It has been said that all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it

Hello mohnish104

I'm glad to explain. This question is about parallelism.

It has been said that all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to lie with it in a slightly elevated position

(A) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to
Wrong. Parallelism problem: leave it,.... ice it, and to lie with it...

(B) all one can do for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone to heal itself, to ice it, and
Wrong. Parallelism problem: to leave it, .....to ice it, .....and lie with it..

(C) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, and then ice it and
Wrong. Meaning problem: leave it.... and then ice it and lie with it...
Secondly, "one" is not clear.

(D) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and
Correct. Parallel structure: leave it...., ice it, and lie with it.....

(E) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone while it heals itself, to ice it, and[/quote]
Wrong. Parallelism problem: to leave it..........., to ice it, and lie with it..........

Hope it helps.

Wrong. Parallelism problem: to leave it..........., to ice it, and lie with it..........

Hope it helps.[/quote]

D makes no sense because it says " the only thing that can be done" and then actually not one but three things are listed...hionestly all answers are bad...questions like this make me wonder why I practice with sources other than the OG

You are right. I sometime am very unsure when not practicing OG questions.

However, I chose D over C because I thnk that the added "then" in C is more of a problem than the "the only thing one can do". But I'm not satisfied with the question either.

The difference between "all one can do" and "the only that can be done" is problematic. I prefer the former, by a long shot, even though the "OA" (I put it in quotes, because it has no OFFICIAL source.) for the first question here chooses the latter. I'm not sure if it's a straight issue, but I think it's quite unclear who is doing the action in that answer.

It has been said that all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to lie with it in a slightly elevated position.

(A) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to
PROBLEM: The list starts after the word "is". Then we get a list, meaning we need parallelism. "leave" and "ice" are parallel. But "to lie" is not.

(B) all one can do for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone to heal itself, to ice it, and
PROBLEM: This time, we lost the "to" on the last item".

(C) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, and then ice it and
PROBLEM: This doesn't make sense. If you the "then" in, it sounds like you're icing it after leaving it alone while it heals. But that's illogical.

(D) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and
ANSWER: Leave, ice, and lie are all parallel. However, I still hold "the only thing...is leave, ice..., and elevate..." is ridiculous on two separate levels. First, how is that a thing? Secondly, how is that ONE thing?

(E) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone while it heals itself, to ice it, and
PROBLEM: We lost our last "to" again.

It has been said that all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to lie with it in a slightly elevated position

(A) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to
(B) all one can do for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone to heal itself, to ice it, and
(C) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, and then ice it and
(D) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and
(E) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone while it heals itself, to ice it, and

this is pure parallelism
A X,Y and to Z incorrect
B to X,to Y and Z incorrect
C then ice it not correct as per the meaning of sentence
D X,Y and Z correct
E to X,to Y and Z incorrect

My usual disclaimer: HUGE amounts of resources are poured into every single official GMAT question, and even the best test-prep companies can't compete. And there are clearly some issues with this question.

I'm cool with the parallelism part of the question: it's easy enough to discard (A), (B), and (E) because of clearly botched parallelism, as pqhai indicated.

Beyond that... well, I'm really not convinced by (C) or (D), to be honest. You're onto something, RMD007: "the only thing is"... three different things? Nope, that makes no real sense. "The only things ARE..." would be OK, I guess.

And the meaning of the sentence is also pretty murky. It doesn't make sense to me to say that all you can do for a sprained ankle is "leave it alone" -- but then we're also going to ice it and lie with it in an elevated position? That's pretty contradictory.

So the parallelism lesson here is reasonable enough, but I don't think it's worth expending much effort distinguishing between (C) and (D).
_________________

I thought that C changes the meaning, was I wrong? As I understand, 'Then' in C implies some order of actions (we first do this, and then the other two things) while there is no such order in original sentence?

Yeah, I think you're onto something there, kivalo. I think you could make a decent argument for (C) on that basis -- though I still think it's weird to say that you'd "leave it alone while it heals itself", and THEN ice it... presumably after it has already healed itself?

Actual GMAT questions really don't leave this much room for debate. So again, I wouldn't waste too much energy debating between (C) and (D). As long as you're clear about the parallelism issue, you're all good.
_________________

Waw... Bunuel can you please explain the difference between this question and another one very similar "It is an oversimplified view of cattle raising to say that all one has to do with cattle is leave them alone while they feed themselves, corral them, and to drive them to market when the time is ripe."

I'm getting so much confused...
Many thanks in advance

Posted from my mobile device

A lacks parallelism - leave it, ice it and to lie
B - same issue as A
C- changes the meaning by changing the things to do with a sprained ankle to the sequence of things to do.
D - no errors
E - lacks parallelism


It has been said that all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to lie with it in a slightly elevated position

(A) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and to
(B) all one can do for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone to heal itself, to ice it, and
(C) all one can do for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, and then ice it and
(D) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is leave it alone while it heals itself, ice it, and
(E) the only thing that can be done for a sprained ankle is to leave it alone while it heals itself, to ice it, and

Posted from my mobile device

Your answer gave me much needed solace that I am not the only one thinking on the same line as you mentioned it out.

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________