally think the answer should be D.
I don't have any software to plot graphs right now, but if anyone fancies plotting quadratic graphs they might be able to show this.



Manager
Joined: 14 Feb 2011
Posts: 194

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Apr 2011, 22:54
1
This post received KUDOS
oster wrote: The first statement can be solved with some calculus. Differentiating x^2  2x + A yields 2x  2. If we assume 2x  2 = 0 and x = 1, we know that the quadratic curve is at its minimum (lowest value possible) when x = 1.
Therefore, substituting x = 1 into x^2  2x + A, we get 1 + A. This is the lowest value possible and since 1 + A > 0 (always positive), A > 1 and always positive.
So it's sufficient.
I'm inclined to say the second statement is true as well. If A < 0, the quadratic curve will have a maximum, which means it will definitely go negative, hence contradicting the statement ("(A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x "). The only way to make it always positive is if A > 0.
So I personally think the answer should be D.
I don't have any software to plot graphs right now, but if anyone fancies plotting quadratic graphs they might be able to show this. Your reasoning for the second statement is incorrect. The only way to make it always positive is if A > 0 OR A = 0. As, at A=0, the value of expression is 1  always positive. So, A can be zero or positive and hence insufficient.



Intern
Joined: 30 Mar 2011
Posts: 8

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Apr 2011, 02:52
beyondgmatscore wrote: Your reasoning for the second statement is incorrect. The only way to make it always positive is if A > 0 OR A = 0. As, at A=0, the value of expression is 1  always positive. So, A can be zero or positive and hence insufficient.
Ah yes, I overlooked that. Thanks!



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 1179

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Apr 2011, 07:28
asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x I've posted about this question a couple of times. Many people solve this backwards and arrive at the wrong answer (those test takers relying on 'number picking' strategies almost always answer this question incorrectly). The important word in each of the two statements is 'all'. In Statement 1, x^2  2x + A is positive not just for some value of x; it must be positive for EVERY value of x. In particular, it's positive when x=0, so substituting x=0, we learn instantly that A is positive and Statement 1 is sufficient. Statement 2 is also almost sufficient. It is only insufficient because of a technicality: it's possible that A=0. So the answer is A.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Toronto
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



Manager
Joined: 27 Aug 2014
Posts: 102
Concentration: Finance, Strategy
GPA: 3.9
WE: Analyst (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Nov 2014, 15:22
asmit123 wrote: Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + 1 is +ve for all x from statement 1: \(x^22x+A > 0\), adding and subtracting 1,\(x^22x+1+A1 > 0\), this reduces to \((x1)^2+A1 > 0\), the least value of \((x1)^2\) is 0, substitute this value in the expression to get the least value of A. 0 + A 1 > , this implies A>1 so sufficient From statement 2: A can take any value for the expression to be positive, NSF So answer is A.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 39673

Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) + [#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Nov 2014, 03:08




Re: Is A positive? 1. x^2  2x + A is +ve for all x 2. (A*x^2) +
[#permalink]
27 Nov 2014, 03:08








Similar topics 
Author 
Replies 
Last post 
Similar Topics:


15


Is 1+x+x^2+x^3+....+x^10 positive?

gmatpapa 
15 
18 Jun 2016, 12:30 

106


Is A positive? x^22x+A is positive for all x Ax^2+1 is

noboru 
62 
11 Dec 2016, 07:43 

38


In the sequence of positive numbers x1, x2, x3, ..., what

testprep2010 
28 
16 Jul 2016, 01:44 

1


Whether x and y both positive? (1) 2x  2y =1 (2) x/y > 1

ahirjoy 
8 
23 Aug 2013, 03:05 

2


In the sequence of positive numbers x_1 , x_2 , x_3 ,...

Vyacheslav 
4 
21 Mar 2011, 20:00 



