egmat wrote:
rishabhdxt wrote:
Experts pls comment
Hello
rishabhdxt,
You have presented a very detailed analysis of this official question. Great job there.
rishabhdxt wrote:
(C) Katharine Graham became publisher of The Washington Post in 1963, and only after that did it move into the first rank of American newspapers, having won high praise under her command
Subject : It is singular & Verb : move is plural
Incorrect
I am afraid your reason to reject this answer choice is not correct. Please note the verb for the subject it is
did move. So there is no SV number agreement error in this choice.
This choice is incorrect because of the usage of the modifier
having won high praise. The modifier having verb-ed has a very specific usage. In modifying a clause, it presents the action done prior to the modified action in the main clause. For example:
1. Having finished his breakfast, Joe went to play tennis.
In the above-mentioned sentence, Joe first finished his breakfast and then went to play tennis. The sentence will convey the same meaning if we change the place of the having verb-ed modifier.
2. Joe went to play tennis, having finished his breakfast.
Both the sentences 1. and 2. convey the same meaning.
With the usage of
having won high praise after the action
did move,
Choice C suggests that The Washington Post first won the praise and then moved to the first rank. This certainly is not the intended meaning.
Thanks.
Shraddha
Hi
egmat - could you elaborate on the "Yellow highlight" ?
I dont think it is the case that case (c) implies that
The Washington Post first won the praise and then moved to the first rank.
In the phrase "comma + having", is
having a present participle ?
Example -
John left the house, eating breakfast
John left the house, having breakfast
Here "Eating breakfast" | "having breakfast" are both taking place AT THE SAME TIME AS John left the house per my understanding.
Thoughts ?
addedumdum #2 - i think "Having killed" is NOT A PRESENT participle but a completely different grammar term, not used on the GMAT (perfect participle)